Skip to Content

Doc Season 1 Episode 8 Review: Man Plans

Critic's Rating: 4.1 / 5.0
4.1

Oh, Doc’s love triangle is about to get messier. You can feel it in the air.

We had a delightful hour as Doc Season 1 Episode 8 makes some headway with developments in Amy’s life.

Our girl passed her boards and is officially a doctor (again)! She and Richard smoothed things over, and her secret relationship with Jake is out in the open.

(Courtesy of FOX)

When an hour delivers many positive outcomes, there’s a sense of foreboding that something else is approaching.

That’s the feeling I had in the pit of my stomach as the hour concluded, and we only had two installments remaining in the first season.

I’ll make my plea again for FOX to renew the show. It’s become comfort food for the soul with the perfect amount of drama.

I want to spend more time with these characters because, as enjoyable as the series is, we still know little about most of them.

Doc does a lot with this short season. I’d even argue they burn through storylines too quickly for the sake of wrapping them up in a tight season.

(Courtesy of FOX)

But ideally, in the renewal I’m manifesting, we’d get a slightly bigger season order so the series can flesh out its stories and characters.

During this hour, we learn a lot about Amy and Richard in the past and present, and it’s fascinating.

We heard about the two’s friendship, but “Man Plans” goes the extra step of showing bits of that bond, too.

Thus far, Doc has framed Richard as the antagonist. He made a fatal error, covered it up, and tried to undermine Amy at every turn to keep his actions a secret.

But just as Doc Season 1 Episode 7 adds context to Miller so he doesn’t serve as a one-dimensional “villain,” this hour builds on that to reveal his and Amy’s journey as friends.

(Courtesy of FOX)

It was surprising to see he was with her on that day when Michael told her about her son’s death.

One minute, these two were chatting it up, suggesting they were long-time friends who welcomed the idea of their pre-teen children potentially falling in love down the road, and the next, Amy heard the worst news in her life.

Miller genuinely appeared concerned about Amy and wanted to be a friend. However, as we’ve learned, she built walls around her heart and started shutting him and everyone else out.

In the moment, it felt like he should have given her grace and not approached her about her brush-off earlier.

However, the colder and more distant Amy became, the more it impacted their friendship, and one could see how hurt Richard was and how their bond progressively worsened.

(Courtesy of FOX)

Pre-amnesiac Amy was not easy to be around, and it’s refreshing that the series isn’t afraid to explore that during the flashbacks.

Doc doesn’t make apologies for Amy with the scathing flashbacks. And it’s unflinching boldness in the face of allowing a complex woman to be messy, complex, and even unlikable, which is admirable and a rarity.

It gives us the space to empathize with many of the other characters every bit as much as Amy, even some of those we may not care for on the surface.

Amy was not kind to Richard in the aftermath, and the chasm between them expanded when she poured her energy into becoming chief to distract herself from the pain of losing her child.

She also threw her weight around in the position, staying on Miller hard. It’s apparent to us now that his son’s diagnosis profoundly affected him on the job.

(FOX)

It’s an interesting juxtaposition to show his encouragement to Amy to take time when she faced a family crisis and his failure to do the same. The contrast in how one thrived, and the other declined due to that choice further highlights their skillset and fuels the tension more.

Amy’s greatness never takes a hit, whereas Richard never quite measures up. It’s not even an indictment of him as a doctor; it’s just the truth.

Richard is human enough and has the ego to take that to heart and struggle.

Working together on Francine’s case was the perfect way to move them toward a friendship again, which will make the Dixon conflict more complicated than ever.

(Courtesy of FOX)

Francine’s case was heartbreaking. It’ll be one of the more memorable medical cases of the season, and the emotional stakes were high as well.

Her pre-frontal cortex dementia is a devastating diagnosis, leaving her precious little time alive and of sound mind and the newfound awareness that her father wasn’t a horrible man after all, but he suffered the same.

The case aligned well with Amy and Richard, with Amy’s TBI, her behavior disrupting her relationship with Richard, and the theme of making amends, second chances, and forgiveness.

But no matter what she and Richard have placed behind him, his glowing recommendation, and his acceptance of her relationship, the Dixon situation lingers, and the consequences are inescapable.

(Courtesy of FOX)

There’s no diverting this train now that Julie is in the know. By now, if Richard should want to face the music.

Jake’s case also aligned well with his personal life. The rom-com element was fun, and Liz’s assistance was endearing and amusing.

I can’t fault her for falling for the Hallmark display during the case. It was ripe for rom-com comparisons.

It was plain as day that Wes’ best friend was in love with him while he was fawning over Olivia. Everyone could’ve predicted that she was the person who wrote the poem about him a decade ago, not the aloof popular girl.

Jake’s disinterest and, at times, annoyance with the whole thing were a bit bizarre, but it was probably because it hit too close to home.

(Courtesy of FOX)

Ironically, Jake still didn’t realize that his patient’s love triangle reflected his life twice over. He’s in two different love triangles without even knowing it.

On the one hand, the situation reminded him of himself, Amy, and Michael and what they were doing, especially after Michael called him to the office.

However, all the advice he gives to Wes’ friend is trippy when he doesn’t realize how similar he is to Wes.

He mentioned how friendship is often the foundation of a great love story, which proved reassuring to a woman who acknowledged how complicated it is to decipher romance and move to that next step out of a friendship.

However, his heart eyes for Amy have always blinded him from seeing Sonya has feelings for him. The previous hour put Sonya’s feelings for Jake into perspective once we learned what she endured.

(Courtesy of FOX)

Jake is a genuinely great guy. He can’t get any better. From all we know about him, he’s practically perfect.

He probably makes Sonya feel safe.

He does the same for Amy as she navigates her life again despite not remembering it. It’s what she said when she confronted Michael and opened up to Richard.

Jake is this port in the storm for Amy, and, of course, it’s beautiful, especially for those who love the pairing.

On the flip side, it’s why I have reservations about the state of their relationship right now. Amy doesn’t actually remember her five-month-long relationship with Jake, only that they had one then and that he’s comforting her now.

(Courtesy of FOX)

They’re not the same, and it’s an unusual circumstance that has Jake all-in on his romance as if he’s picking back up where they left off, and Amy clinging to something that feels comfortable because that’s how it was before.

Amy is trying to cling to anything solid from her life before, and the most consistent thing she has is her friendship with Gina (which she has at least had for many years) and Jake.

Jake probably knows it deep down, which is one of many reasons he struggled so much during this installment. I appreciated his attempt to do the noble thing by taking a break and waiting until Amy secured status again, etc.

It was a swoon-worthy, noble, romantic gesture, and again, Jake is just … the perfect guy. In a sea of flawed characters, he’s as ideal as it gets. It contrasted well with Michael’s actions and further cemented the stark difference in Amy’s dynamics with both.

But as common as the sentiment is, I can’t bring myself to judge Michael harshly either. Two things can be true at once. He was visibly jealous and hurt, especially when he saw Amy and Jake together. He realized how serious Amy’s feelings were for Jake and that she was willing to risk it all for him.

(FOX)

However, his position regarding his concerns about Amy’s career was valid. He probably should’ve called both Jake and Amy to his office instead of only speaking to Jake.

Everything he expressed, even when you removed the bias in his feelings, was on point.

We’ve learned that Michael has spent the past eight years frequently standing between Amy and the board. Professionally, he’s frequently put his neck on the line for her, and she didn’t make things easy for him.

If he’s been slaying dragons in the board room to the point that it impacts his own standing, Amy and Jake’s continuing in secret is less than ideal.

If Richard and Amy had not worked on that case together and settled things between them, Richard would have used that against Amy in his attempts to thwart her.

(Courtesy of FOX)

The board would also jump at the chance to ruin her when she was a problem for them before and after her amnesia. She hadn’t passed her board recertification yet, either.

From Michael’s perspective, it wasn’t the right time to do any of that, even if he had separated his feelings about Amy and Jake dating. His frustrations were valid, and Jake knew he couldn’t argue against it either.

Of course, now that things worked in their favor, Michael has to deal with the unspoken things; the relationship isn’t an issue professionally, but he’s hurting from it personally.

He’s not in the position, given he’s married and has a child on the way, but Michael never stopped loving Amy, even when they fell apart. Seeing her return to the woman he always knew before has made it more complicated for him.

Now, his Amy is in love with someone else. Their final scene together screams that there is unfinished business there.

Amy oversteps
(Courtesy of FOX)

Oh, the drama, my friends!

Over to you, Doc Fanatics.

Are you happy Amy and Jake are out in the open now?

Do you think Amy and Jake jumped back into things too fast?

Is there still something there with Amy and Michael?

Which case did you enjoy the most? Are you happy Amy passed her board? Sound off below.

Watch Doc Online

Lila

Wednesday 26th of February 2025

It was renewed! For 22 episodes!!

You’re easier on Richard than I am. What I saw was a jealous incompetent man. They were friends as long as she didn’t want chief. He didn’t like that she called him out when he screwed up. He didn’t like that she went for chief against him and got it because she was more qualified and a better doctor. The personality change caused friction, but it didn’t seem to be the core of the problem. And now that she’s said she doesn’t want chief, doesn’t remember his big screwup and isn’t a threat, he’s nice and understanding. I thought it was more of the same- he doesn’t measure up and reacts badly when things go wrong.

Worse, it seemed all he had to do was admit he made a mistake at the time and let malpractice handle it. The problem is the coverup and is entirely self inflicted by his ego.

Jake was romantic and great again and left me with mixed feelings again. I get them more now. With everyone else, even Katie, she has to be new, good Amy and earn back the relationship. He just loves her. I can see why she doesn’t want to let that go. It makes things really unbalanced though.

I want more on Jake and Gina. I think everyone else has had a good amount of time dedicated to them. It’s weird that the two closest to Amy are the last to get that time.

Michael was way out of line and throwing stuff at her she can’t handle. Mainly because he’s married, and she respects that.

Jasmine Blu

Wednesday 5th of March 2025

@Lila, LOL! Hey, you aren't alone in that. It's pretty much the entire fandom and most viewers. I think when I try to separate my feelings about the characters I tend to focus on the fact that none of the other characters are getting the same development and layers of Amy. She's full fleshed out, so it's essentially designed to make us love her and loathe anything working against her. I get it, but it needs to be balanced a bit more, you know? Like, it's hard to have very strong feelings about many of the other characters because the only things we know about them are related to Amy. It's why even Richard and Sonya's single episodes of fleshing out made them somewhat sympathetic but people still struggle to like them.

As much as I love Amy, and I love her. I really hope next season, they'll have the time to flesh out the ensemble portion of the show.

But yeah. Richard is Richard. Until he owns up to what he did, he's still not a good guy even with the background. And you're right, he has glimpses of the friendship they shared before, but all of that hinges on her not remembering. If she does, he'll freak out, and villain mode activated again.

Agree about Jake. And maybe that's why my attachment to their relationship is on the same level as my issues with the other characters... I just need more to feel something. He doesn't even have the history working to his advantage IMO. Five months isn't much, and until the day of her accident and they did the "I Love Yous" it felt like a fling.

And that's the thing, everything we have with Jake essentially goes back to Amy. I find it interesting because that's so often done and equally as frustrating for me when it's a male lead and the woman is just... there to be a love interest. So seeing it reversed, it still bugs me.

But fortunately, we get some more little nuggets coming up. I'm definitely really excited about the season two renewal, though. With 22 episodes, they'll really be able to dive in with all of these characters, and I desperately want that. I love this entire cast.

Michael has his own issues. It's just so painfully clear that he never dealt with anything. Amy threw herself into work and closing herself off, including her own family. Michael threw himself into family and trying to recapture that in some way. But she avoided grief and he never allowed himself to do it, and it screwed them both up. I'm fascinated by how they're two sides of a coin when it comes to that.

It's all so deliciously messy.

Lila

Tuesday 4th of March 2025

@Jasmine Blu, I do tend to be one who goes easier on Amy than some of the other characters. I like her more, and I find her more interesting.

I don’t disagree with what you said about Richard. I feel like their friendship can only exist when they’re not competing because he feels so inferior. But that’s not her fault. I just don’t sympathize with him much so far. I feel the same way about Sonya. I get it; I’m just not feeling it. I feel like Richard is putting his issues off on her because she wasn’t nice and ignoring his part in it. I still feel like their friendship is coming back only because she’s no longer a threat to him. We’ve seen how he acts when he’s threatened by her and that wasn’t so nice, now or in flashback.

I can sympathize with Richard feeling like she took something from him. I’m not convinced being chief even really mattered to her which would just rub it in. I think her ambition was just an outlet and new purpose she needed. She put it all at risk to sleep with a subordinate too easily for me to believe it was really her ultimate, worked for goal. But that might change with more information. Maybe her attraction to Jake was just too strong.

I read somewhere that Amy just loves that Jake loves her and that hits for me. I agree she’s getting a little lost in the relationship. She’s putting everything into moving on, but she’s not dealing. I’d like to see her take more space. And Jake desperately needs depth. He got a little more character in the dinner flashback and his enjoyment of the bitchy patient’s attitude, but that’s not depth and still related to Amy. The infidelity reveal (last ep?) felt thrown in. He needs actual focus. Their relationship needs some time, flashback and current. Basically everything Jake needs time.

I like Michael okay. I think this ep he thought he was just protecting her again, like he always has. Until he deals a little though, they can’t have a sincere relationship. And as long as he keeps crossing lines while she’s running the other way from his marriage, he’s not going to get what he’s looking for from her.

Jasmine Blu

Thursday 27th of February 2025

Yup, we had a whole writeup about it. I'm excited about this news! Full season order shocked me, too!

It's not that I'm easier on Richard, it's that I've noticed that viewers are really easy on Amy no matter what we see and what she's done, and I appreciate that in the show, we see more layers to the situation. They don't need us to have a binary approach with the characters where we have to pick a side and believe everything is black and white.

I think Richard is the inferior doctor. Amy is brilliant, and she seems to have a natural gift for the field, but Richard is not. He pales in comparasion to her, and we've seen that with how he approaches many cases, even in the present.

But I think he liked the idea of being chief. It gives you authority, affluence, it's a great title, but it also one that doesn't involve as much practicing, which he probably felt suited him. He's someone who would've spent his career wanting to get that title, whereas Amy is clearly someone who doesn't give a darn about titles, authority, or anything, she's all in for the medicine and praticing. It's truly her calling.

So from Richard's perspective, he knows he's the inferior doctor, but this was his one thing, and when someone like Amy who can do everything hones in on the one thing you may have going for you, it's demoralizing. Because she could take it ease, like taking candy from a baby. His issue was why would his friend who knew how badly he wanted this up and decide she'd just go for it, when she's indifferent to the idea at best. I don't particularly love Richard, but I can sympathize with that position.

Yeah, he doesn't measure up. It's definitely his biggest insecurity, which is probably why in the premiere he needed that resassurance and uplifting from his wife. But yeah, all he had to do was cop to what happened. He couldn't do it, though. But he's an insecure man who already feels inferior, so it wasn't suprising that he didn't.

Yeah, I just always have mixed feelings about Jake. On paper, he's great, perfect, "too perfect." He says all the right things. Behaves all the right ways. He's a Boy Scout. It's sweet, makes him likable, but it's also boring, mainly because we don't know anything about him other than he loves Amy. I just ... need more than that. I can't fully enjoy their relationship because of that imbalance and how one-dimensional Jake is at the moment.

I do get the comfort in Jake for Amy and not wanting to let that go at all. On the flip side, I would love to see Amy trying to navigate this identity crisis she's experiencing without immediate romance. We also haven't gotten to see what her grieving her son looks like NOW. It's like she hasn't really processed that. She's disappearing into medicine again, but also this thing with Jake. It feels doomed because there's so much unresolved stuff, you know?

I agree with you. I want so much more of Jake and Gina. I really want to see who they are outside of being Amy's support system.

Michael is such a messy character, but I do like him. I find his situation compelling, and I'm fascinated by the reactions to him.

Cindy

Wednesday 26th of February 2025

This show is just excellent. Really hope it gets renewed.

Wow Richard! I kept thinking, please stay good and wow that letter of recommendation. I’m torn now given the autopsy results have been found out. What will this mean for their “mending friendship.”

I don’t want to carry on about the Amy and Jake of it all. I’ll just say they are cute together and he seems perfect and says all the right things but I just don’t know. However I enjoy them together.

Now, Michael and that final scene at Amy’s door, “I’ll let you go.” My heart. They cannot be over.

Cindy

Thursday 27th of February 2025

@Jasmine Blu, haha nothing wrong with wishful thinking. I’m right there with you. I think it’s also clear with the flashbacks that Amy was imperfect.

Yes, I had the same feeling with Amy’s I love you too in that first episode.

I agree with you about Michael. His points were valid. He may not be the right person to comment on her love life, but he was just looking out for her as always. I think even Jake got his point. I don’t know, that’s just how I read it. Sans the jealousy, of course.

Jasmine Blu

Thursday 27th of February 2025

@Cindy, I'm curious about what's next for Richard too, but he also seemed more resigned to how he screwed up before, so maybe he'll be graceful about it when the news comes out and he has to take accountability. Is that wishful the inking? LOL

See! You get me. They're cute together, no question. I like Jake. But, like, I need more when it comes to him. I just cannot fully invest in their love story. It even felt off for me in the first episode before her accident, like he loves Amy more than she loves him and she was being indulgent. IDK.

A lot of people hated Michael in this episode, but I understood his perspective and felt that even when you set aside his clear jealousy, his points were valid. I felt for him at the door. Oof.

Sharon

Wednesday 26th of February 2025

I love this show and Amy and Jake together. Hope to see it in season 2

Sweet Amy

Wednesday 26th of February 2025

@Jasmine Blu, Your wish came true!

Jasmine Blu

Wednesday 26th of February 2025

I'm hoping the renewal news will drop any day now. I definitely want to spend more time with these characters.

SeanSanity

Wednesday 26th of February 2025

Jake has an ex-wife and a child. Let's learn more about his back story. The "perfect man" is often the guy on the rebound, and his shelf life is rarely eternal. I'm hearing something that sounds like "boy toy" in the background, too

Jasmine Blu

Wednesday 26th of February 2025

@SeanSanity, I love Jake. He's one of my favorite characters.

But on a show with so many flawed (albeit frustratingly underdeveloped) characters, we actually don't know much about him. I spoke about this in the last few reviews. So far, he just loves Amy very, very much.

And I get the appeal of the relationship and why people root for it so much, but I personally struggle because we have nothing to go on with him. He's too "perfect" but we know, as you said, he has the ex-wife and child. I've also struggled with what he excuses and justifies to be Amy's hugest supporter. He never realized Sonya had feelings for him. He holds so much in.

Jake is the gallant romantic hero in the story, but we really don't have any background to color him in and give him layers, context, flesh him out.

Most Commented

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!