Well, they say that the oldest memories come back first.

James [to Sophie]

Sophie: Were you the officer assigned to my case?
Baden: There is no case. I’m the case. No one knows about this except me and you.

We don’t have to be who were to each other before, okay? Let’s just be who we are now.

Baden

Caroline: There’s a part of the story I left out.
Sophie: Which part?
Caroline: You and James were going through a hard time, and something happened between me and him. And it was a stupid fucking mistake.

Baden: Staying here is going to get you killed.
Sophie: No, you being here is what’s going to get me killed.

Sophie: You know, my whole life made sense, until you walked into it.
Baden: Did it? Did you just believe the story people been selling you? That you just jumped.
Sophie: No.
Baden: Who do you believe, Sophie? Me or him?

Surface Season 1 Episode 3 Quotes

Sophie: Were you the officer assigned to my case?
Baden: There is no case. I’m the case. No one knows about this except me and you.

Well, they say that the oldest memories come back first.

James [to Sophie]