After finding out Andy (Jesse McCartney) hooked up with Jordan (Johanna Braddy), Rusty is hesitant to take Andy as his little brother. Cappie takes Rusty aside and tells him he needs him to be the best big brother he can. Meanwhile, Evan's real life brother, Patrick (Robert Hoffman), comes for a visit and they end up reminiscing with Cappie about their days at camp. However, Evan is shocked by Patrick asking for money. Meanwhile, at ZBZ, when Casey and Rebecca thinks that Fisher (Andrew J. West) is responsible for stealing the food supply, they can't figure out why Ashleigh won't accept until she reveals the truth.