Following Anthony's cat clue, Henry discovered a mass grave for nine cats, all decapitated. Susan tells the Sullivan family that there's no evident tie between the cats and Anthony's disappearance, and to let the police do their job. Henry objects to Luke and Helen looking through his old files for suspects. Helen berates Luke for not getting names of others who hate Henry from Jim Chilton. Henry, Catherine, and Luke question the park's groundskeeper. Henry thinks his past is a dead end and that he needs to identify the cat killer. Helen goes to see Chilton. The Sullivans are tailing the cops. While Martin Lackey stonewalls Susan and Cooper, Luke breaks into their car and snatching files, setting off an alarm, before the Sullivans race away. Chilton wants sex from Helen in exchange for information. Steven Price reluctantly talks to Susan and Cooper then gets skittish. They are suspicious of Price because he had been homeless but now owns a house on just a custodian's salary. Also Henry's car got made near the car break-in. Chilton takes Helen to meet some ex-con buddies. Helen texts Luke for help. Lackey takes off and the cops tail him. Henry breaks into his apartment. He finds a locked door behind a bookcase and locates the key. But Lackey is just hiding a drug lab. One ex-con mentioned Jason Dodd, the man who raped Maggie, to Luke and Helen. Luke is starting to put together the pieces. Then Susan called Luke looking for Henry after the break-in. A bloodied Henry assaults Price.  Then he goes to the hospital looking for Catherine and gets checked in. Dodd died after being castrated, before Anthony's disappearance. Helen proves Luke isn't the son born from Dodd's rape of Maggie.