Luke hands Catherine Henry's file about Maggie's rape. The police are focusing on Steven Price as a suspect in Anthony's abduction. Henry wakes up in the hospital. Henry said the baby boy that was the result of Jason Dodd's rape of Maggie was adopted by the clerk. Helen is bleeding but her baby is fine. Luke and Helen argue over her keeping the baby. At St. James Orphanage, a boy who had bullied Price had died of an apparent suicide 32 years ago. Luke and Catherine try to talk with Debbie Smith, the clerk at Dodd's trial, who adopted the baby. She tells them to talk to Henry. Luke confronts Henry to no avail. Helen tells Frank she's pregnant with their baby. Cooper follows Price to the Cedar Hills senior facility. But Price puts down a fake room number when he signs in. Debbie Smith's brother Michael calls Luke and asks to meet. Henry uses Fred as a sounding board about the case. Henry thinks Anthony saw the cat killer and that's why he was taken. Henry calls Susan and tells her to have the cat autopsied. MIchael said that someone had threatened his sister to keep quiet after Luke's visit. Their sister Andrea adopted the boy. She told her son David about the Sullivans. Andrea overdosed and the police took David to an orphanage. He tells Helen and Catherine his findings. The autopsy finds eight objects in the cat's stomach. When assembled, they formed the torn-up photo of Maggie that Henry gave to Anthony. The kidnapper is sending the Sullivans and police on a treasure hunt, giving them the first two clues. The police can't get a warrant to search Price's house. Cooper breaks in anyway. Price shoots Cooper.