Ryan tells Amanda that he loves her. She admits she does as well, and decides to move in with Ryan. Wilfred tells him this is a bad idea, because he has too many secrets.
Wilfred invites Bruce over to help Ryan understand why he can't let Amanda move in. Ryan plays Bruce in a game and if he wins he gets a briefcase full of the "truth." When Ryan eventually wins, the briefcase is just a timer showing that he was playing this game with his neighbor's dog and an imaginary man for 12 hours. He breaks up with Amanda.