Round Table: "Damage Case"

by at . Comments

This week on the Round Table, McDreamy McFreaks over McVet, Burke's future with Cristina is debated, and Dr. Torres' hygiene is called into question...

Do you think Calli really washed her hands?
Dr. Torres

McCritic: Of any sort of bathroom residue? Probably. Of the insecure notion that she was being judged by two of our heroines? No way. Like a seventh grade girl who wore a clashing scarf and sweater to school, Calli is sitting alone at the metaphorical hospital lunch table. Bring her some tater tots and always offer to carry her Trapper Keeper, George.

iheartizzie: I doubt it, and there's nothing wrong with that. It's just not important at 6 a.m. when you're gonna shower later anyway. In my household, we strictly adhere to the unofficial policy of "Number One, You're All Done; Number Two, Wash 'Em, You!"

Married-to-McDreamy: Not a chance. Her story definitely doesn't hold water, if you will. She says that she was embarrassed about running into Meredith and Izzie in the bathroom and because of that, she waited to wash her hands until she left and was in the kitchen. However, if she really was that embarrassed, why would she proceed with going to the bathroom after noticing them in there? Very suspicious indeed.  

Who won the Mer/Der fight in the stairwell?

iheartizzie: Mer takes this one in a landslide. Just because McD's hair is one of the wonders of the modern world does not give him license to pass judgment upon his former lover. He never mentioned to Meredith that he was, how shall we say this... married. Then he dumped her when his wife appeared in Seattle. How do you expect Mer to react? And is she even sleeping around? She and McVet hadn't even kissed at that point, while the George incident -- for which she received 106 percent of the blame -- was initiated by Dr. O'Malley during Mer's peak vulnerability. Derek was out of line. She let him know. Game, set, match, Dr. Grey!

Married-to-McDreamy: As much as I would like to say Meredith won the fight, as it was nice to finally see her get a backbone, I have to side with McDreamy on this one. Despite Mer's tirade, he still had the last word and called the shots by saying that they were done.  

McCritic: Derek came out swinging with his whorish accusations and condescending contempt, but Meredith withstood this early flurry and delivered the ultimate knockout blow: a direct order (he doesn't get to call her that!) followed by a stern, rational guilt trip (he did, indeed, break her). Before Derek calls this kettle loose again, he may wish to take a look at the promiscuous pot lying next to him in bed each night.

So Meredith is scary and damaged. Pick another character and describe him/her in two words.

Married-to-McDreamy: Calli Torres: Unclean and homeless. (What a catch!)

McCritic: Preston Burke: Puurrrr. Fect.

iheartizzie: George O'Malley. Bad. Hair.

Will Dr. Burke and Cristina break up in the season finale?

iheartizzie: Exasperating, messy and emotionally-challenged as Cristina may be, Preston loves her dearly. A technically proficienct brainiac is his ideal match, while Cristina looks up to his professionalism and drive. Unless Dr. Burke has an estranged wife back in New York who we don't know about, and she mysteriously shows up in Seattle next week, it's
Drs. Burke & Yang
hard to see something driving them apart.

Married-to-McDreamy: Married-to-McDreamy certainly hopes not. Despite their obvious differences and newfound problems in the bedroom, Burke and Cristina compliment each other and without their bizarre banter, the hallways of Seattle Grace just wouldn't be the same.  

McCritic: As we learned last week, Burke isn't a a natural talent. He had to practice and work his way to the top. If all those years of Tantric dedication result in a partner who can't even remain awake to appreciate such sexual skills, it's time for him to move on. Find someone else, Preston. Then, when the series climaxes next week, maybe you will, too.

TV Fanatics Love Prime Instant Video
Amazon Prime Instant Video
Catch Up on Old Episodes
of Similar Shows and Old Favorites.

Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.

Tags: ,

Oh and about callie, u know i don't know how i feel about her. I do think george needs somebody, and they even our kind of cute together, but she's just kind of weird, and there is something eles about her that i just can't stand, and i don't even know what it is. She just bugs me.


You i love derek, but i do agree he should of never said those things to Merideth, i wish that right at the end of the conversation, she should of said, something, "oh and by the way finn and and i didn't have sex!"


I was really upset after I watched the fight.
But I think I'm on Meredith's side. Remember the first season that she begged Derek to pick her, but he didn't, he chose Addsion. He gave her up, so there's nothing to do with him how she's goona live. And as long as he himself sleeping with Addsion, he has no right to accuse Meredith for sleeping around.
But actually, I think he got so mad just because he still in love with Meredith.


i heart izzie is so right. der had no right to accuse mer of anything after he ended it between them. plus mcvet is so cute!!!!!!!!!!


The only thing that would have made the whole Meridith/Derek fight scene even more satisfying than Meridith's striking defeat over Derek ( she did actually have the last words) would have been having Addison secretly witness Derek's obvious torment over the state of affairs (pun intended) between him and Meridith. He is there giving it as well as getting it over and over with Meridith, because for him, therre is something to fight for. Recall his blatant, cintinuing indifference when it came to Addison's betrayal. He has never wanted to fight about that. The big bedroom bandaid they put on their relationship has got to be experiencing the loss of stickiness, and soon to the extent that they will have to tear it off permanantly or reapply a new one and continue the facade their marriage hsa become.


If it were really over for Derek and Meredith, he wouldn't be so angry.


U don't wash hands after #1? That is str8 up gross.


I normally despise Mer but I gotta say Der had no right to treat her like that. As if it is his business or he really knows whats going on.


nooo! oh god i hope they don't break up. that would just kill me.:,(

Grey's Anatomy Season 2 Episode 24 Quotes

MEREDITH: "You don't get to call me a whore. When I met you, I thought I had found the person that I was going to spend the rest of my life with. I was done! All the boys and all the bars and all the obvious daddy issues, who cares? I was done. You left me. You chose Addison. I'm all glued back together now. I make no apologies for how I chose to repair what you broke. You don't get to call me a whore."
DEREK: "This thing with us is finished. It's over."
MEREDITH: "Finally."
DEREK: "Yeah, it's done."
MEREDITH: "It is done."

MEREDITH: "I don't cook."
FINN: "Nobody asked you to cook."
MEREDITH: "I know. I'm just saying... you know, I don't cook. So you don't have to cook, I don't expect you to cook for me."
FINN: "Okay, look. You, sit there. I want you to drink this and try really hard to act like you aren't scary and damaged."
MEREDITH: "I'm not scary and damaged."
FINN: "Yeah, you are."
MEREDITH: "No, I'm not scary or damaged."
FINN: "Mmm hmm. Alright. Why don't you tell me about your family?"
MEREDITH: "Okay, me not wanting to talk about my family does not make me scary to damaged."
FINN: "Okay, tell me about the last guy you slept with."