American Idol

Tuesdays 8:00 PM on FOX
American idol
TV Fanatic Works Better with Prime Instant Video
40,000 other titles are available to watch now.

American Idol Controversy: Topless Antonella Barba Pictures Surface

by at . Comments

Remember Frenchie Davis, American Idol watchers?

Those that do pretty much only recall this contestant as the singer that got disqualified for posing in her lingerie years before the competition.

Antonella Barba hopes she doesn't become a similar victim.

Pictures of the semi-finalist have surfaced on the Internet. We're not judging, just presenting them to fans so they can have an idea of what we're talking about.

Antonella is second from the right. Could she follow Akron Watson out the door? Or will producers give the girl a break? She is covering up, after all...

Antonella Barba, Topless

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.


Sign the petition to bring back Antonella Barba! Tell everyone you know to sign!




Sorry for a third in a row everyone... Here's a link (viewer discresion is advised) If people can say its all innocent after this, the world has really come to something unfortunate.


PS If Frenchie got booted off because of her topless pictures (which I have personally not seen, but have been told that they are done as more of art than anything else), Antoinella should be out for porn.


Ok guys, I think some people are missing something here..Antoinella was not JUST seem on the beach topless, there's pics of her giving fellatio too! They aren't just pictures of stuff that we might've done when we were young; it's porn. While I'm not a mother myself I think I would want to do everything I can to get rid of her on American Idol so kids aren't idolizing some wannabe porn star. And for whoever that was who said it's her personal business, it is IF it wasnt all over the internet. And for one last thing, I am a music student and work with a fantastic vocal coach...Antoinella can't sing worth crap (not saying that I can do better of course. Anyone can see that she's got nothin' compared to some of those other girls!


They also need to take her off the show. They took Frenchie off, and she only had ONE topless photo. What is up with that shit?


There are many more worse pictures that that! Any self-respecting person wouldn't take those filthy pictures. You just blame youth as an excuse, because she is young and beautiful. She isn't beautiful, and you can see better looking women on the street. Overrated in looks and in singing. Well, honey, there are plenty of young people out there who wouldn't pose for those pictures. Unless, today's young generation has gone into the toilet. That could be. You people seem to think that it is cute. Girls think it is cool to dress and act like sluts. You proabably idolize those bimbos Paris Hilton and Britney Spears. Look at all those idiots trying to get jobs these days when all their shortcomings are splashed all over the Internet. Employers can easily find that stuff, and believe me, they won't be very impressed.


I say leave Antonella alone, she will be gone sooner or later. She really isn't that good. So someone took her picture when she was in the bathroom u cant see anything. The beach picture...geez that isn't anything either. Now if the other girl would have made it then WOW we would have some stuff to talk about. Drug dealing, coke sniffing everyone would want to know who the father of the baby is! Now thats some good stuff!


Oh my God the real reason why she should be thrown off the show is because she can' hold a note not because she's young and decided to let loose and have fun for a little while. Lord Jesus half of the people posting here talking about shes a slut, shes a hoe, she's a freak did something like that or worse when they were younger. Give the girl a break. Shes young and beautiful..but we all know that she doesn't belong on American Idol. She can't sing, thats the only reason America should vote her no talent having ass off. I'm just saying.


Antonella has a bright future in a least two or three porn movies! She will get voted off American Idol within a couple of weeks and then she will turn to posing nude and doing porn. I’ve seen it a million times. Oh yeah, she will probably be a Go-Go Dancer too! Lol What a whore….