American Idol Reviews
American Idol Review: Who Did Elton John Justice?
American Idol paid tribute to Elton John last night, and may have found a couple new contenders in the process. First, Haley Reinhart surprised us by closi...
American Idol Season 10 Premiere: Watering the Flower, Letting It Grow
American Idol may have kicked off season 10 by telling viewers "it's not our story, it's yours" (while spending its entire first block recounting its game ...
American Idol Review: Bowersox by TKO!
We hate to simply quote Simon Cowell, but his reaction to Crystal Bowersox's take on "Up to the Mountain" last night says it all: "I thought that was, by f...
American Idol Review: Casey Ya!
Kara may still crush on him, but we can only hope America's love affair with Casey James come to an end this evening. The singer is perfectly nice and not ...
American Idol Review: Snoooooze!
The American Idol finalists sang a pair of duets this week, both of which were praised by Kara and Simon with the following critiques: "The duets tonight w...
American Idol Review: Casey James Butchers Frank Sinatra
It was made official this week: Casey James is as lost without his guitar as Sue Sylvester is without her power of intimidation on Glee. James, an early fr...
American Idol Review: Contestants Go Country
As Ellen DeGeneres told viewers at every opportunity last night: the Shania Twain left the station on American Idol. Who got on board, as this country star...
American Idol Review: "Elvis Night"
Every week on American Idol, the pressure gets ratcheted up. But finalists were faced with a number of reasons to be extra nervous last night, foremost amo...
American Idol Review: Guitars, Bagpipes and Didgeridoos!
Tim Urban has advanced to the top nine on American Idol due to a nice smile and fantastic attitude. But we have a feeling he'll stick around this week for ...
American Idol Review: Lee and Big Mike Stand Out
Lee DeWyze really stepped up last week on American Idol, breaking the inconsistency that has long plagued him and establishing himself as a guy who may las...
