American Idol Finalists Sufffer Through Second Beatles Week

at . Comments

Aside from heavy favorite David Archuleta, not a single American Idol finalist earned praise from all three judges last night.

Archuleta, however, bounced back from forgetting the lyrics to his Beatles song last week by belting out a rendition of "The Long and Winding Road" that was called a "master class" by Simon Cowell. Dude brought the hotness, praised Randy Jackson!

As for the rest of the Idols, only David Cook and Carly Smithson could muster any sort of positive reaction from the panel.

The Top 11

Who was your favorite performer of the night? Who should be sent home?

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.


Who dresses these contestants ? Carly's clothing choice does NOTHING for her and are really,really ugly !!


Wonder if Carly made bottom 3 because of
her gross tattoo and her husband tattoos.
She should cover them up from now on.
Plus her teeth need work.She has a great voice-now she has to figure out why she got so few votes.