While we have visual evidence of other, current American Idol scandals - such as Ramiele Malubay posing lewd with friends and David Hernandez working as a nude gay stripper - the following is nothing but a rumor at the moment:
The National Enquirer is reporting that someone is shopping Amanda Overmyer nude photos around the Internet.
While there are no pictures to speak of at the moment, the celebrity gossip tabloid claims the individual that possesses them hails from Amanda's home state of Indiana. He's demanding serious cash in exchange for the bare photos of this hopeful rocker.
Can this story be believed? It's hard to say. But consider this: The National Enquirer was also first to report awhile back that Vanessa Hudgens nude pics existed... and they did!