One Tree Hill Review: "I Can't See You But I Know You're There"

by at . Comments

What a stomach punch. 

I was all ready to be back on board the One Tree Hill train after an improved season premiere... and then this?  On "I Can't See You, But I Know You're There," Clay and Quinn took near-death hallucinations to a whole new level, and not in a good way.

I am not one for dream sequences in general, but I could choke down the scenes by these two in the premiere because they were off in their own beach setting.  I assumed once they figured out what was going on, it would be the end of it.

Mia and Chase

Boy, was I wrong!  What I couldn't handle is the fact that these two were having simultaneous out of body experiences in which they watched their own surgeries.  I mean, come on, that is tough to sell me on.

And how is Clay so knowledgeable on how these types of in between life and death situations work?  He knew that Quinn feeling weaker meant that she was going back to real life, and he knew exactly when she was going to leave him in this limbo of a reality?  Why?  What's the reasoning behind his obscure knowledge on this subject?

So now that we have that out of the way, let's get to the other stuff I didn't like about this week's episode.  I still can't get over how underdeveloped Clay and Quinn are as characters.  As they hung in the balance of life and death, I found myself not caring whatsoever about which way the landed.

I mean, the moments in which James Lafferty and Bethany Joy Galeotti gave such great monologues to unconscious Clay and Quinn, respectively?  Those were great, but I could care less because of the characters they were having the heart to hearts with.  If that was Lucas and Peyton lying in those hospital beds, I definitely would have shed a tear or two.

And onward to the only other story of the episode that gave us much to work with.  The Chase/Mia/Alex triangle, and Mouth's return, could have been cut entirely and I would have been okay.  But the dynamic between Julian and Jamie was interesting to me.

When Jamie and Nathan interact, it doesn't feel comfortable at all.  It's very mechanical and their love for each other doesn't really shine through.  Jamie and Julian, on the other hand, work like gang busters.  Their chemistry in the scene where they are conjuring stories for people at the arcade more than made up for the horrific batting cage scene just before it.  Seriously why are TV shows so bad at sport segments?

Jaime and Julian

Although Julian's character is enjoyable when interacting with Jamie, that's about the only time he is still worth watching.  This all-around good guy version of the character isn't nearly as entertaining as the sarcastic, disinterested Julian we first met in season six.  Julian has matured, just like Nathan did back in the early seasons. We need another male jerk to come on the show to break up this gang of nice guys.

Anyway, Quinn has come back to life, while Clay still lies in the balance.  When will he make his way back?  And do you care if he does?  Questions about Haley's pregnancy and Nathan's health status are still up in the air.  Things should get interesting in the coming episodes, as long as the out of body experiences end soon.

Other Thoughts:

  • Starting every episode this season with Haley writing to Lucas would be a great addition.  Let's hope this stays.
  • They really knew what they were doing with the nostalgia of bringing the theme song back.  Having different people perform it from time to time makes it that much better.  This week the opening credits were performed by Kate Voegele (Mia).
  • This week in the quirky One Tree Hill-ism in which different characters say the same thing seconds after each other, we had: Brooke and Mia both having "long stories" and Mouth, Mia and Brooke all claiming "it's my fault."

What were your favorite One Tree Hill quotes from the episode?

Review

Editor Rating: 2.0 / 5.0
  • 2.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 3.8 / 5.0 (37 Votes)

Dan Forcella is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more One Tree Hill?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

From Around the Web

    More From TV Fanatic

    Past-transgressions

    Graceland Review: Unintended Consequences?

    The road to healing and closure is a long one. Some of our agents are on it, others are struggling. Check out our Graceland review of "Magic Number" now.
    Safety-concerns

    The Bridge Review: Finger, Hand, Ear?

    On tonight's The Bridge, Sonya and Marco deal with the aftermath of saving Eva. With their lives in danger, how will they protect her?
    Fighting-the-sec

    Suits Review: Always a Choice

    Jeff and Jessica try to fight off the SEC, while Mike struggles to make good on an investment, causing more rifts as he does it. Can Pearson Specter survive the onslaught? Read our Suits review of "Leveraged" now.
    A-distrubing-encounter

    Extant Review: Welcome Home

    On the Extant series premiere, astronaut Molly returns from a 13-month trip to space with a condition that seems impossible. Read the review for details!

    Avatar

    I disagree with you on the out of body experiences because they give us insight of what the character are thinking and feeling. I really like these and Quinn / Clay characters. Actually, OTH is still interresting only thanks to Brooke, Julian, Quinn and Clay. I erally can't stand Nathan and Haley (since the beginning) and please don"t make Peyton come back (that took 6 seasons to get her out, it was long enough). So far I really enjoy this season.

    Avatar

    I LOVED the opening credits.

    Avatar

    I LOVE One Tree Hill.
    Even though the later season aren't nearly as good as the earlier ones, I still like this show a whole lot. I thought the heart to hearts were so heartbreaking. :(
    I love the return of the opening credits.
    Why is Haley talking about Lucas and Peyton all of a sudden. They never mentioned them like all last season, but now everyone is mentioning them. Could it be that the writers are hinting at a possible return for Brooke's wedding. That would be totally awesome!!!!!

    Avatar

    Please, thank God for Julian and Brooke. They are the only characters worth watching anymore. If they were to bring Peyton and Lucas back, I think I will stop watching. For 6 seasons straight it was about them. It's like Joey-Dawson all over again. Anyways, it's too early in the season to determine if it's gonna suck or not. Mark Schawhan, please, we beg you, no more dream sequences.

    Avatar

    Brulian and Naley are the only reasons why I still watch this show... I'm tired of Clay and Quinn and the limbo storyline, however the only thing I really loved about the episode was Julian and Jamie. Julian is one of my favorite characters, I think he's adorable and an inner nerd, I don't think they need another jerk because there would be no one to pair him up with unless they pair him up Quinn, but if Clay ends up living there would be no point.

    Avatar

    totally agree with you about the bringing a jerk guy in
    and the whole out of body thing should end, really not going anywhere and we have already seen it in season 4 with lucas and that was pretty good.
    Quinn clay just need to come back... i wanna know what happens with brooks company and naley!! whole pregnancy and back thing
    as for jamie and julian... i agree but i reckon they should really try get the father son relationship back with jamie and nathan, really the whole scott family back in their cheesy ways, because although it was corny as hell, it was good to watch, well for me it was. BTW loving haley (bethany joy galeotti's hair) the season has started off alright, but i have a feeling there is alot of juicy stuff to come in the following episodes and the whole season. ps. liking the whole writing to lucas, gives that feeling of haley and lucas' friendship again, i missed that in season 7 !!
    BRING LEYTON BACK !!! for at least a little while