God, what are those people watching who criticize the show ... ok it is not fabulous I will give you that and the edge is a little gone and I am tired of Yo Dog and Steven's non-committal comments but J-Lo's criticisms are well spoken and some of these singers are darn good! Colton can play piano and sing fabulously. Jessica is a sweet, young fabulous singer who just needs time and will one day turn into one of the best female singers on the market. Skylar is one of the cutest little country singers I have ever seen and she can sing and she makes country feel like country music again, not pop-country. One more I don't think America is giving a fair chance and that is because no one has shown this girl how to perform on stage ... Elise has a great voice and I haven't heard anyone with a rasp like hers since Janis Joplin ... she CAN move me with a song like no other. Her only problem is she needs to loosen up on stage and make people warm up to her ... Elise, if you are reading these, honey, you come across a little cold and aloof ... make people love you! Perform your heart out! You have the looks definitely and you have a absolutely amazing voice ... make the world love you, baby, and you can win this show! Oh and just for me I want you to sing a Joplin song so badly ... I can just see you right now with "Piece of my Heart" or "Try". Amazing voice!
Give AI a break ... who cares about the judges or anyone else except the singers! Give them a shot!
Hire Jimmy Iovine as a judge fire Steven and jlo please! Get randy Jackson back to saying yo dog pitchy dog doggy dog dog. I haven't heard him say dog in 2 season now that's wrong ...here's who judges should be Kelly clarkson jimmy lovine randy Jackson
I think all of them are horrible. The girls are the bottom of the barrel. The judges are ridiculous. I will not be watching anymore. Bye Idol!
I thought no one is good they all need work phillip Phillips sounds the same every week its getting old heejun was funny in a idol way hope he stays the show needs him ....skylar is the first American idol I would say that I get excited to see she is amazing I would buy her music ...but seriously theses judges are weak we need tougher judges with wider ears the talent for the last 3 years have been the same controlled by backstage politics that's why Simon left I like xfactor more
Heejun reminds me a little like Sanjaya His performance was not entertaining at all I have not liked Heejun since the groups auditions I dont like his attitude and joking around there is a time and place for that!! As far as the changes with I think that there are too many mentors throwing the Idols in too many directions = FRUSTRATION They need a judge more like Simon to set them start I have been watching AI since it all started 11 years ago I am thinking that maybe its time to switch to something else XFactor maybe????
Sorry, y'all! I totally meant Whitney when I said Celine in regards to Jessica Sanchez' performance last night! That's been fixed. Though "I Will Always Love You" is totally the kind of song Celine Dion would nail.
As for Heejun, he is far from the best contestant in the competition. In fact, he may actually be the second worst vocalist currently on the show. But what I like about him is that he's quirky and funny. His humor may not be for everyone, but different strokes. I don't think he's long for the Idol world, though.
That episode arguably worked better than Ambien. What a snooze fest. I don't care who goes hone as long as it isn't Philip,colton, Jessica,Joshua, or deandre.
I agree with Meg on this one. Heejun and DeAndre need to go home.
I have absolutely no idea how Heejun even made it in honestly. I haven't heard him sing a song yet that didn't make me want to cringe.
And I have trouble understanding DeAndre a lot when he sings. Not to mention that ridiculously distracting hair.
Speaking of hair... I love Erika to death, but not a big fan of the cut and color. I think she was perfect just the way she was.
The top three I a pulling for are Heejun (entertaining, Hollie and Jessica. I was so very sorry to see Shannon get booted last week. Thought her talent was much greater than Elise. Although I felt Elise did not have much of a personality, after her friends came on stage, feel a little differently. The warmth they showed to her must mean she is a pretty nice person. I think Hollie has a tremendous voice and hope, due to a poor choice of song, that she does not go tonight. As for Jessica, she looks like a possible shoe-in to win this contest. Her range, her tone, her power all add up to one great talent. It will be interesting.
Ok, so I agree that Elise has some chops but to be honest I thought this week was not a good performance. As much as I love her, Skylar, and Phillip all they seem to know how to do is growl alot and shout at the top of their lungs. Deandre is BORING and Erika, well, I don't even know what to say about her. She seems a little arrogant and too be honest her and Elise don't have the greatest personalities. I do believe that is why they have been in the bottom three more often. They need to lighten up a little. But hey, this is just me.
You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please
© 2013 TV Fanatic