American Idol Review: So Many Years, So Many Ballads

at . Comments

Last week, the American Idol contestants paid tribute to Whitney Houston and Stevie Wonder. This week, they're dazzling us with music from the years they were born. I suddenly understand why my favorites in this competition are my favorites. Two of these contestants were born in 1994 and two of these contestants were born in 1995. Which makes me almost old enough to be their mother. Ouch, Idol. My favorites don't make me feel so old.

Ryan leads with the teaser that one of the contestants will be going home tonight instead of tomorrow night. Producers aren't attempting to spin the reason for Jermaine Jones' ouster into something positive, which is refreshing. Ryan says we'll learn more about that later.

American Idol Top 11

Phillip Phillips leads the night singing "Hard to Handle" by the Black Crowes from 1990. He tells Jimmy and guest mentor Will.I.Am that after his practice he has to go have surgery to have kidney stones removed because his right kidney isn't functioning. OUCH. And? Sympathy vote. Not that he needs it. He takes the stage without his guitar but jams with a piano and gives a great performance to start the night. Randy is amazed that he did that well given his recent surgery. J.Lo says Phillip seems to feel his songs in every cell of his body. Steven's advice is to watch the melody, but otherwise says it's a great job. I think Phillip won't suffer from having been the lead tonight and he's set the bar high. 4/5

Singing Gloria Estefan's 1995 hit "Turn the Beat Around," Jessica Sanchez is up second. She's apparently always been a bit of a diva. (Can't say I'm shocked by that one at all, really.) Will.I.Am and Jimmy love her practice round. I'm not loving her performance. She's incredibly distracted by her hair and, while she hits the lyrics, it's just not a fantastic song choice to show off her vocal talents. Steven says she needs to stick closely to ballads. J.Lo, the ultimate Latina diva, says her syncopation was off with the rhythm and this wasn't her favorite performance. Randy says the judges need to "stir" her in the right direction since she's one of the best singers in the competition and that this song choice wasn't great for her. I think she's safe, but I agree with every word the judges said. It wasn't spectacular. 2/5

Heejun Han takes us back to 1989 with the Richard Marx classic "Right Here Waiting For You." Will.I.Am wisely counsels him to enunciate and not drop the final syllables off his words. Then Heejun asks for Fergie's digits. This performance is a total snoozer, just like every other song Richard Marx ever released. (Which was what, one other song?) Randy says the song was boring and this wasn't a great performance. He recommends Heejun stick to R&B. J.Lo says the song got really beautiful toward the end. Steven said Heejun "stepped way outside his circle" for this one. I think J.Lo got it right--the song was beautiful toward the end. When it was over. 2/5

Coming at us from 1983, Elise Testone is singing Tina Turner's version of "Let's Stay Together." Will.I.Am suggests she smile a little. Elise says that when she takes the stage tonight, "people are going to be making babies." I...uh...this is a family show, Elise. This performance is the reason Elise Testone deserved to be saved last week. It's not high-energy, but it fits her like a glove vocally. Steven says her rasp is so natural, and J.Lo says she showed America who Elise is. Randy says "Elise is back." And she is. She picked a song in her wheel house and made it work. If she can keep doing this, she'll be one to watch. 5/5

DeAndre Brackensick was born in 1994 and has decided to sing "Can You Feel the Love Tonight" by Elton John for The Lion King. Bad song choice #1. Will.I.Am and Jimmy switch him to "Endless Love" after comparing his first song choice to a tennis racket in the hands of a carpenter. Bad song choice #2. I didn't love his performance. It wasn't the worst of his performances I've endured, but it wasn't fantastic. J.Lo says he can sing anything and that he sang that beautifully, but thinks Jimmy and Will.I.Am steered him wrong with the song choice. Randy says his song was boring and way too safe. DeAndre didn't seem confident or comfortable with the song choice and I think it showed. This could be his swan song. 1/5

Another 1995 baby, Shannon Magrane, listens to "Don't Speak" by No Doubt before settling on "One Sweet Day" by Mariah Carey and Boyz II Men. Will.I.Am tells her to practice the song lying down to get her breathing right. Does he expect her to perform lying down, too? Shannon doesn't hit the sour notes she hit last week, which is great for her, but she's pushing too hard. J.Lo says she was terrified for Shannon but thinks Shannon did a great job. Steven says she sings her best when she's not trying so hard. Randy says he was also terrified, but Shannon is fearless and, "considering the mountain she was trying to climb," she did a great job. That's a backhanded compliment if I've ever heard one. Shannon has talent and can definitely sing, but she's aging herself with her song choices. No Doubt would've been a better, younger choice even though the songs came out the same year. 2/5

Colton Dixon chooses White Lion's "Broken Heart" from 1991, and it's a song nobody knows. Will.I.Am tells Colton that White Lion didn't even know the song, so Colton has no choice but to make it his own. He suggests making it more hard rock and Colton agrees. It was a good choice. While it still sounds decidedly like early 90's rock with a little modern alt-rock mixed in, Colton actually performs the song instead of just singing it, which is what sets him apart from the others. J.Lo said Colton's a lover which makes him relatable. She also thinks he looks pretty when he sings. I'm thinking she's been wooed by the Eye-Sex. Steven said it was the wrong song for Colton's voice and passion. Randy said the song didn't matter and his performance was "dope." I enjoyed Colton's quasi-throwback. It's clear that Colton feels comfortable on the stage and that translates into a solid performance. 5/5

Erika Van Pelt is singing Bryan Adams' "Heaven," or something like it. She says she's happy to get back to rock. Will.I.Am seemed nervous for her. I was kind of happy when her performance ended. Steven said she "was too busy all over it" and the audience booed him. J.Lo said the arrangement left her wanting more. Randy said it was an 8 out of 10 for him, but that the arrangement was "catchy" and "jerky." The judges, all three of them, haven't been more correct tonight. That arrangement was all over the place and didn't do Erika any favors. I wanted to like it, and I'm all for contestants taking risks and changing songs to suit their personal style, but when you have such an iconic song like that, it's hard to fix what isn't broken. 2/5

Ryan confirms that one of the contestants will be leaving the competition due to information that has recently surfaced "thanks to the help of law enforcement." That contestant is Jermaine Jones. We see footage of Jermaine sitting down with Idol producers Nigel Lythgoe and Ken Warwick, and they tell him that the charges against him are typically youthful indiscretions and they wish he'd been more forthcoming with them. They reiterate that they aren't allowed to have anyone with outstanding warrants against them on the program, but he has four. Nigel and Ken tell him that his practice performance was the best song of his they've heard and they're sad to see him go. We get to see footage of Jermaine at practice (which was a mere hour before he found out he'd be going home), and just like that, Jermaine's out.

Skylar Laine picks Bonnie Raitt's "Love Sneaking Up On You" from 1994 and Jimmy doesn't feel like there's enough song there for her. He and Will.I.Am throw song after song at her, including "Gangsta's Paradise," but Skylar sticks to her guns and Bonnie Raitt. It's the right choice. Steven loved it. J.Lo said she killed it. Randy said "good on her" for doing so well.  No, she didn't get to show off a crazy vocal range on the song, but Skylar did her thing, and in doing her thing, she's proving that she knows who she is as an artist which is more than some of the other girls her age can say. 4/5

The state of Louisiana sent their hero Josh Ledet an entire tub of crawfish. Maybe more crawfish than I've ever seen in my life and certainly more crawfish than one person could even conceive of eating. Which is completely unrelated to his performance of Michael Bolton's "When A Man Loves A Woman" from 1992 but is equally as crazy. All three judges are on their feet halfway through the performance and I'm just sitting her scratching my head. Randy said it was phenomenal and incredible and credits his awesome performance to the crawfish. J.Lo said it was "the best thing she's ever seen on American Idol." He churched up Michael Bolton, y'all. I just cannot wrap my head around this, nor can I imagine him as a contemporary artist. I'll give him credit for being talented, but I can only take so much Mantasia. 5/5

Hollie Cavanagh closes the night with Celine Dion's "The Power of Love" from 1993. Will.I.Am wonders where she's got all that power hiding. She schools every other female contestant in the competition in what it means to be a powerhouse performer. J.Lo and Steven said she had one or two pitch problems but commenting on them would be silly. Randy said she "blew it out 'da box." And she did. And she does. And no doubt, she'll do it again. But here's the problem--she's painting herself into a corner of only being able to sing ballads. Hollie needs to pick up the tempo next week and show some versatility. 4/5

It's clear that Hollie Cavanagh and Josh Ledet are the runaway winners of the night. The judges were so overwhelmed by Josh's performance they seemed hard-pressed to find words for Hollie's. This is the kind of week that really drives the point home that song choice is everything. When you're not limited to the songs of one particular artist and can choose from an entire year's worth of songs, it's incredibly easy to pick a great song, and picking a great song is about more than just picking a song you loved listening to when you were growing up, which is what I think a couple of the contestants did, namely Shannon and Jessica.

Also, ladies and gentlemen, enough with the ballads. Listen to what's playing on the radio right now and try to make yourselves current.

My top picks for the night are Phillip Phillips, Colton Dixon, Skylar Laine, and, reluctantly, Josh Ledet. I think a combination of Shannon Magrane, Heejun Han, DeAndre Brackensick, and Erika Van Pelt will make up tomorrow night's bottom three.

Who had your favorite performance of the night? Least favorite? What do you think of the way Idol producers handled Jermaine's elimination from the competition? Do you think we'll get another surprise twist tomorrow night and find out that no one's going home because of Jermaine's elimination?


Editor Rating: 3.5 / 5.0
  • 3.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Miranda Wicker is a Staff Writer for TV Fanatic. Follow her on Twitter.


Heejun will probably go home tonight. He totally sucked last night.
My top picks.....Phillip, Colton, Skylar and Hollie. I've mentioned before I haven't watched Idol in quite a few years.
I still say the only reason people watch today is Steven Tyler. Their ratings are declining.
They DO need another Simon. I got so tired of all three judges saying last night "Your voice is beautiful" was sickening!


I love the show, but more and more I realize they need Simon...some of those ppl were terrible yesterday....especially Elise, she has a great voice but ruined that song...ugh...also, the coaches are giving terrible feedback and promoting their own thing...Heejun was not great, but tell Randy there were a lot worse, listen to the show again..anyway, hope it's better next week


Phillip P. is the one to beat. He and Colton have the only considerable good voices for the guys! Girls ... diva maybe but Jessica has a beautiful voice and Skylar is my pick to go further, with or without Idol! She's got stage performance, voice and personality to boot ... that's star quality! And I don't like country music!


I write a review also, so I sometimes will check out other reviews as a matter of comparison. I should mention I've been a front man on stage and behind the scenes for many years too. The two singers last night that received high praise from the judges and didn't come close to the hype were Ledet and Cavanagh. First, to compare Joshua's "best ever" review from Jennifer Lopez is just sad. He wasn't bad last night but hardly an "Idol Moment". He has a truly great falsetto and that salvaged an otherwise karaoke performance. As for Hollie... I reviewed the recording of last night and my first impression stands, she may have been the worst of the night. Her pitch was off for nearly the entire song. I thought she was going to end strong because the last chorus seemed to get on track, then she went terribly off pitch at the end. Skylar used the stage very well but was otherwise average, Shannon should be glad Hollie and Erika had bad nights. Colton and Phillip were on point, I didn't agree with Steven regarding Colton either. Jessica was boring this week too. Fans could go either way regarding Heejun, I am dubious on him. Phillip, Elise and Colton won the night, I sure hope the voters will show it to Elise. Some of these contestants are good but aren't getting votes. Elise was the only bottom feeder from last week that deserves better.


Wow! I am shocked at this review and the comments. Idol talks about being true to one's self and do your best. Joshua out sang EVERYONE hands down. This might not be the best outlet for his talent but he was phenomenal! None of the girls were impressive and most were pitchy and over-dramatic... Hollie was terrible and very pitchy. But after Josh, I cant blame her. Shannon was pitchy too. A lot of the problems were attributed to song choice. Hopefully, they wont eliminate anyone tonight and they will all get a chance to redeem themselves next week!

Miranda wicker

@Blu, I can enjoy each contestant in their given genres even if I don't enjoy that genre of music, but AI is about discovering a "star." When I think of "star" in today's terms, I think of what's going to be played on a Top 40 station, and so far, only a few of these contestants are that kind of star. @john, oversight, I guess? I liked her performance more than I liked Josh Ledet's, but Josh is a shoo-in for Top 3 tonight and Elise probably isn't because of where she performed in the line-up. @Wondering, Endless Love may have come out originally in 1981, but a lot of the contestants were singing covers. Jessica's number is originally from 1976, but was made famous in 1995.


Ooops! Just noticed my typo. It should have been 1984, not 1884!!! I'm not THAT old! :)


I was only halfway paying attention when I watched last night, so I missed what DeAndre's birth year was. So tell me, if he was born in 1994, how does he end up singing a song I sang in choir in high school when I graduated in 18 EIGHTY four???? I looked it up. It's a 1981 song. Just wondering.


How do you not put Elise as a top pick when you give her a 5/5?


i think shannon was awesome! i think the only two girls that deserve to be there are hollie and shannon and the boys are coltan and joshua! even though i think joshua need to force to hit the notes! i think skylar look like she is going to die everytimes she try to hit a note!(but i still want her to stay) and jessica wasnt good and i never really like are!! i think last week shannon did a bad perfomance(well not that bad actually)and she was in the bottom 2 well this week she did awesome and jessica wasnt great so jessica should be and deserve to be in the bottom 2. jessica thinks she is the best maybe she is a great contestant this year but she is to confident and knew she will hit a wall someday and that day was to day so she should be in the bottom maybe not living but not safe either!