Perception Season Finale Review: Nothing But The Truth

at . Comments

With Perception's 10 episodes ending via a great season one finale, it's safe to say that Eric McCormack has found a fantastic character to sink his teeth into.

McCormack has always had a likable personality and charm, but it's been tough for him to completely break away from his character on Will & Grace. Not to say that Will Truman wasn't great, but there's always something about being on a series for so long that sometimes people and viewers can't separate the actor and the character.

Except the star found a way to bring to life Daniel Pierce in a way that wasn't Will Truman or even Eric McCormack playing the doctor. This was Daniel Pierce as Daniel Pierce, a compelling character with quirks, flaws, humor and a personality that made you want to watch him solve crimes.

And "Light," while it did send Pierce into a darker hole even after his realization that he had been hallucinating for three days, managed to illustrate his ability to push back and find the positives in dealing with schizophrenia.

Pierce Needs Help

Boy, did the show sink Pierce to an ultimate low.

First, he discovered his doctor looked exactly like Natalie, confusing him even further. Then he found out she technically was Natalie (but really named Caroline), the girl he saw in college, but in reality he never spoke to. Imagining that they dated and she was there was truly when his first symptoms began.

The heartbreaking line he said to Caroline truly made you want to hug the guy: "I always believed there was this one beautiful summer, before I became a complete whacko, and I had what normal people have: someone to love, something real. And now I look at you, the most familiar stranger I've ever met, and I know I never had it at all."

The emotional resonance between the two characters was sincere and each story Pierce told or "remembered" opened up even further his type of character. Sure, he spent the first half mostly being sad in bed, but can you blame him? His world was turned upside down.

Which is why it was fantastic to see him, in addition to taking his meds, have a resurgence of determination and passion in solving the case.

And I loved that Pierce used Caroline to play the "Natalie part" when he was trying to figure out the puzzling situation. Kelly Rowan, who plays her, has great chemistry with McCormack. Even no longer his hallucination, you could still tell that there was a certain spark between the two.

Now, the political conspiracy might not have been my favorite case, but it linked in perfectly with Pierce's situation. And certainly, having Kate's partner pretend to be Pierce to catch the killer was funny, especially with Pierce more concerned about his bike.

The final conversation about not keeping secrets with Kate was an interesting one. We know that probably won't happen (that would be too easy), but I am curious as to how their relationship will evolve whether it's platonic or romantic. I'm still mixed on how I want these two to end up, but I'm glad nothing was rushed between them this season.

However, I would love to see Caroline and Pierce test those love waters because now she's willing to be his friend. They seemed to hit it off just fine, even if he enjoys doing puzzles without her giving the answers.

And of course, the episode concluded with my favorite aspect of the series: the classroom lecture. It truly bookended the hour's concept but was a great contrast to the pilot. That last shot of Lewicki walking away and Pierce actually being able to talk to someone real was a pleasant and positive change.

My only really minor questions involved what happened to the kid who killed Wesley and who was that FBI guy Kate was talking to at the beginning. I know they don't actually impact the overall story or outcome of the episode, but that kid has to be charged right? And what happened to Kate's boss or was that guy an interim one?

Overall, Perception really stepped it up giving us a phenomenal character in Dr. Pierce and providing a pretty satisfying conclusion. It may not have been perfect, but the series is certainly on an upswing and I look forward to seeing what season two has to offer.

What did you think? Did you enjoy the finale? Excited for more Dr. Pierce? Sound off below!


Editor Rating: 4.6 / 5.0
  • 4.6 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.8 / 5.0 (146 Votes)

Sean McKenna is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.


the FBI agent is the weakest part of the show. She is too young, too inexperienced and comes off as an amateur, the acting is not up to snuff compared to the rest of the cast. This is also where the writing is the weakest, and makes it hard to suspend my disbelief.
McCormack is excellent, as is the rest of the supporting cast, Lewicki, Natalie etc. The depiction of schizophrenia is believable and sympathetic, and also shows us how someone with mental illness can still live a full and rich life.
I look forward to the next season.


It's been such a long time since I've come across such interesting show! 10 ep is just not enough!! Love the story the cast and everything! MORE PLEASE!


That was the season finale?
But there's only been ten episodes!
I want more!!!:]


I really like this show, it is differnt and intersting. You need to stay focused or you will not get what was real and what was a fantasy. But on the other hand we can never be sure what is what, in the end this all is a fantasy of the young FBI agent... *g*


I like this show. I love Monk but he got on your nerves. This show as open my mind on some of the things that a close relative has had to go through. He is fighting against himself. He show as a strong charter with a weakness. Glad Natlie/Caroline showed up as a human that had actually crossed his path in his earlier life. Hope you keep her as human. I don't think the FBI 's are too young. As you get older yourself, you expect younger. I felt bad that Daniel thought he was so far gone that he had himself committed. It's a good show. Glad he has Lewicki.


@TME. part 1 was mostly in his head, from the time kate brought him home till lewicky came home he all made it up


I can't believe no one else noticed the senator's widow, who died in Part 1, was back, alive and talking, in Part 2! Or did I miss something?


I agree that the FBI agents do look a tad young, but they do handle the mental illness part of Daniel's reality quite well. 'Natalie' keeps him grounded and makes him think; Lewicky keeps him in reality. He does appear to be a combined group of characters from other shows all rolled up into one, but it is very well done and I will enjoy watching it.


I enjoyed the finale and it reminded me of an old English movie staring Glynis Johns - The Cabinet of Dr. Calgari - she was a young woman whose car had broken down and she sought shelter from the storm in this spooky old house. After a while, she felt she was a prisoner and couldn't escape. She found a 'friend' in a young man who was going to help her escape (Lewicki in Daniel's case or Natali?). But at the end, we find out she suffered a severe breakdown and everyone in the hospital setting who she feared was going to kill her, were actually the doctors and nurses supervising her care. The kind young man, turned out to be her son and she was quite old in reality. She left with him, her delusions were gone. I just couldn't get that movie out of my head while watching this episode.


Eric McCormack may have had trouble distancing himself from Will and Grace in the past, but he has DEFINITELY found a break-away role with Dr. Daniel Pierce! McCormack very ably brings Pierce to life in SUCH a unique and sympathetic way, there is only room for Pierce in my mind when I am watching him. Some people claim the show is a ripoff of Monk, but I think Pierce is a much more interesting character than Monk because he refuses to accommodate his illness - he challenges himself every day in a way that Monk rarely did. Monk was mostly smart. Pierce is smart AND courageous - except when it comes to intimate relationships. But even there, we're seeing him turn new corners. I'm really looking forward to Season 2 and seeing where his beautiful mind leads him next.

Tags: ,