Gossip Girl Round Table: "Dirty Rotten Scandals"

at . Comments

Welcome back, once again, to TV Fanatic's weekly Gossip Girl Round Table Q&A discussion! Below, our panelists break down all aspects of last night's Gossip Girl episode, "Dirty Rotten Scandals."

In our Q&A session, TVF CEO Eric Hochberger (Gossip Guy), editor Steve Marsi (Mister Meester) and staff members Courtney Morrison and Leigh Raines share their opinions on Monday's events.

Weigh in with your take on the following topics after reading ours!


1. What was your favorite quote or scene from the episode?

Courtney: "My back is up against the wall, and not in a hot Chuck Bass kind of way." Gotta love Blair Waldorf.

Eric: No G? No favorite Gossip Girl quotes.

Leigh: Chuck coming to Blair's rescue at the atelier after she fainted. It was such a rare purely sweet moment between them, proving they are not just sex and scheming.

Steve: Leigh's use of "atelier" above. Best-written line of the week. That scene was also the most significant of the episode, plot-wise, which isn't saying a lot. Nice moment for the couple, whether they're "together" or not.

Gossip Girl Final Season Round Table Logo

2. Dan going dark: Long overdue or over the line?

Courtney: A little bit of both. He has been walked on and taken advantage of enough in the past that it is about time he grows a set. But his own father as his first public take down? That's where I draw the line.

Eric: Long overdue. I'm proud of my little outsider. I don't blame him. That little stunt Blair has basically pulled with him? Hell hath no fury like a Lonely Boy scorned.

Leigh: Both. It should be called Snapped: Dan Humphrey Edition. Really upset that he did Rufus and Nate dirty. Not liking this. I mean, Rufus and Ivy eww but still, he's always loved and supported Dan.

Steve: I don't have a problem with the book. He's a writer and if it's the truth and a great story, let him use it to bolster his career. Where I thought he crossed the line was selling out Nate, and in not apologizing to Rufus. "Dad, I'm sorry I published the story and didn't tell you, let's move on." That would've sufficed, but his ego is way too big at this point.

3. Harder to believe: Sage playing Serena and Blair, or anyone thinking that was actually risque.

Courtney: How to choose? S and B ran the UES at Sage's age, of course they should have realized what was going on. I don't think anyone would find that risque, especially in the fashion world. And I definitely don't think people would walk out on a show because of it.

Eric: Definitely thinking that movie was risque. I've seen Kendall Jenner bikini photos get less flak.

Leigh: Sage playing Serena and Blair. I am SO OVER HER. She's boring and bratty. I'm sorry but there is nobody who is "ten times worse than high school Serena." Implausible. SVDW is one of a kind.

Steve: I get that Sage used her father's relationship with Serena as leverage, but it was still a stretch. Not as much as of one as the idea that her display on the runway would make a New York crowd recoil in abject horror, but a stretch. Anyone who's been to New York Fashion Week knows you'll see far more than that on a nightly basis.

4. More uncomfortable couple to watch: Nate and 17-year-old Sage, or Rufus and con artist Ivy?

Courtney: I can't believe I am saying this... Nate and Sage. At least Ivy is of age!! Nate is the head of a media company that runs stories like the one he is currently in. I just can't imagine Nate would risk all of that for this brand new girl. Especially when he has already been with Vanessa. I mean let's face it, Sage looks just like her. In the UES princess sort of way.

Eric: Rivy for sure. Rufus is a weird emotionless robot puppy around her. It's awkward enough watching them from my couch. I can only imagine how uncomfortable it must have been for Dan to walk in on.

Leigh: This is terrible, I hate them both. I guess Rufus and Ivy is just extra messed up and entertaining at least. See above: I want Sage gone.

Steve: I have to take Nage, because I don't see why Nate is so into her, and because of the age thing. Dating a 17-year-old is one thing, but openly talking about stripping her naked just feels a little strange.

5. What will Blair and Chuck find in their quest to take down Bart?

Courtney: I really hope it has nothing to do with Chuck's mom/aunt/or whoever. I have to admit, I'm not that invested in this story yet. And I love me some Chuck Bass. It better be something great to have taken up this much  time of the final season.

Eric: Another incredibly lame reason not to be together.

Leigh: I actually have no idea where this storyline is going, but I assume some kind of dirty business deal. This is Bart Bass we're talking about, he got revived from the dead. I'm not sure the writers can shock us anymore when it comes to him.

Steve: Hopefully something interesting. One gets the sense they are running out the clock with this storyline. When and how will Chair get together for good? Is this anything more than a vehicle to reach that end or will it be entertaining on its own merit? Hopefully the latter, but how much do we really care about Bart at this point?

6. Gossip Girl Season 6 so far: Thumbs up or down?

Courtney: Blair/Chuck/Nate - Thumbs Up. Dan/Georgina/Adults - Thumbs Down. I'm thinking the end of the season will get a thumbs up if all of the spoilers I've seen come true.

Eric: Going one thumb up. Relative to last season? I may need to borrow some thumbs. Not a huge fan of the Chair and Rivy storylines, but loving the rest of the gang's adventures. I just need more G.

Leigh: Thumbs up, minus last week. I just need Blerena back together. You wanna know who I ship? I ship Blair Waldorf and Serena Van Der Woodsen as besties.

Steve: Can I punt this until the coming weeks reveal more of where the season is going? I liked the premiere a lot, with its great dialogue and intriguing premise. Since then it's lost some steam. Too many distractions and stories I'm having a hard time getting invested in, unfortunately.

7. In light of the recent Gossip Girl spoilers, share your updated endgame predictions.

Courtney: Blair and Chuck are getting married. For sure. Whether a cop comes and carts him off is a different story. But believe me, those vowels are getting said. Serena is going to end up with either Steven or Nate... there is no Humphrey in her future. Eric is going to be revealed as GG and Jenny will come back with him to remind us that raccoon eyes are still out of style.

Eric: I desperately try to avoid Gossip Girl spoilers, but when you work with enough TV Fanatics you're bound to hear something about all these wedding dresses. Obviously a Chair wedding. And if there's a Gossip Girl reveal, like Courtney, my money is still on Eric. So Serena is in a wedding dress supposedly? I smell a trick again.

Leigh: I really don't see how Serena could marry Dan after the way he's been treating her. It just doesn't make sense. Maybe it's a foiler and she really marries Nate? I have to believe that there were scenes filmed in studio that we didn't see. They wouldn't just leak everything. That said, I definitely think there is a flash forward after seeing that adorable little mini-Chuck running around on set. I think it will end with the reveal of GG, some romances, families reunited and with Dan and a successful author but not from being a d-bag.

Steve: A focus on the CORE CHARACTERS, and a happy ending for all. Is that too much to ask?

What do you think? Sound off in the comments!

Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.


My favorite quote: "Suck it, Humphrey". Does anyone else think Sage is seriously creepy? The rooftop scene could be one of Blair's nightmares, perhaps inspired by Charade.


By the way the answer to your position already gave @neddi^^, with which I agree.


@ sophia, Partially're right, Serena and Dan respect each other, the two of them built that during season 1 and 2! You are able to see that in season 5 when the conflict broke between Serena and Dan about his book, and they have confidence in each other - Dan believes without question to Serena and vice versa. Serena and Dan do not have a problem with trust in each other, but they are not yet old enough to understand what they want in their life, and most importantly how to achieve that! Also, Serena and Dan are completely identical in character of personality, and that's one of the reasons why they are connected! I would not write again passages and paragraphs, preferably @sophia that you watch season 1 and 2, as well as the 3x21 and 3x22 episode, and I guess you've watched season 4 and 5, in order to understand how deep the relationship between Serena and Dan is, and that flame of their love, in fact, has never ceased to burn! By the way the answer to your position already gave @neddi^^, with which I agree.


@neddi^^, Excellent, I totally agree with you!


@zoran you are right serena did hurt dan in season 4 but she didn't direspected dan the way he does. He dated her "best friend" and treated her like crap.Serena always respected dan at least i think so.I don't know all the derena love story so tell me if i am wrong


@zoran: well i think chair, derena and rufly have often hurt eachother so much. but they always come back to eachother. dan and blair broke serenas heart and ben broke dans heart. bart broke rufus heart, and ivy broke lilys heart.. the IP was the almost death from chair..chuck and jenny was hard for both too. but look now.. serena forgives dan. chuck and blair are again on good terms. lily can not be without rufus.. they talk again in 6.6 and they are friends again in 6.071 it doesnt matter how often this couples did hurt eachother.. the only fact is important here: they all can not be without eachother!


But Dan's relationship with Serena always been different than the other girls, because no love is easy but it is very complicated. Because why would Serena aids Dan to find a new home, or why Serena and Dan together write a story in which to indemnify their friends - because after what happened they should not even talk. But whenever Dan feels of losing Serena he go back to her and vice versa, as well as for Chuck and Blair! Sorry for the so long answer.


I think Dan's love for Blair was a test for him and her, how much Dan still loves Serena, and how much Blair loves Chuck! You need to remember that both Dan and Blair were hurt by Serena and Chuck in season 4 when they first connect. Serena told Dan in season 5 - Dan Humphrey I love you, always have, always will! - Dan was surprised by this statement, but he did not said that he does not love Serena! Dan is a complicated person, but can be summarized in one attitude – Dan, and his father Rufus too, has a weakness for girls in trouble! And when those same girls get out of trouble, Dan, and his father, does not know how to behave. As an example with Blair, where Dan acted as a knight in shining armor and a friend, and so fell in love with the illusion of Blair, not the kind of Blair as it is. But Dan's relationship with Serena always been different than the other girls, because no love is easy but it is very complicated. Because why would Serena aids Dan to find a new home, or why Serena and Dan together write a story in which to indemnify their friends - because after what happened they should not even talk. But whenever Dan feels of losing Serena he go back to her and vice versa, as well as for Chuck and Blair! Sorry for the so long answer.


@ QueenB, If you put that then any couple does not deserve to be together, even Serena and Dan or Chuck and Blair or Lily and Rufus. But that's not true, they all made mistakes with loved ones, however they still coming back to each other - Dan and Serena, Blair and Chuck, Rufus and Lily! On the other hand it is not the first time that Dan is in love with another girl, and it is not the first time that Serena is in love with another guy. But what makes the difference between the other partners of Serena and Dan is that the two of them stay connected, they have built trust between himself and the love between the two of them did not disappear! Serena and Dan are destined for each other, I know this is a cliche, but when you look from season 1 until now you will see that it is!


I'm surprised TV Fanatic hasn't posted the producers preview for 6x4. Maybe they are agreeing with me that those things don't help the episodes and instead seem to damage them?

Tags: ,