It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia Review: Science Is A Liar Sometimes

at . Comments

On this episode of It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia Season 8, "Reynolds vs. Reynolds: The Cereal Defense," a car accident causes The Gang to hold a mock trial that devolves into a debate about evolution.

Court at Paddy's Pub

I'll be honest: without knowing that this was this season finale, I thought this was the best episode of the past three years. Most finales up the ante and try to go over the top in their execution, but here The Gang gets back to basics; no recurring secondary characters, no guest stars, just The Gang at its finest: flip-flopping, back-stabbing, suspecting, accusing, tearing each other down and pumping each other up.

From the get-go, you could sense we were in store for a ridiculous chain of events - Charlie giving Frank driving directions... on tape. Frank barely able to see over the wheel much less through his coke bottle lenses. Dennis listening to a public radio program about composting while eating a bowl of cereal. 

While Dennis and Charlie gave exceptional performances during the mock trial, Mac really stole the show. The trial meter (only took three hours to make), the evolution meter (only took three hours to make), and the "Science Is a Liar... Sometimes" board belong right up there with 'The D.E.N.N.I.S. System' presentation. Mix in the exoneration of being donkey-brained certificate and I'd be shocked if the "Always Sunny Home Mock Trial" Kit isn't for sale in the FX merch store for last-minute Christmas gifting. 

Really, though, it's the little things that made this episode an instant classic. How about the dude drinking at the bar in the background the majority of the half hour? Dee's motives flying under the radar. Dennis' disdain for Mac claiming to be the tastemaker of the group. All classic. But I think it was the Law & Order-esque sound effects and black title cards interspersed throughout the proceedings that sealed the deal for me. 

Now that I know it was the finale, I don't know that they could've ended the season any better. The only minor note I have is that there wasn't really a setup for next year. Or, at least, so I thought. We've seen each character pushed to the brink of insanity - some more than others - and I feel like Dee has finally reached her wit's end.

Will Season 9 be the Season of Sour Dee? What amazes me most is that's just one of many storylines The Gang can roll out, which is unbelievably impressive after eight years. 


Editor Rating: 4.5 / 5.0
  • 4.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.8 / 5.0 (24 Votes)

I have been a fan since the first episode and I loved recent show! I can't believe more people aren't watching this show!


I definitely thought Mack was the star of this episode, which is good to see in a season dominated by Dennis. In the early seasons, Mack was my favorite character, but was replaced by Dennis in the past few seasons. I like the episodes where it takes places almost entirely in the bar and mostly among themselves. No group of characters has chemistry quite like them, and when they are constantly verbally attacking each other is always great. I'm glad I wasn't the only one that noticed the guy in the background the whole time even before he got up and actually had a line. Classic ending of the gang eventually just blaming Dee for something she had nothing to do with, and put a cap on to this seasons theme of recycling old material. Can't wait for season 9, I hope we get 13 episodes next year!


I thought this was a terrible episode. Dennis is becoming increasingly angry (he did not always yell so much) and his character lacks the missplaced yet somehow effetive self confidence seen in such classics as the D.E.N.N.I.S. system. Dee is essentially an after thought at this point and the predictable ending that once again everything is blamed on Dee was boring. The board taking 3 hours was such an obvious joke the second time around and going with an evolution vs. religion theme was unneeded and again boring. Also, Mack's arguements were far to historically accurate for Mack. Frankly, the argument that it was Frank's fault for taking the wine glass was far to sensible for Mack. I guess I just didn't get it. This episode seemed lazy and self indulgent.


this episode was one of the greatest episodes they've ever done. This is the kinda stuff they've been straying away from lately and should be returning to in the majority of episodes. They need to stop thinking up plots to put the gang in and just let the social interactions of the gang lead the plot naturally.

Tags: ,

It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia Season 8 Episode 10 Quotes

Charlie: Ladies and gentlemen, distinguished collies. My client, Frank here, isn't really on trial today, ya know. Common sense is on trial. And while common sense would tell you that eating a bowl of cereal while operating a car it's reckless, it's moronic, one might even call it, 'donkey-brained'.
Dennis: Donkey-brained?
Charlie: It means to have the brains of a donkey or a donkey-type creature.
Dennis: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I think I know what it means, guy.

Dee: Dennis, you don't want to go anywhere near a court. How many bench warrants for sexual misconduct do you have? Yeah, and Frank, how many unregistered guns do you have in your car right now?
Frank: A lot.