Sunday's episode of Revenge saw the ABC melodrama finally show us what happened aboard The Amanda, while a number of events unfolded on and offshore that may prove series-altering.
Below, TVF's Miranda Wicker, Kate Brooks, Steve Marsi, Leigh Raines and Christine Orlando break down the latest installment and look ahead to March's return in our Round Table Q&A.
Weigh in with your own responses to these Revenge topics below!
1. What was your favorite quote or scene from "Sacrifice"?
Miranda: Simple. Four words. "I love you, too." Emily guards her heart and tries not to let people in. Even though she's used Amanda all these years, she did care about her.
Kate: The "I love you" and "I love you too" between Emily and Fauxmanda. Though I was sobbing during this scene it was nice to hear Emily say the words and mean it.
Christine: Emily holding Amanda as she died. It was the first time I think I've seen real pain and grief from Emily and it was heartbreaking. "You've given me the one thing I thought I'd never have. A real family."
Leigh: I want to vary this up but it's not even possible because that end scene between two girls who became sisters was so touching. I love that Emily told Nolan to leave with Jack that she had to go back for Amanda. Then when Amanda insisted on grabbing the necklace she seemed so stupid but that flashback was the best part.
Steve: Make it (almost) a clean sweep for the Emily-Amanda farewell. One of the most memorable moments in show history, putting the exclamation point on a terrific episode.
2. Was this the best episode of Revenge Season 2?
Miranda: YES! Yes. It absolutely was the best. In fact, aside from Jack and Amanda being married, it didn't even feel like part of this season. It felt like an episode from Revenge Season 1. Easily the best of the season so far.
Kate: Yes. It had the same intense feeling I remember having during the end of Revenge Season 1.
Christine: Absolutely. I didn't get the ending that I'd hoped for but it kept me on the edge of my seat and I really cared about what happened at the end.
Leigh: Definitely. It felt like a different season altogether! Season 2 has kinda dragged but this had me in tears.
Steve: This is the first time in awhile that I'm still thinking about it days later, and genuinely excited to learn where Revenge will take us next ... so that has to mean yes, right?
3. Will Jack survive?
Miranda: Yes, he will. While I love Emily with Aiden, I think she's supposed to end up (many, many seasons from now) with Jack. Or Jack is at least destined to know the truth about Emily's real identity. He can't learn that if he dies. And Carl needs his dad!
Kate: Of course! Jack and Emily are endgame and I was wondering what they would do to get FauxManda out of the picture. Sadly, they killed her.
Christine: Can I bribe the writers to kill him off? Amanda may have been crazy but she had guts and was never boring. I'm a fan of actor Michael Trucco so I was disappointed to see him die as well. I know I'm in the minority here, but I've always thought Jack was a bit of a wuss and dull beyond words. Now if he survives, which I'm sure he will, we'll be stuck watching a grieving Jack. Ugh.
Leigh: Well duh they already showed him at the funeral in previews.
Steve: I think so. As Miranda and Kate said, he's too central to the arc of the show to die in this fashion, and losing Amanda, while tragic, clears the way for a new path for his character - and Emily's
4. Will Emily regain her focus on "Retribution"? How/where will she start?
Miranda: She absolutely will, probably to the point of shutting people out again. She'll start with Conrad and ending his ridiculous run for governor before it really gets off the ground.
Kate: I agree with Miranda here. I think Emily will go "hard" again, which will be nice to see. Her main target will be Conrad and Victoria. Though, I do want her to expose Conrad at his most vulnerable point - how about when he is just ABOUT to be elected. That's the "old" style of Revenge, waiting until their most exposed to expose them for who they are.
Christine: Watching her pseudo sister in Revenge die will definitely light a fire under her. The Graysons won't know what hit them but I feel bad for poor Charlotte. That girl can't catch a break.
Leigh: Yes and she will always go back to Graysons. Sometimes I'm bored of them but Victoria and Conrad keep it interesting.
Steve: I'd watch my back if I were Charlotte. Or Daniel.
5. The Graysons' plan to throw off The Initiative: Will it work?
Miranda: I think it worked for the moment, but the Initiative is too smart for that to work for long. They'll see it as too convenient that Amanda is dead and will probably look into her death. Now I wonder if it was them on the diving expedition at the beginning of "Sacrifice." If they find her body and discover her identity, things will get really interesting for Emily.
Kate: Yes and no. I think they will always somehow circle back to the Graysons.
Christine: To be honest, I'm a bit tired of the Initiative plot. Victoria and Conrad are crafty enough to throw them off for a while but I doubt the Initiative ever plans to release them from their claws.
Leigh: For now or at least I'm hoping. I wonder if the writers know the audience is getting bored of The Initiative and their creepy voyeurism.
Steve: Obviously the Initiative will not be easily duped or defeated, but you almost have to credit the Graysons here. It takes SERIOUS brass to pull off, conceal and frame someone for a MURDER, then launch a high-profile political campaign in the midst of the cover-up.
6. Will Conrad be elected Governor of New York State?
Miranda: Oh no. No. Emily will see to it that his name never makes it onto the ballot.
Kate: No. Emily won't let that happen, she'll expose him before. Or at least I hope.
Christine: I think Emily will let him get this close and then snatch it all away in the most humiliating way possible.
Leigh: I doubt Emily would allow that but you never know on this show. He might get close but he's got too many skeletons in closet.
Steve: Will he actually win an election and serve in the position? It's hard to envision that ... the show's set in the Hamptons, not Albany. I hope they run with this storyline for awhile, though. He's pretty perfect as a smooth-talking, morally bankrupt, shady and corrupt political candidate.
7. Write a brief eulogy for FauxManda.
Miranda: Farewell FauxManda, we knew you sort of well. You had amazing hair.
Kate: Goodbye to the woman who stole Amanda's Clarke true love whilst posing to be Amanda Clarke. A character who should have only been around for a few episodes but ended up over welcoming her stay by getting pregnant. Rest in Peace FauxManda, well, the real Emily Thorne.
Christine: With a tire iron in one hand and a baby in the other, FauxManda you will not be forgotten.
Leigh: From the moment you came on the scene in a tire iron and pranced around in your red bikini, you had everyone's attention. Impulsive and careless at times you were still the sister the real Amanda Clarke never had. Rest in peace real Emily Thorne.
Steve: FauxManda. We hardly knew ye. Scrappy. Unabashed. Loyal. A fighter 'til the end. Your devotion to Jack, baby Carl and Emily will never be forgotten, nor will your hair by any woman who ever laid eyes on you. The Beaver Dam's profits will undoubtedly take a hit after this. [*points skyward*]
Want more Revenge?
Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!