It came down to the Final Four on The Bachelor Season 18 Episode 8.
During the two-hour broadcast, Juan Pablo joined Andi, Clare, Nikki and Renee in their hometowns for what it always an explosive installment of the franchise - and this year was no different.
There was drama. There were major surprises. And there were quite a few family members across the board wondering about Juan Pablo's intentions with their daughters.
Is he really in this for the right reason? Why should they trust a reality star?
Watch The Bachelor online to see how Juan Pablo responded and, of course, to see who was sent home: