Toby Cavanaugh is Jenna's stepbrother. He was blackmailed by Allison, and took the blame for blinding his stepsister. He has also been threatened by Jenna, and forced to have sexual relations with her. He was a suspect in Allison's murder, but his name is now clear.
I may have broken my left arm, but my right arm is fine.Toby (to Wren)
You know I could come with you, and I could rub your shoulders between rounds and wrap your knuckles and hold your spit bucket.Toby