Audrey's forced to protect criminals when there's a vigilante on the loose on Haven. "Double Jeopardy" is the fifth episode of the show's third season.
Added:

Haven Season 3 Episode 5 Quotes

Parker, the bolt gun killer has the tattoo. He's one of the guard, and I'm getting in with them.

Nathan

They took his eyes out with a spoon. His eyes.

Audrey