Elizabeth: (To Neal) Why don't you just ask her out?
Peter: Good point. (To Neal) Do you think it will work?
Elizabeth: (Without hesitation) Yes!

Neal: You think I'm still a thief?
Taylor: Fish don't do well out of water.

No dusting, no smiling.....

Guilty people do guilty things. Am I wrong?

In three months, you could be a free man.

Peter: Tell me you're wrong.
Neal: You're wrong.

Elizabeth: What do you think he was going to say?
Peter: I don't know.
Elizabeth: Do you think he was going to leave Kate?
Peter: I don't know. Doesn't matter.
Elizabeth: I think it matters.
Peter: Why, it's kind of a mute point now.
Elizabeth: It matters to you.

Neal [to Peter]: What do you say Newman? Ready to con the mob out of half a million?
Peter: Lead the way, kid.

You have a lot of rules for someone who doesn't play by them.

Don't give me the be careful speech, I invented the be careful speech.

It's like their speaking Criminese.

Caffrey: How upset were the Canadians?
Peter: Oh, very... well, as upset as Canadians can get.