Calvin: Where's the fire department? The S.W.A.T. team? Why is it just you two crawling around down here?
Abbie: Because we don't know enough about the situation yet.
Calvin: Then tell me what you do know.

Franklin choked with envy when he saw it.

Jefferson

Ichabod: I had no idea that a man out of time was itself such a time worn literary trope.
Abbie: Oh sure Doctor Who, Connecticut Yankee, Marty McFly; the list goes on.
Ichabod: Here I thought I was rather unique.
Abbie: Don't worry, you're the only one in the non-fiction section.

Abbie: If we're dealing with a witch problem, we have to call Katrina.
Ichabod: Since our encounter with the warlock, Solomon Kent, Katrina has been distant; withdrawn.

General Washington made a pact with our coven. If we helped win the war, witches would finally reintegrate into society. A promise he reneged on and one that must be reconciled at any cost.

Katrina

Katrina: I am sorry it took me so long to see the truth. The idea that a mortal man and I could truly make a life together.
Ichabod: Be wary, what you say now can not be unsaid.
Katrina: In a way, it is a relief to finally be able to speak it.

I recall there were two witnesses in the book of revelation. We've been here before, you bare your teeth then you back down. You don't have what it takes to do violence to your only son.

Henry

Ichabod: You've not learned a thing since Moloch dragged you from your fetid box.
Henry: Moloch was self-righteous and self-serving like you. He abandoned me just as you did.
Ichabod: I did not abandon you, Henry. I did not even know you existed.
Ichabod: You've not learned a thing since Moloch dragged you from your fetid box.
Henry: Moloch was self-righteous and self-serving like you. He abandoned me just as you did.
Ichabod: I did not abandon you, Henry. I did not even know you existed.

Ichabod: You have no tangible information; good day.
Abbie: The Horseman is not working alone. He has an ally now, one equally as dangerous. A woman, to make sure you die on that battlefield.

Abbie: You're even on the hundred dollar bill.
Franklin: A hundred! How about that Ichabod, a hundred dollar bill? What is Jefferson on?
Abbie: Two dollar bill.
Franklin: The two? The two, does anyone even use the two? Sounds cumbersome.
Ichabod: I think that's quite enough, thank you.
Franklin: No it is not. We're standing in front of a woman who's two centuries ahead of us; brilliant, educated, well spoken. What is your profession?
Abbie: Ah Sheriff Detective.
Franklin: Officer of the law, Ichabod. Everything we're striving for here. Fighting with our dying breath to create for this country. A free land of opportunity for all Ms. Abigail Mills represents. She is the American Dream.

Ichabod: I'm here to save you. Though it appears Sutton is in greater need.
Abbie: Better late than never. What made you come back?
Ichabod: I viewed a moving picture, in which you and I attempted to create a still picture.
Abbie: A selfie.
Ichabod: Yes, as you said. Everything you said is true; we're partners.
Abbie: More than that, we're friends.

Ichabod: It will be a pleasure to make your acquaintance all over again Ms. Mills. Yes?
Abbie: It's just, you don't speak to me so formally in the future.
Ichabod: Then what would you prefer?
Abbie: Lieutenant.
Ichabod: Well leftenant, let us change the course of history... again.

Sleepy Hollow Quotes

Abbie: Who is he? When's the last time you saw him?
Ichabod: When I cut off his head.

Police Detective: Do you admit to cutting off his head, yes or no?
Ichabod: Nooo. First I shot him, then he rose back up. Cutting off his head seemed the next logical step.