On American Horror Story: Freak Show Season 4 Episode 12, the troupe celebrates Elsa's departure and welcomes Chester to their family. Before she can go, they must first handle Richard Spencer, aka Stanley. Now that they know the truth about his double dealings, they plan to enact their own punishment on him.

He runs into the pouring rain only to be surrounded by freaks on every side and finds himself their victim. Later, they discuss Ethel's death and arrive at the conclusion that it wasn't a suicide.

Elsa and Maggie visit Jimmy who is upset that his father is dead. Despite his protests, Elsa assigns Maggie to be his caregiver and she is determined to win his trust and prove her loyalty. Elsa has called upon an old friend to help restore Jimmy. 

Chester angers Marjorie when he puts her away during a tryst with the Tattler sisters. The doll decides the twins have to go. Dandy Mott visits the girls to share with them the information he's learned about Chester. After reading the file, Bette and Dot tell Chester they no longer wish to be his magic assistant and Maggie volunteers in their place.

Bette and Dot decide to warn Elsa that the monsters are coming for her. She brokers a deal to save herself.