After Josh reveals that he still loves her, Rebecca is trying to decide who she will choose, even making a list for each one. She can't decide and then gets a call about Audra leaving her husband and three kids for Las Vegas.

She decides to take that as a way out of deciding, going down to Las Vegas and finding Audra. First, she doesn't want to go back with her but after an illegal poker game, Audra realizes she hit rock bottom and goes back.

The guys all end up seeing the list and decide as a group to figure this out once and for all. Once Rebecca comes back they all present her with a plan. She gets a single date with all of them, and then she chooses who she wants to be with. 

Meanwhile, Heather gets frustrated by how she has become Hector's mother in a sense. She comes back from Las Vegas and makes it clear that they are partners. 

Also, Valencia wants Beth to propose to her. She tells her she either does it now or she won't come back to NY. Then in Las Vegas she sees how a frenemy of hers made her fiance propose to her and she doesn't want to be that person. She says sorry to Beth, who tells her that it doesn't mean marriage is off the table forever and Valencia could also just propose herself too.