The events take place on October 3, 1993, 1994, and 1995.

In 1995, the lawyers state their opening statements for the court case. The statements pit the case between Jeanette and Kate. Past flashbacks show Jeanette and Jamie together, and Martin and Kate together in his house.

In 1994, Kate is getting ready for The Marsha Bailey Show; Joy picked out her outfit and Rod wishes her well. The scene shows Kate accusing Jeanette on live TV. Meanwhile, Jeanette is cutting her hair in front of the mirror.

In 1995, the reporters are swarming Jeanette outside of the courthouse. Jeanette is talking with Jamie about the trial.

Kate is having a chatroom conversation; she's worried that she'll slip during her testimony. Later that night, Jeanette is eating ice cream with her father.

During the testimony, Kate states that Martin picked her up in her car and drugged her before trapping her in the car. Jeanette's lawyer uses the chatroom conversation in her questioning against Kate. The news is revealed that Kate went to Martin's house willingly.

Kate's lawyer reveals that the chatroom has been with Ashley. The lawyer wants her to be completely honest with her or else the trial will suffer.

Jamie goes to visit Ben and apologizes for driving drunk/causing the accident. Jamie tells Ben that Vince didn't do anything wrong either.

Kate is upset that "Berenice" turned out to be Ashley; she wanted someone to talk to who experienced her situation. Kate tells Mallory that she wants to go through her tapes to discover Annabelle.

Ben visits Vince at the video store to apologize for abandoning him. Vince is upset, but Ben wants Vince to forgive him and try again.

Kate sneaks into Martin's house; she reminisces over the abandoned furniture. Jeanette enters the house; Kate had asked her to attend to get the full story. Jeanette and Kate argue about the truth; Kate thinks Jeanette stole her life and did dirty tricks, but Jeanette thinks Kate destroyed her life.

Kate claims Jeanette saw her, but Jeanette is adamant that she didn't. Kate and Jeanette explain the time during Christmas Eve; Kate claims she saw a hooded Jeanette outside getting on her bike. Jeanette reveals that the bike (the blue bike with the stereo and the playing card) belongs to Mallory. Mallory was the one who saw Kate at the window.

A flashback from 1993 reveals that Mallory stumbled on Jeanette sneaking into Martin's house; she wanted to get Jeanette busted. Mallory saw a darkened window, but she saw a blonde figure earlier. Jeanette gave Mallory the snow globe after Mallory accused her of being holier than thou.

Kate apologizes to Jeanette for being wrong about the accusation. Kate reveals to Jeanette what happened between her and Martin in the house, but she can't remember Annabelle; she needs to go into the basement.

A flashback shows Martin with a gun; he informs Kate that the police came over. "Annabelle" is a family heirloom gun he had; the gun was the same one his family used to commit suicide. He wants her to live a long life. He stops himself from killing himself, but when he drops the gun, Kate grabs the gun and points it at him. He changes his mind and wants to be with her; Kate fires the gun and kills Martin.

She tells Jeanette that she stayed with the body all night before calling the cops. A flashback shows Jeanette and Jamie hearing the gunshot.

Kate comes cleans the next day at the courthouse about clearing Jeanette's name.

Kate confronts Mallory about the snow globe and seeing her. Mallory was packing and reveals that she did see Kate in the window, but she only saw her from behind and thought it was someone else. Mallory didn't know it was Kate until the news report was shown of Kate escaping Martin's house. Mallory kept the secret to herself because she didn't want it part of her business.

Kate forgives Mallory and doesn't want her to leave town.

A flash-forward to a month later has Jeanette being interviewed on The Marsha Bailey Show. Marsha apologizes to her for the part she played in the scandal. Jeanette reveals she dropped the lawsuit and only wanted the truth to be exposed. Jeanette apologizes to Kate live on air.

Mallory and Kate are still friends; they're dancing in front of the car. Kate kisses Mallory.

In 1994, a flashback is shown of Jeanette sneaking into Martin's house again. Jeanette heard Kate yelling from the basement and left her in there. Jeanette knew all this time that Kate was in the basement.