The Slutty Pumpkin How I Met Your Mother Pics: What Almost Was...
Also known as Naomi and played by the adorable Katie Holmes, the Slutty Pumpkin haunted Ted for years. She was the girl who got away in season 1 after he lost her phone number and every Halloween, Ted would go to the same party dressed as a hanging chad in the hopes of finding her. It took until season 7 and the reality never quite lived up to the fantasy in his head.
Want more How I Met Your Mother?
Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!