Skip to Content

The Rainmaker Early Review: A Legal Drama That Remembers TV Is Supposed to Be Fun

Critic's Rating: 4 / 5.0
4

We’ve been conditioned lately to think every legal drama has to be shadowy, brooding, and “prestige” in order to matter. 

The Rainmaker, USA’s new spin on the John Grisham classic, begs to differ. It’s not trying to be The Night Of or even Goliath. And thank goodness.

This is the kind of show you can actually look forward to watching — not just “survive” in 50-minute chunks — because it’s built for enjoyment. It’s slick, it’s soapy, and yes, it has a few rough edges, but that’s precisely why it works.

(USA Network/Screenshot)

The case at the center — a grieving mother convinced the hospital killed her son — has stakes, but the show never gets lost in the kind of cynical spiral that prestige TV loves. 

There’s room for moments that breathe, banter that’s actually fun, and a willingness to let relationships be messy without every scene dripping with existential despair.

That lighter touch is not a flaw; it’s the feature.

Suits didn’t conquer Netflix because it was the sharpest legal drama on the planet — it conquered because it was fun to live in that world. 

The Rainmaker is tapping that same well, offering a familiar network-TV gloss while telling a story you actually want to follow week to week.

(USA Network/Screenshot)

Some critics have complained that the leads are too green.

Maybe they are. But TV used to be the place where actors became stars, not just where they parked after they already were. 

Milo Callaghan’s Rudy and Madison Iseman’s Sarah are at the start of their arcs — both the characters’ and the actors’ — and watching them grow alongside the story is part of the investment.

Pairing them with heavy-hitters like John Slattery and Lana Parrilla isn’t a liability; it’s mentorship in real time.

Speaking of Parrilla, her Bruiser is already getting the “too crass” treatment in some corners. That’s selling her short. 

(USA Network/Screenshot)

Yes, Bruiser leads with bravado and more than a few eyebrow-raising one-liners, but by the time you’ve seen her in a quiet moment, you realize it’s all armor.

Cracks are showing — the kind that hint at a backstory worth sticking around for.

The Rainmaker also benefits from its willingness to expand beyond the courtroom. Deck’s side hustles, Melvin Pritcher’s ominous wanderings, and even Rudy’s awkward hallway run-ins with his neighbor all add texture. 

This isn’t a straight procedural; it’s a world. One where not every subplot sticks the landing, sure, but where you never feel like you’ve been trapped in the same stale conference room for 43 minutes.

Is it perfect? No. But it doesn’t need to be. It needs to be watchable, rewatchable, and just addictive enough to make you hit “Next Episode” before you realize it’s midnight. And it is.

(USA Network/Screenshot)

If TV is going to keep thriving in the binge era, it can’t be all prestige heaviness and streaming exclusivity. 

We need shows that make space for fresh talent, that entertain without exhausting, and that understand there’s room for levity in a story about fighting for justice.

The Rainmaker gets that. And it’s worth celebrating.

The Rainmaker premieres on USA Network on Friday, August 15 at 10/9c.

Ron G

Saturday 23rd of August 2025

Commercials seem to come very fast.

J.Aleese

Saturday 16th of August 2025

"Some critics have complained that the leads are too green" -- I don't agree that they're "TOO green", but even so, that's another feature not a bug, seeing as those characters are very green in their law careers. And "too crass"? Please, they wouldn't be saying that if the character was still a man.

sarah

Wednesday 13th of August 2025

I am looking forward to the show, Lana is great actress, especially Once A Upon A Time and Lincoln Lawyer. Tv Line gave it a negative review, when Dave does the reviews, almost also negative. I want to fun, this show right in my wheelhouse.

J.Aleese

Saturday 16th of August 2025

@Jasmine Blu, The television industry seems to have reached a peak in its inferiority complex next to cinema. So many shows--especially the "prestige", especially the streamers--wanna be movies so bad.

Jasmine Blu

Wednesday 13th of August 2025

Lana Parilla is such a fun actress. I'm so excited about her being in another project.

I think we've reached a point in the industry where everyone expects high-brown, high-caliber, Emmy-chasing series at all times, and it's just not realistic. It isn't fun either.

Laura Nowak

Wednesday 13th of August 2025

I'm excited for this one. I love the premise, and have been a Lana Parrilla fan for years. I was relieved to read your positive review after all the negativity, and that gives me hope.

Carissa Pavlica

Wednesday 13th of August 2025

You know who we are at TV Fanatic. Everyone else is searching for an Oscar winner. Screw that. I want to enjoy myself, and I'm sick of having to seek that enjoyment out from other countries and in the past because my own failed me. Let's have fun on TV again!!!!

Most Commented

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!