Skip to Content

I’m Relieved Boston Blue Will Carry On This Aspect Of Blue Bloods’ Legacy

Blue Bloods is so closely associated with family dinners that it’s easy to overlook its other legacy.

The Reagans weren’t just a family sitting around the dinner table. They were a family of cops — and that’s an important distinction.

One of Blue Bloods’ other missions was to portray what life is like for cops, both on and off duty, and it’s exciting that Boston Blue is continuing that legacy.

(Michele Crowe/CBS)

Blue Bloods was very different than other cop shows because it was committed to showing cops’ perspectives and let people make up their own minds whether they agreed.

I wasn’t sure that Boston Blue would follow suit. It’s a new show with new writers, and I was worried that it would shoehorn Danny into a foreign concept that didn’t feel like it belonged to the same franchise.

Danny standing on a busy street on the phone on Blue Bloods/Boston Blue
(John Paul Filo/CBS)

Fortunately, Donnie Wahlberg put that fear to rest during a recent press event promoting the fall schedule.

The beloved star explained that he’d spoken with many police officers around the United States over the past 14 years who appreciated seeing families like his own on TV, and that he wanted to do the same thing with Boston Blue.

That excites me even more than the return of family dinners (without spoiling anything, I’ve seen the premiere and can confirm that there is a family dinner that is both different and the same as what the Reagans did every week).

I’ve seen some comments that Boston Blue being too similar to Blue Bloods means it’s trying to copy the magic without the Reagan family, but I disagree.

Danny holds up his badge against a blurry background on Blue Bloods/Boston Blue
(John Paul Filo/CBS)

Blue Bloods‘ family dinners were intertwined with the fact that this was a family of cops that we all saw as being like us.

That same message is infused into Boston Blue’s DNA, and that’s a good thing.

Boston Blue Also Relies on Consultants and Real Police

If the new writers were making up cop interactions out of whole cloth, I’d be annoyed enough to skip Boston Blue.

But that’s not what’s happening here.

Danny standing by a wall full of graffiti, thinking, on Blue Bloods/Boston Blue
(John Paul Filo/CBS)

Sonequa Martin-Green, who plays Danny’s partner, talked at the press day about consulting with real detectives and learning to shoot a gun properly as part of her preparation for the role of Lena.

Her description felt both reassuring and comforting to me. 

I read articles about Blue Bloods using a retired NYPD officer as a full-time consultant, and it sounded like Boston Blue is doing the same thing.

I was skeptical about Boston Blue for all the reasons that many Blue Bloods fans are.

Danny standing and looking shocked with his hands in his pockets on Blue Bloods Season 14 Episode 18
(CBS/Michael Parmalee)

And no, it will never be Blue Bloods 2.0. You can’t just send Danny to another city and substitute another family for the Reagans.

Fortunately, that’s not what this show is doing.

Blue Bloods Had a Fantastic Legacy

Instead, the offshoot has taken the best of the mothership and combined it with their own ideas.

It’s an interesting experiment, and one that I’m getting more and more behind now that I know what it’s actually about and how the show will explore its Blue Bloods connection.

(CBS/John Paul Filo)

What about you? Are you eager to watch or still skeptical?

Either way, I want to hear your thoughts!

Your passion is what keeps TV Fanatic alive, so don’t hold back.

Hit the comments with your opinions about these latest Boston Blue developments, and share this article with your friends so they can join in the fun.

If you’re interested in more procedurals, check out our coverage of Elsbeth, High Potential, and Matlock.

Watch Boston Blue Online

TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.

Brian

Saturday 8th of November 2025

So far the episodes are horrible. Very disappointing . New cast members are so so. Nothing special about them. Adding the dinner sequence on the show as it was on Blue Bloods terrible. Don’t know who’s at the dinner table and why are certain ones there to begin with. Will give it a few more episodes to watch but it will never last 14 years as Blue Bloods did.

Jack Ori

Monday 10th of November 2025

Sorry you're not enjoying it. I'm loving it. I think it has a lot in common with Blue Bloods whle still being its own show.

Allen

Monday 8th of September 2025

The real magic of "Blue Bloods" was the combination of the police procedurals and the impact on the families associated with those mini-dramas. The personal interactions among the various family members are the special sauce that made the entire meal so enjoyable. It is hard to imagine that Donnie alone (with other cast members) will be able to bring that "togetherness" to the screen. But, good luck.

Carissa Pavlica

Monday 8th of September 2025

It's like a foster family. He will be attending another family's dinners. No reason it can't work.

sarah

Monday 8th of September 2025

I am still skeptical, I did not like the trailer, or, hiding Mika, playing Sean, I am wondering how thick is the Canadian accent? Sean is the reason, Danny goes to "Boston", Sean shown no interest being a cop, last time we saw the character he was over weight. Filming in Toronto does not help. When show filmed in Boston, because Roger's Stadium, cannot look like Fenway Park. You have seen the first episode, enjoyed the premiere episode, I am more open to the show. Blue Bloods, is on my favorite shows, have been fan since the first season. Blue Bloods was different than you typical CBS procedurals. I would have preferred to seen a Jamie and Joe spinoff, I enjoyed their relationship.

Most Commented

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!