I don't know what it was that shifted that night, but I could feel it.

James [to Sophie]

The games rigged, remember? So let's even the playing field.

Sophie [to James]

Sophie: This place seemed like a fresh start. Like I could be anyone I wanted. I mean, that's the myth of California, isn't it? You are who you say you are. And if it doesn't work out here, then on to somewhere new.
James: So, who do you say you are?
Sophie: I haven't decided yet.
James: You know I got this weird feeling that, you could be anyone you wanted.

Thanks for coming, Officer.

James [to Baden]

Baden: There's nothing wrong with you, Sophie.
Sophie: But what if there is? What if this is something that's always been in me?
Baden: You decide who you are.
Sophie: Yeah, I hope you're right.

Pretty soon, this will all be over. And all you have to do is be yourself.

Baden [to Sophie]

Sophie: It's Caroline's gala. She's expecting us to be there.
James: I don't care about Caroline.
Sophie: That's a mean thing to say about my best friend. Especially since you two were fucking.

Caroline: You seem different.
Sophie: Maybe I am.

James: You're the fucking guy.
Baden: No, you're the fucking guy.

Hannah: I’ve told you before. Those clinics are dangerous. Especially for someone like you.
Sophie: Someone like me?
Hannah: Someone who’s still fragile.

Harrison: Yeah, well, you better be right because, um, I might believe you when you say none of this is really your fault. No one else will.
James: Look, I’m not gonna let this mistake ruin my life or yours.

Look, I know you want what’s best for Sophie. It’s a lot more complicated than that. Sometimes stirring up the past, it does more harm than good.

James [to Caroline]

Surface Quotes

Sophie: I need you to know something. What happened before will never, ever happen again. The girl who did that, I don't even recognize. However fucked up I might be, I don't want to die.
James: I know.

Baden: Your husband's coming. Look he's not who you think he is, okay? He's not telling you everything.
Sophie: What are you talking about?
Baden: You ever think there's more to what happened on the boat that day?