A person is being pulled out of the school on a stretcher before Naomi is questioned about aliens in Port Oswego by an unknown person.

Throughout the hour, people are questioned by a mysterious interviewer about what happened at the party.

Flashbacking to the party, Naomi, Annabelle, and Jacob discuss who the alien at the party could be. They have everyone at the party give over their social media handles so Jacob can track their pages and triangulate who was on Naomi's street the night the disc was taken.

They discover that the three people at the party on Naomi's street that night were Nathan, Anthony, and Lourdes.

Commander Steel visits Dee, and Dee later calls Zumbado, as the two wonder about what Steel knows. They head to the party, and Greg tells them about Steel finding Naomi's birth rock. Jen and Zumbado then head to base to access Steel's computer.

The kids play 'Never Have I Ever' to discover who the alien is. But Naomi cannot pinpoint who the alien is, and she and Nathan disagree about not being honest with one another.

Jacob reveals that aliens can emit blue eyes in photographs processed in a specific chemical. Jacob takes pictures of all the guests while Naomi goes to the school with Lourdes to obtain the chemicals needed to process the film.

Steel shows up at the party and tells Greg that he knows Greg is hiding something and gives him a chance to come clean.

Jen gets access to Steel's computer, and they discover that he knows Naomi is an alien.

Naomi sees Nathan at the school at her locker, and she confronts him about lying to her. He reveals that he put flowers and pictures in her locker to ask her to prom. But when Naomi tries to apologize, he leaves.

Steel approaches her at the school, revealing an S-RUD device. An unknown person causes Steel to collapse, and we discover that he was the person taken out on the stretcher earlier in the episode.

It's also revealed that everyone was interrogated by military police, who found evidence on Steel's computer of him being obsessed with aliens and targeting the McDuffie's. This information is on there, thanks to Jen planting it there.

When Naomi develops the last roll of film, she sees herself and her parents emitting blue eyes, as it's revealed they made Steel collapse at the school.