Mabel has a dream delivering a podcast, Oliver, and Charles.

Oliver wakes Mabel up who had dozed off at the hospital bedside. The doctor discharges Oliver from hospital.

They decide to try and get Loretta cleared of the murder charges but they have to prove Dickie wasn't that killer.

The trio interviews Dicie who provides an alibi on the night of Ben's murder.

The trio visits a location Ben frequented which they think is a brothel but it turns to be a sewing shop where Ben sew the hankies he gave the cast.

The seamstresses' reveal Ben was their friend and he was anxious on opening night. They had promised to be present on the opening night.

The trio creates a timeline for the 30 minutes before Ben's death. They watch Detective Williams' interview tapes and imagine themselves in the scenes.

They recreate all the scenes from the slap, to Ben firing Tobert.

Mabel reveals that she had turned thirty that same day.

Howard pieces the shredded paper and Oliver notices that the original document was Maxine's review of the play.

Charles and Oliver sing Mabel a happy birthday song.

Mabel realizes that Ben was speaking to a cookie he ate before hitting the stage.

They figure out that it was Donna who shred the review that panned Ben as bad performer so she poisoned the cookie.

The trio rushes to the courtroom where Loretta is due for sentencing. They find Donna in the courtroom.