Skip to Content

When Calls the Heart Season 13 Episode 1 Highlights Love, Community, and Better Writing

Critic's Rating: 4.2 / 5.0
4.2

Many Hearties have been divided about the writing in the last few seasons of When Calls the Heart.

Having story arcs, such as Little Jack’s diabetes or Goldie National Park, has helped immensely because they have brought the community together again, which has always been the heart of the series.

On When Calls the Heart Season 13 Episode 1, Elizabeth, Nathan, and the kids are scheduled to return to Hope Valley, but they learn that the railroad closed, so the inspector can’t come to approve the diabetes clinic.

(David Dolsen/Hallmark Media)

Most of the episode felt bittersweet because they assumed it was only a quick visit home, and no one wanted to leave because it was home.

Hope Valley needed to find a way to lift Elizabeth’s spirits and to help her and Little Jack stay permanently.

When Calls the Heart Teaches Us to Believe When It’s Darkest Before Dawn

My heart went out to Elizabeth (Erin Krakow). Nothing is more complicated than being away from your main support people, trying to keep your spirits up for the kids, and then everything crashing.

While Jack missed his friends, it was even more complicated for Allie, who wanted to spend her senior year with them. 

(Ricardo Hubbs/ Hallmark Media)

Elizabeth had never missed teaching school, so she longed for her schoolhouse as well.

While Nathan promised they were in this together and he meant well, it was challenging to cheer either of his girls up.

Elizabeth has always been the center of Hope Valley, so it was heartwarming to see how happy everyone was to have her back, and how much everyone tried to make things easier.

I loved that Minnie was going to temporarily take over her classroom, and that her family was eager to chip in at the cafe.

Minnie seems lonely since Angela left, and also needs to find her purpose; she’s wonderful with other children.

(Jeff Weddell/ Hallmark Media)

Allie thrived seeing her friends again. It was bittersweet because it took her so long to become comfortable with people, including Oliver, and she didn’t want to lose those connections again.

These types of arcs showed how the community rallied around one another. They didn’t want to lose one of their own again.

Charlotte Thornton Was Pivotal in the Plan to Help Elizabeth and Little Jack

Charlotte Thornton (Brooke Shields) has not appeared on When Calls the Heart in 10 years, so many things have changed in Elizabeth’s life since then.

She seemed genuinely eager to help Elizabeth and Little Jack, and appeared warm to Nathan and Allie, too.

(Courtesy of Hallmark Media)

While we’d seen part of the scene in the official trailer, I suspect Charlotte encouraged Nathan to propose, teasing him, “not to mess this up.”

It was such a touching moment when she admitted that she had difficulty imagining someone besides her son raising Little Jack, but she knew Nathan was a good man.

Nothing like an endorsement from Elizabeth’s mother-in-law. I imagine Nathan often fears about measuring up to Jack, so I wish they had skipped some of the tedious triangle and dealt with some of this drama.

Maybe now that he’s met all of Jack’s family and gained their approval, things will move forward even more.

Sometimes listening was half the battle as Nathan realized when he wanted to cheer Elizabeth up, and he and Rosemary tried to conquer the impossible.

(Jeff Weddell/ Hallmark Media)

He remembered that Skeet used to ramble on about a friend who flew planes, so he called Charlotte to see if Skeet would help.

It was heartwarming to see the inspector arrive by plane and approve Faith’s clinic.

Sometimes, hope, faith, and love do work miracles, only in Hope Valley.

Nathan’s gesture allowed all of them to stay, making both Elizabeth and Allie ecstatic, since they both wanted to start the new school year there.

(Jeff Weddell/ Hallmark Media)

Lucas Was Used More Effectively in the When Calls the Heart Season 13 Premiere

We’ve frequently complained that Lucas deserved better writing, so I was pleased to see that he was already being written better.

While he’s not going to reunite with Elizabeth, I enjoy their friendship and was pleased that he was the one who notified her about the inspector’s delay and the clinic’s uncertified status.

He still cares about her and Little Jack and wants what’s best for them, too, so it was refreshing that.

Lucas and Edie fans will be pleasantly surprised by the adorable content they received.

(David Dolsen/Hallmark Media)

Lucas was so smitten that he had eyes only for Edie and ignored the brand-new traffic light, which incited teasing from his friends.

The parallels between Lucas’s talk with Lee and Edie’s chat with the women were the best part.

Edie felt hurt that Lucas never contacted her while he was gone over the summer, and he merely wanted to pick up where they left off.

However, Lucas seemed confused, since things had been good between them before he left, and he had no clue what he’d done to offend her.

It was time for some match-making and for those two to communicate better.

(Ricardo Hubbs/ Hallmark Media)

Could Goldie National Park be a Double-Edged Sword?

The opening of Goldie National Park was supposed to be one of the most significant events. 

The older children wrote about why they loved nature, and some struggled to do so. The words only flowed for Allie once she returned to Hope Valley, and she realized how much hiking and fishing here meant to her. 

Those moments were cherished memories, and she hoped others would experience them.

That was the motto of the park, and I loved how the Coulters and Goldie were the face of it.

It should have been a celebratory day, especially after everyone learned that Elizabeth, Nathan, and the others were staying.

(Ricardo Hubbs/ Hallmark Media)

But that cliffhanger with the teens hiking in the woods, checking the trail markers, just as a forest fire broke out, has me worried.

Was the fire accidental, or does McGinty still hold a grudge against the locals, and will the men save the kids before anyone is hurt?

Let us know in the comments and tune in next week for the answer.

Enjoyed this review? Help us out.

Drop a comment or share it — it’s free, painless, and helps keep independent TV coverage alive.

K

Monday 26th of January 2026

I love Nathan

Lynette Bennett

Tuesday 6th of January 2026

There are too many characters in this show now. None of them get a long enough storyline to be able to bring the audience into a full arc of any character in each episode. The media campaign Hallmark did for this season was one of the best yet. It got my hopes up for more than what the first episode gave me I feel. I have watched every season but this newest episode did not hold my interest much. I hope the season gets better. Otherwise, I am done watching this show.

Sweet Amy

Tuesday 6th of January 2026

@Tbookfan, that is a good idea for the minor characters. I know for budgetary reasons Chicago PD excludes main stars from various episodes, then also gives them their own centric episode. It isn't my first choice, but I do enjoy the centric episodes.

I love Ned, Flo, and Molly, and agree that they are seriously underused. They writers/showrunners should have expanded their roles more, instead of bringing in so many new characters.

Tbookfan

Tuesday 6th of January 2026

@Lynette Bennett, There are way too many people on this show; I felt this way for about 5 seasons.

Unfortunately, they won't trim the cast. To me that should split the episode counts for the MINOR characters: giving them a good storyline line for 6 episodes and then give the other minor characters a good storyline for the last 6 epsidoes. The minor characters who are not involved during the 6 episode heavy period can still have minor background parts like they do now. This way everyone gets some substantial time.

Seriously, they need to give Molly/Flo/Ned more to do. They have been with the show from the start.

Sweet Amy

Monday 5th of January 2026

I am so happy that When Calls the Heart is back, and that was a fantastic episode! My heart hurt for Elizabeth, she just wanted to be back home with her friends and community. Bless Nate for coming up with the airplane idea for the inspector to come. This community is the best, basically a big family. Considering the way the show ended, you can be certain that the community comes together to battle that horrific fire, and save the kids. I wouldn't put it past MacGinty to have started it. I hope everyone will be okay.

Granny

Monday 5th of January 2026

I believe A J McGinty started the fire in Goldie National Park. He was against the park from the very start and he doesn't like anyone in Hope Valley. He is a very evil man!!!!

Tbookfan

Monday 5th of January 2026

@Sweet Amy, Without any clues, Im going to guess that Henry's son accidentally started the fire. Maybe he was smoking and carelessly discarded the match or cigarette. And out of shame, fear he doesn't confess.

Sweet Amy

Monday 5th of January 2026

@Granny, that was my thought as well. Even if it's not him, I bet that it is arson.

Tbookfan

Monday 5th of January 2026

@Granny, He would be the obvious choice and the 1st person they will question; so its probably not him. Melissa Gilbert's character comes back in episode 6 to help with the investigation. She's on for 6 episodes so the "who done it" will last most of the season.

Tbookfan

Sunday 4th of January 2026

This was a very good episode! It was well balanced amongst the cast. Most importantly, they have integrated Lucas back into the community vs last season. I think that this will be a good season. As a Nathan and Elizabeth fan, I like the closeness of their relationship. I know that they are getting engaged this season and I’m happy about that.

The fire arc and special effects looks very promising.

Pure vanity…. I didn’t like Nathan and Oliver’s mustaches, so I’m glad that they shaved it. Also, why is Erin back to wearing those horrible wigs, her natural hair last season was much better.

Sweet Amy

Monday 5th of January 2026

@Tbookfan, I did not like their mustaches either. Thank goodness they shaved. I didn't realize that Erin was wearing a wig. I know when she is not working, she has very curly hair.

Most Commented

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!