Grey's Anatomy Review: "Hook, Line and Sinner" Comments (Page 2)
24 Comments
sofilove123 Rank: Recurring Character
April 30th, 2010 4:33 PM
This episode was really good (not better than SFTP but still it's up there for me) Callie/AZ is still up in the air again I mean if you strongly want kids you can't just give up like that (and I don't think AZ is heartless people don't want kids and that's ok) Callie/AZ are in serious trouble
Mer/Der: The chief shepard bit made me smile A LOT! That was enough Mer/Der for me tonight
Sloan: I wanted to hug him when he realized that Sloane wasn't ready to be a mom and she wasn't honestly. The baby scenes broke my heart
Alex/Lexie: Ok I have tolerated the sex buddy system enough! I did notice Alex looking @ Lexie and it pissed me off. Alex is far from ready to go into another relationship after what Izzie did. I have completely accepted that A/I are done and that was hard for me.
ITA that Alex needs someone to love him but he can't let himself love someone that fast. I want Alex to find someone new to love him not sleep with him because lexie is not over sloan not by a long s
Kiki
April 30th, 2010 12:39 PM
@brokkie87
Yes, you are absolutely right, but, well, that´s GA creating drama, isn´t it ;-)
They love each other, they can only see the future with each other, but Callie's dream isn't Arizona's dream, and Arizona wouldn't want Callie to give it up because of her. And Callie doesn't just want a baby with anyone. She wants that with AZ, because that's who she sees herself with, that's what feels right for her. I feel that there will be a short break between AZ and Callie with AZ initiating the break up as AZ loves Callie too much to let her give up a part of herself. They would be letting go because they love each other too much to stand in their way. That's selfless and that's definitely the kind of stuff I want between them.
brokkie87
April 30th, 2010 11:44 AM
@ Kiki and smoker
I don't want kids either and I know couples who don't either. It doesn't make you a better person if you want a kid or the other way around. it's just a choice of how you chose to live your life.
So I really get where arizona is coming from. I also get that she was upset callie assumed it was about her brother. and still I feel like siding with callie here. first arizona doesn't see callie is devastated and goes on about wanting chickens. then when callie finally has the guts to tell arizona she want a child she litteraly pulls away(hands). then she avoids talking about it(pound cake). and when callie brings it up AGAIN she doesn't show callie any compassion(except in the last scene). she doesn't try to see it from her perspective. callie fought for arizona all episode and all arizona did was pushing her away. I hope arizona will be more understanding in the next episode but I doubt it. I think they will break up in the next episode. arizona doesn't want callie
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
April 30th, 2010 11:12 AM
Ha! Mer preggers...if only...
Lina
April 30th, 2010 11:05 AM
All I really vare about is that Callie and Arizona DONT'T breakup! Cuz they r by favorite couple! And I actually think they might work this out. Cuz and the last scene with them this Episode I just started cryin when Callie did, cuz it was so heartbreaking. But on the other hand I think that Arizona saw how important it was for Callie, and hopefully she will reconsider her choice of not having kids, ever. Cuz I don't think that any of them want to lose the other, so I just Hope that Arizona can just give Callie just a glims of hope. Cuz even if I HATE that they r fighting, I actually like that there are more then just they kissing-scenes now. But to summ it up, I'm SUPER scared for them, SUPER!!
Kiki
April 30th, 2010 11:05 AM
I totally agree with smoker!!! Why is wanting a kid more important and more worth to bend for than not wanting a kid! And why does someone have to have serious problems in the bust just because of not wanting to have kids. And more than any other especially Arizona who likes kids and is around them day by day knows what it means to have kids in your life! But as Arizona loves Callie so much she will not let her give up her dream. And even if they break up, both will be very devastated - I break up with you, so you can have kids with someone you have to find, maybe will never find, altough we are MFEO - whoa! I guess it will come to a "maybe in the future" from Arizona. And, come on, please drop this Callie&Mark thing finally! They nevernever were in love with each other! They had meaningless just for fun sex ages ago! They are best friends and share the same sexual chemistry everyone else shares! And just because both of them want kids now?! Why not hook up Callie and Derek, both w
jls2829
April 30th, 2010 10:26 AM
don't know how anyone else feels but I'm just not liking Teddy. I don't know why. I never have and now that she's with Mark, I like her even less. I want Mark and Lexie to get back together. I thought it was interesting that Owen basically told Derek to send her packing. I guess he wants to remove the temptation. Can we all see the writing on the wall? Owen and Teddy will get together. I'm not liking Arizona too much right now. She acts like Callie should respect her feelings on the kid issue but what about Callie's feelings? Aren't they just as valid? Arizona won't even discuss it. I wasn't that impressed with the whole episode. Hope next week is better.
Ceridwen
April 30th, 2010 10:13 AM
Um...yeah...as others have said, April is not going all psycho. Shonda said so. And Derek and Meredith are going to be strong going into AND coming out of the season finale (again, Shonda said so on Twitter). I think you're really reaching here with your ideas. Seems like you're laying out the plot for some bad Grey's Anatomy fanfic. Based on what Shonda has said, I think that something is gonna happen like some big accident/issue at the hosptial in the finale that kills April. Maybe she saves Derek, sacrificing herself. And a big, loud accident could bring Owen's ptsd back full-force, and perhaps cause him to accidentally hurt Cristina more seriously then he has before, providing a catalyst for them to break up. Shonda said the couple that breaks up don't do so due to another person, so this would allow Cristina and Owen to break up without Teddy being the cause. If something happens to the hospital itself, that would certainly also be a game-changer. Also, Mer pregnant would totally
dutchy78
April 30th, 2010 10:12 AM
I agree this wasn't the best episode (could it anything have to do with the hiatus? we always get this excited when we have to wait, to get disappointe when it actually airs?!). But there was a lot of Callie/Arizona, the Sloan-story was okay, Yang and Bailey made me smile like they always do and there where many great quotes.
Callie and Arizona: I'm pretty scared for them. Callie is trying really hard, but Arizona won't buy it. It was as if they were literally grabbing on to each other at the end, knowing they're losing each other. Heartbreaking. BUT I think that when they break up, they'll realise that missing each other is even harder, so they'll find a way to make it anyway. (Right Shonda? Right?!?)
Owen, Cristina, Teddy: Owen and Teddy should hook up, they make a better couple. Cristina will live, her heart lives in her scalpel anyway.
Alex and Lexie: my thought exactly!
Mark and Callie: no way!! BFF's should stay BFF's for once. Why should every boy-girl friendship tur
smoker
April 30th, 2010 10:04 AM
sorry for my english
firstly, mark and callie have never been a couple, only sex partners, they have zero chemistry (it's my opinion of course), they had a great friendship last season but now they cross the line again and again, you can't wait to have a girl/boyfriend watching things they are doing and stay fine with it. moreover, calzona are MFEO thanks to shonda so...
I'm with arizona, callie is talking to her in a disturbing way, arizona deserves to live her life the way she wants to, just the same callie deserves, but callie doesnt respect arizona lifestyle, I don't like kids and I don't think there is something wrong with me, one of them need to change her mind but I don't like it if it is arizona, why?, I don't callie, and this season I just hate her, she is so weak
laurie
April 30th, 2010 9:47 AM
i think don't think callie & mark will happen again. i think shonda is aware of that "stereotype" in the lesbian community and would never perpetuate it further using one of her shows. i hope i'm right on that one. that being said, i don't think callie & arizona will last much longer but that doesn't mean they will never get back together again. it just might be a bumpy road for a season. on twitter shonda said april is just a silly girl with a crush and she won't go all psycho on anyone. but i do agree the crush has to play into this somehow or it wouldn't be present. this episode was a bore. i hate to say it but last season was 100x better!
brokkie87
April 30th, 2010 9:34 AM
I really don't see mark and callie getting back together. that would be such a insult. and besides spoilers already tols us that mark hooks up with reed and that lexie is not happy about it. so I see a lexie and mark reunion.
well either callie or arizona is going to give in. I love arizona but she was way too harsh too callie. arizona has shut her out for weeks now and when callie wants to know why arizona doesn't want kids she shuts her out again. yes callie was assuming it was about her brother and she shouldn't have but arizona really should have shown more compassion. it seems callie is always trying to make the relationship work. with george, erica. no wonder she turned to mark for some oncomplicated sex. I hope arizona changes her mind and gives callie what she has always wanted. I think next episode callie and arizona will break up because arizona doesn't want callie to give up her dream to be with her.
Rank: Recurring Character
April 30th, 2010 4:33 PM
This episode was really good (not better than SFTP but still it's up there for me) Callie/AZ is still up in the air again I mean if you strongly want kids you can't just give up like that (and I don't think AZ is heartless people don't want kids and that's ok) Callie/AZ are in serious trouble
Mer/Der: The chief shepard bit made me smile A LOT! That was enough Mer/Der for me tonight
Sloan: I wanted to hug him when he realized that Sloane wasn't ready to be a mom and she wasn't honestly. The baby scenes broke my heart
Alex/Lexie: Ok I have tolerated the sex buddy system enough! I did notice Alex looking @ Lexie and it pissed me off. Alex is far from ready to go into another relationship after what Izzie did. I have completely accepted that A/I are done and that was hard for me.
ITA that Alex needs someone to love him but he can't let himself love someone that fast. I want Alex to find someone new to love him not sleep with him because lexie is not over sloan not by a long s
April 30th, 2010 12:39 PM
@brokkie87
Yes, you are absolutely right, but, well, that´s GA creating drama, isn´t it ;-)
They love each other, they can only see the future with each other, but Callie's dream isn't Arizona's dream, and Arizona wouldn't want Callie to give it up because of her. And Callie doesn't just want a baby with anyone. She wants that with AZ, because that's who she sees herself with, that's what feels right for her. I feel that there will be a short break between AZ and Callie with AZ initiating the break up as AZ loves Callie too much to let her give up a part of herself. They would be letting go because they love each other too much to stand in their way. That's selfless and that's definitely the kind of stuff I want between them.
April 30th, 2010 11:44 AM
@ Kiki and smoker
I don't want kids either and I know couples who don't either. It doesn't make you a better person if you want a kid or the other way around. it's just a choice of how you chose to live your life.
So I really get where arizona is coming from. I also get that she was upset callie assumed it was about her brother. and still I feel like siding with callie here. first arizona doesn't see callie is devastated and goes on about wanting chickens. then when callie finally has the guts to tell arizona she want a child she litteraly pulls away(hands). then she avoids talking about it(pound cake). and when callie brings it up AGAIN she doesn't show callie any compassion(except in the last scene). she doesn't try to see it from her perspective. callie fought for arizona all episode and all arizona did was pushing her away. I hope arizona will be more understanding in the next episode but I doubt it. I think they will break up in the next episode. arizona doesn't want callie
Rank: Regular Character
April 30th, 2010 11:12 AM
Ha! Mer preggers...if only...
April 30th, 2010 11:05 AM
All I really vare about is that Callie and Arizona DONT'T breakup! Cuz they r by favorite couple! And I actually think they might work this out. Cuz and the last scene with them this Episode I just started cryin when Callie did, cuz it was so heartbreaking. But on the other hand I think that Arizona saw how important it was for Callie, and hopefully she will reconsider her choice of not having kids, ever. Cuz I don't think that any of them want to lose the other, so I just Hope that Arizona can just give Callie just a glims of hope. Cuz even if I HATE that they r fighting, I actually like that there are more then just they kissing-scenes now. But to summ it up, I'm SUPER scared for them, SUPER!!
April 30th, 2010 11:05 AM
I totally agree with smoker!!! Why is wanting a kid more important and more worth to bend for than not wanting a kid! And why does someone have to have serious problems in the bust just because of not wanting to have kids. And more than any other especially Arizona who likes kids and is around them day by day knows what it means to have kids in your life! But as Arizona loves Callie so much she will not let her give up her dream. And even if they break up, both will be very devastated - I break up with you, so you can have kids with someone you have to find, maybe will never find, altough we are MFEO - whoa! I guess it will come to a "maybe in the future" from Arizona. And, come on, please drop this Callie&Mark thing finally! They nevernever were in love with each other! They had meaningless just for fun sex ages ago! They are best friends and share the same sexual chemistry everyone else shares! And just because both of them want kids now?! Why not hook up Callie and Derek, both w
April 30th, 2010 10:26 AM
don't know how anyone else feels but I'm just not liking Teddy. I don't know why. I never have and now that she's with Mark, I like her even less. I want Mark and Lexie to get back together. I thought it was interesting that Owen basically told Derek to send her packing. I guess he wants to remove the temptation. Can we all see the writing on the wall? Owen and Teddy will get together. I'm not liking Arizona too much right now. She acts like Callie should respect her feelings on the kid issue but what about Callie's feelings? Aren't they just as valid? Arizona won't even discuss it. I wasn't that impressed with the whole episode. Hope next week is better.
April 30th, 2010 10:13 AM
Um...yeah...as others have said, April is not going all psycho. Shonda said so. And Derek and Meredith are going to be strong going into AND coming out of the season finale (again, Shonda said so on Twitter). I think you're really reaching here with your ideas. Seems like you're laying out the plot for some bad Grey's Anatomy fanfic. Based on what Shonda has said, I think that something is gonna happen like some big accident/issue at the hosptial in the finale that kills April. Maybe she saves Derek, sacrificing herself. And a big, loud accident could bring Owen's ptsd back full-force, and perhaps cause him to accidentally hurt Cristina more seriously then he has before, providing a catalyst for them to break up. Shonda said the couple that breaks up don't do so due to another person, so this would allow Cristina and Owen to break up without Teddy being the cause. If something happens to the hospital itself, that would certainly also be a game-changer. Also, Mer pregnant would totally
April 30th, 2010 10:12 AM
I agree this wasn't the best episode (could it anything have to do with the hiatus? we always get this excited when we have to wait, to get disappointe when it actually airs?!). But there was a lot of Callie/Arizona, the Sloan-story was okay, Yang and Bailey made me smile like they always do and there where many great quotes.
Callie and Arizona: I'm pretty scared for them. Callie is trying really hard, but Arizona won't buy it. It was as if they were literally grabbing on to each other at the end, knowing they're losing each other. Heartbreaking. BUT I think that when they break up, they'll realise that missing each other is even harder, so they'll find a way to make it anyway. (Right Shonda? Right?!?)
Owen, Cristina, Teddy: Owen and Teddy should hook up, they make a better couple. Cristina will live, her heart lives in her scalpel anyway.
Alex and Lexie: my thought exactly!
Mark and Callie: no way!! BFF's should stay BFF's for once. Why should every boy-girl friendship tur
April 30th, 2010 10:04 AM
sorry for my english
firstly, mark and callie have never been a couple, only sex partners, they have zero chemistry (it's my opinion of course), they had a great friendship last season but now they cross the line again and again, you can't wait to have a girl/boyfriend watching things they are doing and stay fine with it. moreover, calzona are MFEO thanks to shonda so...
I'm with arizona, callie is talking to her in a disturbing way, arizona deserves to live her life the way she wants to, just the same callie deserves, but callie doesnt respect arizona lifestyle, I don't like kids and I don't think there is something wrong with me, one of them need to change her mind but I don't like it if it is arizona, why?, I don't callie, and this season I just hate her, she is so weak
April 30th, 2010 9:47 AM
i think don't think callie & mark will happen again. i think shonda is aware of that "stereotype" in the lesbian community and would never perpetuate it further using one of her shows. i hope i'm right on that one. that being said, i don't think callie & arizona will last much longer but that doesn't mean they will never get back together again. it just might be a bumpy road for a season. on twitter shonda said april is just a silly girl with a crush and she won't go all psycho on anyone. but i do agree the crush has to play into this somehow or it wouldn't be present. this episode was a bore. i hate to say it but last season was 100x better!
April 30th, 2010 9:34 AM
I really don't see mark and callie getting back together. that would be such a insult. and besides spoilers already tols us that mark hooks up with reed and that lexie is not happy about it. so I see a lexie and mark reunion.
well either callie or arizona is going to give in. I love arizona but she was way too harsh too callie. arizona has shut her out for weeks now and when callie wants to know why arizona doesn't want kids she shuts her out again. yes callie was assuming it was about her brother and she shouldn't have but arizona really should have shown more compassion. it seems callie is always trying to make the relationship work. with george, erica. no wonder she turned to mark for some oncomplicated sex. I hope arizona changes her mind and gives callie what she has always wanted. I think next episode callie and arizona will break up because arizona doesn't want callie to give up her dream to be with her.
April 30th, 2010 9:24 AM
Well Kristina - what do you think will happen?
April 30th, 2010 9:16 AM
i dont like your ideas at all