One Tree Hill Review: Kids These Days...

at . Comments

One Tree Hill covered the idea of having children this week, along with the relationships these children then have with their parents. It wasn't as good as some recent episodes, but not nearly as bad as some earlier in the season.

Let's start with Brooke and Julian, who were attempting to adopt a baby from a 19-year old pregnant woman played by Leven Rambin. Rambin seems to be in everything these days. After I first disliked her character in The Sarah Connor Chronicles, I proceeded to dislike her characters in Grey's Anatomy, the two episodes of Scoundrels I watched, and ,most recently, as a red head in Wizards of Waverly Place (yes, you read that correctly).

Brooke and Julian

I loved her on "I Think I'm Gonna Like It Here," though, and not just because she ultimately decided to let Brooke and Julian adopt her baby. Her character, Chloe, seemed to have been through a lot, so her final speech to Brulian about why she chose to give them her baby felt really good.

How that storyine got to that ending point was certainly a trip, though. I mean, come on Brooke! Are you really lying straight up to the girl's face about your clothing line and your parents? This is something I would have expected from her five seasons ago, but now? I thought she had grown enough over the past couple of seasons to not do something so silly. Did she learn nothing from her experience with Sam?

The whole lying bit was worth it, however, because it created the fantastically awkward scene in which Haley's baby shower turned into the gang chatting about how it was cool to go to jail and do drugs right in front of Chloe. One might assume that this would have scared Chloe away, but the baggage that Brooke and Julian bring with them was actually something that convinced Chloe to go with them, and I thought that was a nice touch. 

I'm sure Haley's fantastic toast about Brooke - in which she claimed that "There is no one else to whom I would trust my child more" - didn't hurt, either.

Meanwhile, Haley's baby girl is on the way and she has decided on a name. She needs to make sure it is okay with big sis Quinn for her to name the baby after their mom, and of course the answer is yes. They have a few touching moments, but once again, these scenes would be much more heartfelt if they were about a parent that we had met for more than a couple episodes before she passed away. 

It would be much easier to tear up if they were sad about losing Karen or Deb... or how about Keith?  He's dead and now that Lucas is gone, no one ever talks about him.

On the relationship with parents side of things, Clay, Nathan, and Julian spent time with Ian Kellerman as they prepared to sign him to Fortitude. This kid is a real handful and, just as Nathan seems to think, reminds me of a young Nate Scott. Not the bearded, drunken, in a wheel chair, jerk of a Nate Scott from season five, but the "I'm too cool for school, I hate my half-brother, I'm the nicest basketball player ever" Nathan Scott from season one. 

Nate's ability to take all of Ian's antics in stride because he knows that the young Kellerman kid might be able to grow into a man was poetic. Nathan's the rock of the show, and he proved it once again with his ability to reel Kellerman in.

And, finally, there was the hilarious baseball action at Jamie's Little League tryouts. None of the comedy came from Jamie, of course, because his ability to make me laugh left after his first season on the series. You know what will never cease to get old, though? Julian knowing nothing about sports. "Eating ice cream is the best part about Little League... except for maybe catching butterflies" is a quote to remember.  Add to that Chuck complaining about bad hops and taking his shoes off, and you had a pretty darn funny episode of One Tree Hill.

One final note: When are people going to start noticing that Alex Dupre is in their presence? They need to either explain that she is not as big a celebrity as they once said she was, or explain that people in the One Tree Hill universe don't care about movie stars. Unacceptable for this to continually happen.

So how excited are you that Brooke and Julian's parenthood seems imminent? Do you love Naley naming Jamie's baby sister after Haley's mom? And when and how will Clay propose to Quinn? Sound off now!

Review

Editor Rating: 3.5 / 5.0
  • 3.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 3.4 / 5.0 (33 Votes)

Dan Forcella is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,

One Tree Hill Season 8 Episode 16 Quotes

What about the off chance that he doesn't do so well, you gonna go all Dan Scott on him?

Haley

Brooke Penelope Davis Baker, you break that box spring and you're sleeping on the floor.

Julian

One Tree Hill Season 8 Episode 16 Music

  Song Artist
Off we go Off We Go Trent Dabbs iTunes
Song Easy Arnold
Carrying the torch Carrying The Torch Generationals iTunes