Glee Review: The Pluck of the Irish

at . Comments

Rory Flanagan may not have the ability to make any cereal magically delicious, but he sure did magically appear on "Pot O' Gold" and play a significant episode on the first new Glee episode in weeks, didn't he?

It was a bit jarring to have this character just plopped down in both the hallways of William McKinley and in the bedroom of Brittany S. Pearce (no, not like that! He wishes!), getting his first solo within minutes of his arrival.

Was I invested in his rendition of a Kermit the Frog classic? Not exactly. It was far from earned, having just been introduced to the heavily-accented foreign exchange student. By the end of the hour, though, I was as excited as the rest of New Directions to welcome Rory on board. I even understood almost every other word he said!

Rory and Brittany

Meanwhile, this non-Leprechaun wasn't the only one granting wishes: someone on the writing staff must have heard my pleas for an abundance of Burt Hummel and delivered exactly that. I'm already loving his campaign against Sue, partly because it's based on actual issues.

How to best spend public funds for school? That's very much a real debate. Arts versus special ed? I don't even have a joke here. What side would you take? It's a tough one and it serves to humanize Sue. Yes, she's a hoot when she's rattling on about Will's hair - and, now, Burt's lack of locks - and it's hilarious that she wants to take down Tom Bergeron... but Glee is best served when its characters are grounded in reality. A fine job of that here.

Similarly, whoa, serious Brittany might need to be a contender for Scariest Character on Television. Bravo to her for standing up to Finn's "idiot" insult. Considering the major deal it is for her to defect to The Trouble Tones (I sort of like Hot Messes... anyone else?), the show needed to give her something more legitimate as a basis than granting a Leprechaun's wish. Well done again. This season hasn't been perfect, but the writers did appear serious about focusing on consistent storytelling.

The same can be said for Puck and Shelby. Am I alone in jumping right on the Pelby bandwagon? We've seen Puck's affection for cougars before - they make his nipple rings twitch, after all - and I absolutely bought Shelby's sadness over raising a child alone. I can see these two together - not together together, just growing close as they have been and then realizing how they can't actually go there - especially if it helps wake Puck up to Quinn's seriously evil plan of stealing back Beth.

No, Quinn. Just... no! That's some dastardly scheming, far beyond any high school pranking.

Other thoughts on an enjoyable episode that has me craving both Lucky Charms and some Christina Aguilera:

  • Sue thinks math teachers make $2,000 per year.
  • And that West Wide Story glorifies gang violence, yet remains gay.
  • I need to point out the bullying hypocrisy again: Glee spent weeks on Kurt getting shoved into lockers last year, yet it's just accepted here as something Rory is unfortunately going through?
  • Yes, Hummel is more difficult to spell than Lisa Murkowski. Look at Glee getting all political! It could almost pass for The Good Wife.
  • Along those lines, call me a raging liberal, but Brittany didn't want to be known as a quitter due to her rising political career? Hmmm... could that be a reference to another former Alaskan government official.
  • Leprechaun is Santana's favorite movie. It learned her two things.
  • Blaine wanted to remind everyone what Glee is all about, which, as he put it, is just... fun. Amen, right, readers?
  • It's been awhile, so just a reminder: We've already updated our Glee quotes and our Glee music sections, as we do every Tuesday night. Click and enjoy!

What did everyone else think? You can get an early look at next week's sex-based episode NOW!


Editor Rating: 4.4 / 5.0
  • 4.4 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.1 / 5.0 (226 Votes)

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.


An enjoyable episode of Glee, okay scratch that, a very enjoyable one!
I'm loving Rory directly and I'm so happy to this blossoming friendship between him and Finn.
I'm starting to dislike Santana. Yes, she's cool, bitchy and stuff. They told us for a whole Season 2. But right now? It just seems that she's taking advantage of Brit's innocence.
Shelby-Puck relationship is cute, but I'm a Quick shipper and yes, I keep hoping that Quinn will repent someday. Amen.
For people that keep complaining about Glee's storyline and other stuffs, I'd like to quote Blaine, "Glee Club is!" So just hop in and enjoy the fun ride and stop complaining about everything.


@zandrew ever? coz you just bankrupted every bar in the world


maggies right, no one above the age of 17 should date


@maggie- depends on how old puck actually is. plus you could argue that she's not REALLY a teacher


Am I the only one here who thinks that Finn is pure awesomeness?
I'm a straight dude and I love Finn!


The new kid clearly is thrilled to have gotten the job on Glee but it makes for a really poor performance. Not natural at all, in fact totally wooden delivery, saccharine permanent smiles is just irksome. Bloke needs to up his game, in fact the whole does.


I think it's reckless for the reviewer to condone such inappropriate behaviour between Puck and Shelby, who are a student and teacher respectively. It is illegally, and rightfully so, and I hope that the show doesn't go there and glamorise statutory rape simply because Shelby is a "hot MILF".


NOOO! Mercedes is NOT pregnant. She just ate bad quiznos! Amber riley Tweeted herself. Sheesh!


Out of the blue but I think Mercedes is pregnant


Kurts just mad another guy's falsetoing

Tags: ,

Glee Season 3 Episode 4 Quotes

I got a bee in my bonnet, and that bee's name is "government waste."


You look magical and amazing, but I don't understand what you're saying. So if you're gonna make it this his world, you better learn to speak English.

Brittany [to Rory]