Tuesdays 8:00 PM on FOX
Glee

Glee Round Table: "Michael"

by at .

According to the ratings, Glee's tribute to Michael Jackson was a hit.

But what about according to our Round Table panel of Matt Richenthal, Miranda Wicker and Steve Marsi? Read on for their opinions on this performance-heavy hour and then respond with your take...

-------------------------------------------

What was your favorite scene from the episode.
Matt: Can I just go with one line? It was a throwaway and many viewers might not even have noticed, but I cracked up when Glee went meta for a second and Santana mentioned that, had Kurt taped a recorder to his penis, it would have been talked about for a week.

Miranda: This is a tough one because I thought most of the episode was great compared to the past two episodes. It's a toss-up for me between anything having to do with Santana and Kurt dragging his dad all over the school before he could open his letter from NYADA.

Steve: Call me a sap. But it was Rachel saying yes, hands down.

Glee RT New

What was your favorite scene from the episode.
Matt: The cellos? The voices? The simplicity? The daggers shooting out of Santana's eyes? "Smooth Criminal" all the way.

Miranda: While I, too, loved "Smooth Criminal," I'm giving this one to Artie and Mike Chang's "Scream" based solely on the performance and not the scene in which it occurred. It's nice to be able to see Kevin McHale up and out of the wheelchair from time to time, so I like that the writers found a way to let him stretch his legs and show off his talents.

Steve: The final one, "Black or White." Especially the morphing of faces at the end, which took me back to my childhood and MJ's original video for that track.

Did the New Directions make the right move in withholding the slushee evidence from the police?
Matt: Yes. In the same way that Will made the right move two weeks ago in turning his proposal to Emma into a school assignment.

Miranda: Not even kind of. They most certainly should've turned the evidence over. That's what happens in the real world. However, Sebastian's dad is supposed to be a state's attorney, so he'd know a thing or two about having that tape ruled inadmissible and we'd be right back to a sing off. Maybe Glee just circumvented a dead-weight storyline and did us all a favor.

Steve: I agreed with both of you... until the final scene. When Santana made the point of Sebastian's fellow Warblers knowing exactly what sort of man they were dealing with, it made a bit more sense - then again, they'd also have realized this if the police had gotten involved. Okay. Yeah. It was ridiculous.

Biggest tear-jerker: Quinn getting into Yale; Rachel saying yes; Burt hugging Kurt; or Sam kissing Mercedes?
Matt: Burt FTW! He's easily my favorite character on the show, which, granted, might say as much about my growing distaste for many other characters as it does about Burt. But it killed me with his closing line to Kurt, post-hug: Today, you won.

Miranda: Since the other three were just sort of "meh" for me, Burt and Kurt win.

Steve: Quinn getting into Yale. But they were tears of joy because I hope it means we don't see any of this nut case on season four.

Do you want to see more tribute episodes?
Matt: No. They take far too much attention away from actual storylines and characters. Seriously, think about this episode for a moment: did it really make any sense at all for everyone to be wondering what Michael Jackson would do? Of course not. Ryan Murphy just wanted to sell more sons on iTunes.

Miranda: I'm down with more tribute episodes if they're done right. While some of the performances in this episode were forced to fit the episode (Sam and Mercedes, Finchel, and "Bad"), the rest of them were incorporated well and worked for me.

Steve: It really depends. This one was far better than the nonsense that was the hour-long dedication to Britney Spears, for example. Give me a Bruce Springstein tribute and I'm there!

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.

Tags: ,

From Around the Web

    8 Comments New Comment Subscribe

    Avatar

    Can this be the last tribute episode for a while?

    Seriously...This one wasn't the worst but they all come off as forced...Also, if I wanted to watch the original video concepts...I'd watch the original video.

    Glee needs to go back to using the classics to further plot and create interesting and original performances, not rip off the artists they admire.

    I think the only tribute episode that has come anywhere close to being well done is the Madonna one.

    Pablo2203

    After this episode I quit glee, it was so awful, nothing like the glee I love, I tried to give it a chance after all the terrible episodes lately but I had to skip most of the episode

    Avatar

    My favourite scene is Sebastian in the coffee shop, I love any scene with Sebastian. Nice to finally have a villain, who is exactly that. Sue can't decide which way her moral compass is facing. Grant Gustn is wonderful and the chemistry in 'Smooth Criminal' is fantastic

    Avatar

    I loved every minute of it. From the performances to the story lines for all. I agree with Steve odd how after Quinn's been so orbital to earth that she has come to full sanity in 3 to 4 epis to get into Yale and to have wisdom of the ages for her frenemy Rachel. IMO Quinn was speaking out her own thoughts that apply to how she sees life not that it applies to all, especially, Rachel and how Rachel sees her life. Out in left field to me. Just an observation but what gets me is Quinn never blinks. Furthermore, why in the heck would Rachel go to Q for advice about Finn(ackward-too much emotional baggage between these girls). And I don't buy it that they are such good friends. IRL I do Dianna and Lea.
    Burt is the best dad ever.

    Avatar

    Are you kidding? This episode was like eating cotton candy, fun for the moment then a bellyache.

    The last episode YES/NO was a truly great episode, it had characters with issues that really mattered to them, and the great proposals- this one was just meh.

    Aquariuz

    1. Favorite scene will be Rachel emotional burst with Kurt. I really feel for her. So freaking touching.
    2. Favorite performance will be Smooth Criminal, hands down but then for the sweetness, "I Just Can't Stop Loving You" is my favorite from the ep.
    3. If I'm the po-po, I don't think I'll be that interested in a slushie case. Just saying. So, I think the kids did well by showing the Warblers just how gruesome their captain is.
    4. Refer to first question, Rachel crying then being hugged by Kurt.
    5. NO! Please, I hate tribute episodes. It seems like they're cramming so many songs in an episode and it's just "Hell to the no!"

    Avatar

    Justin Timberlake
    Rihanna (they've already ROCKED we found love)
    Boybands (Backstreet Boys, NSYNC, Westlife ect.)
    High School Musical
    Taylor Swift
    Katy Perry

    The possibileties are endless :D

    Blu

    1.Hard to say.Loved the entire episode.I got Burt/Kurt bonding moments.Blaine getting slushied.Santana being all badass.Samcedes kissing.But you know...special props to Artie ranting.Sometimes that kumbaya crap just doesn't cut it.He got to shine in a way he rarely does.
    2.I'm assuming you meant favorite song?Again hard to say.Loved the opening.Loved Smooth Criminal.I loved Human Nature, I even loved Scream.
    3.I see Miranda's point.But to quote Mercy "Hell to the no!"
    4.Tie between Burt and Kurt(because Burt is AWESOME!)and Samcedes.I love them apart.I love them together.
    5.Depends.This was a worthy one,as was Madonna.Beiber and Britney weren't.




    You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register