Thursdays 8:00 PM on CW
The-vampire-diaries

The Vampire Diaries Round Table: "Bringing Out the Dead"

by at . Comments

One tear-inducing death. One all-male dinner date. One shocking return.

The Vampire Diaries featured one OMG moment after another on "Bringing Out the Dead" and now, as usual, our Round Table panel of Matt Richenthal, Dan Forcella and Steve Marsi have gathered around to break down the latest happenings in Mystic Falls. Won't you join them?

-------------------------------------------

What was your favorite scene from the episode?
Matt: Elena and Caroline's sit-down and emotional chat about fathers about halfway through the episode. It's what makes The Vampire Diaries unlike any other show on TV, really, this ability to throw 16 twists and 27 turns around truly heartbreaking, sentimental moments that ground those twists and turns in characters we care about.

Dan: As great as it was meeting the other originals, my favorite scene had to be when Klaus first welcomed the Salvatores to his dinner party. He was slyly making a mockery of their little get together, but at the same time, he was just making it as magnificent an occasion as he could. Klaus likes to go all out.

Steve: The introduction of the original brothers, followed by the bigger reveal of the mother immediately after. Most shows would spread these things out, but meeting them in rapid succession made it truly jaw-dropping. It's like TVD doesn't even begin until 8:58!

Eric: Don't worry, I won't take the copout answer two weeks in a row and pick the cliffhanger.  Besides, Steve did that this week.  I'm going to do an equally cheesy answer and pick the entire dinner party.  Who would have thought a dinner party with four dudes could be so entertaining?  Oh wait, every female reader.

Vampire Diaries Round Table logo

With which brother would you most want to dine: Klaus, Elijah, Stefan or Damon?
Matt: Probably Klaus. But not for my sake, for his! The guy is just really lonely and seems like he would hate to dine alone. We could talk about his family, his potential hybrid army, American Idol. Whatever he wanted.

Dan: I'd love to say Klaus, as my love for the King Hybrid is well documented, but that's only a "watching" love. I would be way too afraid of him to even eat any of my food. I'd go with Stefan. I'd be least afraid that he would kill me, and I heard he cooks a mighty fine steak.

Steve: Can I say all four? That dinner party was one of my favorite scenes in weeks, a perfect blend of humor and pins-and-needles intensity. If forced to pick one, I'll take Elijah, just because I missed that guy, and how can you run out of things to talk about with somebody who's been resurrected four times now, and been a sworn enemy of everyone at that table, yet remains so personable and likable?

Eric: Can I go with Alaric?  No?  Fine.  The definitely Damon.  Besides the fact I could just get lost in his eyes for hours, I think his snarky sense of humor could keep the meal entertaining.

Pen a eulogy for Bill Forbes.
Matt: You made Caroline cry. Hard. Often. I hope you rot in the fiery pits of Hell.

Dan: Bill Forbes was no Noah Bennett. He didn't even wear horn-rimmed glasses. He didn't bring much to the table, and I am not sad to see him go. Worst of all, though, is that he didn't allow himself to transition, in which case we could all call him Vampire Bill (see: True Blood).

Steve: Way to stand by your core beliefs, Bill. Mitt Romney totally would have transitioned and become the most boring, successful vampire ever.

Eric: Agreed with Dan here.  Dude never even donned a pair of horn-rimmed glasses and tortured my girl.  Just like he's not getting immortality, he's not getting a eulogy out of me.

Is Meredith Fell the Mystic Falls Stabber?
Matt: No. She shouldn't even be the prime suspect. That should be Katherine, d'uh! Why else would Elena's fingerprints be on the stakes? Why would Katherine do such a thing? Who knows. Does it really matter with her? She'll just escape the authorities anyway and not be heard from again until the writers decide to randomly insert her into a storyline.

Dan: At this point it is way too obvious that Meredith is the stabber, so it must be someone else. Who could it be though? Maybe it's Elena! She's blacking out, stabbing all of these people, and then forgetting all about it. If anything, I'm right about her killing one of them: Ric.

Steve: I'm inclined to believe the stabber is someone we haven't met yet, but I do like Daniel's theory. Elena's been dipping out more than The Situation on Jersey Shore and acting more unpredictable by the week.

Eric: Funny Matt.  I was wondering the same thing while watching.  Do Katherine and Elena have identical fingerprints?  And if I know Vampire Diaries, which I don't because the show is impossible to predict, it's going to be someone we know from the past.  Mason Lockwood or Vicki anyone?

Does Klaus have a point? Should Damon and Stefan let Elena go?
Matt: He has half a point. Is it in Elena's best interests to not be pursued by two ancient vampires, wrapped in a centuries-long battle between werewolves, witches, hybrids and Tim Tebow knows what else? Yes. But does that mean she should be forced to marry and procreate with Matt? Of course not.

Dan: Yes, they should let Elena go. Don't they know Tatia is the one everyone should be going after. What if all of Klaus, Elijah, Damon and Stefan were all going after the same girl? That wouldn't get too crowded, would it?

Steve: YES! At least for awhile. This will give Matt something to do by being the "safe" option for Elena ... only to get offed in a few episodes when Klaus' grand idea - keeping multiple rippers desperately in love with his doppelganger blood source - spectacularly backfires.

Eric: What!?  And let Klaus have yet another attractive female of the show to himself?  Throw Bonnie in the mix and the dude just monopolized Mystic Falls. 

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more The Vampire Diaries?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic

Pll-rt-new

Pretty Little Liars Round Table: "Run, Ali, Run"

Gather around, Pretty Little Liars Fanatics. Let's discuss "Run, Ali, Run."
Suits-round-table-logo

Suits Round Table: “Pound of Flesh”

Join in on the discussion as we ponder over the events in Suits Season 4 Episode 5, including Harvey and Mike's temporary truce, the adventures of Louis and Donna, and more.
Tvd-gang

The Vampire Diaries Season 6: How Will Elena Cope?

What can viewers expect from The Vampire Diaries Season 6? SPOILERS AHEAD!
Days-of-our-lives-round-table

Days of Our Lives Round Table: Who Is the Victim?

Our Days of Our Lives Round Table: debates whether or not Abigail is a victim, if Theresa can be redeemed, and if there's any hope for EJ and Sami after this week's Days of Our Lives.

Avatar

cooooooooool :D

Avatar

Joseph Morgan is too great an actor. His expressions at seeing his mother were so touching. I had to watch that scene more than once.

Avatar

I'm with you, Chrys. Elena picked this life for herself, and if she ever decided to leave Mystic Falls I don't think either of the Salvatore brothers would hold her back. And what would TVD be like without Delena and Stelena!?! And that new Gelbert that's coming (I forgot her name) she could be the stabber. It could totally be Tatia too..and the mystery begins!

Chrys

Q1: The dinner scene was amazing but i will go with the Original's reunion... It was a beautiful scene...up until the moment the OW arrived. This lady makes me feel kind of weird...She looks kind of...cold.
Q2:Damon...It'd be fun...All the others are much too serious!
Q3: I was sad...for Caroline...But i can't say i cared for Bill's character enough to write him a eulogy.
Q4:Hmmm...No! Just because she's the obvious choice. But she's definately mixed up in the murders. She's crazy nanny Kery for God's shake!
Q5: He wasn't right... Elena chose this life for herself.When she chooses to leave it behind neither Stef nor Damon are gonna stop her from doing so.They know what's best for her.

Avatar

I like the idea of Matt as the killer. It would give him a storyline for once and end the possibility of him monopolizing Elena or Caroline with his whiny personality again. Maybe he's going after Council members in revenge for them covering up his sister's death, and because he wants the rest of the town to realize all is not well in Mystic Falls. Plus the cumulated events of the past year have sent him crazy. This will make Elena realize that human guys can be just as messed up as vamps.

Avatar

Maybe becauce i`m the biggest TVD-fan i`m also the biggest critic. But who the hell is the strong storytelling. Okay whe have the great Originals, but without them? For me it feels like they use the triangle to much to push the different fanbases against eachother and leave to many plotholes. 1.) Last episode of season 2 Elena had nothing better to do the let Stefan went to Klaus for making a deal and be devasted about Damons close dead, than Stefan turn into a fullblown ripper hurt Elena whenever it`s possible and is now devasted that this really pushes his girl into Damons direction. You`re not a smart man, Stefan.

Avatar

2.) Katherine, this totally plothole-filling character which was first offered us as a villain. Now, she told Stefan to get mad and brought him to the idea to stole the coffins. And now, who is she..Where is the agenda here. 3.)I`m not a delena shipper, but i love the strong development of Damons character and they have no better idea, the switch parts again? Damon crying for her, Stefan on the winning boat..Come on, this is boring..Than let Elena choose somebody else..Because she couldn`t be really happy with one of them, because even that she don`t admit it till now, it`s obwious she loves both..and who couldn`t blame her

Aquariuz

I agree with the user below. Tatia is totally the stabber! Now, bring on the third Nina Dobrev character and let's see if she needs to see psychiatrist after this show due to multiple personality. Lol.
And yeah, for now, I kinda ship Matt-Elena (back to basic?), since Stefan and Damon need to sort out their own problems.
And Caroline, I wish I can hug her out. T_T

Thatgirl301

It would be awesome if the killer was the original Petrova doppleganger, Tatia. Like she decided to appear like everyone else and was just killing based on her knowledge of who could be linked to anyone that has something to do with Elena

Avatar

I miss the Delena and Forwood scenes :(