Private Practice > Private Practice Round Table: "The Letting Go" > Comments Page 2
@Natasa and @Ally hear hear!!! I couldn't agree more. Yes, a round table should be subjective but it also needs to be a mixture of people with different views. Imagine having a political round table over Obamacare with only Republicans slamming it and vice versa. We need a member of staff who loves AddiSam and another who doesn't loath Pete and Violet (relationship wise). Ps I for one don't like Jake with Addison one bit and I believe Sam is where her happiness lies.
Natasa , agree agree agree!!!
Your Q&A so ridiculous and awful. Jackie , I agree with you.Who is Jake.He is perfect man? C'mon guys.Nobody is perfect.Love Addison and Sam relationship :)Hey TVF , I want AddiSam fan writers :))) Ok. Just kidding but I really love Addison and Sam.
Because it's a Round Table I expect to see a variety of views. But that is not the case. You all hate Addisam...always praise CharCoop and Jake. It is always the same. Most of the time you agree with each other.
I don't expect everyone to agree with me, but your Round Table does not express a variety of views.
5. Everything except the cheese, that can't be good for anyone let alone a pregnant woman.
1. Best scenes for me were with Jake and his daughter. I thought they were sweet and not to corny. It was a great way to learn more about Jake.
The heart wrenching scenes were def with Mason and Charlotte. I think that she will make a great mother. Love her character.
2. Every scene with Mason, Erica and CharCoop. They have really been through the ringer throughout the season and this arc has really brought out the best in Charlotte and Cooper.
3. I think that Pete will always love Violet much the same way Owen loves Christina but for them to get together again, there has to be some growing up and maturing on both their parts. The marriage did not work the first time because of issues they need to deal with.
4. I think AddiSam has run it's course. Sam wants something else, Addie wants something else. The relationship can't work in that way. I never understood why Sam doesn't want another child or why they are writing this obstacle for Addie to have a child. I think Jake i
We appreciate everyone’s feedback, but let’s get a few things straight here.
Some of you must be new to this site. Like Caitlyn said, this was simply a Round Table and not the actual review. Here, we’re merely sounding off while trying to be honest in presenting a variety of views.
As for my review, just like every review on TVFanatic, it is based off of my opinion on the episode. So, it shouldn’t be objective at all. It should be just the opposite – written in a subjective manner.
There really is no need to attack others that leave comments because everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I mean, if you’re going to voice which couple you ship or which storylines you love, why can’t the next guy or gal?
I am tired of Sam and Addison, as well. I would MUTE them too. I am Team Jake. Sam and Addison are boring to watch because they so obviously do not belong together. The character of Sam is boring, and Ty Diggs skills are underutilized. I am not sure that Private Practice is the right fit for Ty Diggs anymore. Sam could be written off without being missed by me.
İ agree with erin and jakie and ana
Hello Caitlyn with all your respect the Q/A still ridiculous, THOSE are the type of questions that you/your colleagues came up after an episode that touched so many different real life good stories (for once), when the link was posted twitter I couldnt believe it. I expected Q/A from a "staff of writers" (like you proudly call yourself/others)with more challenging questions about the episode, after the amelia question I expected the four of you to start discussing addison's choice of shoes and/or charlotte's make up for the episode.
It's just constructive criticism. And I have to agree with those saying that "staff of writers" are bias towards what they want and have zero to non objectivity in writing the review for the episode.
I think I expressed a concern about the private practice round table on the previous review they had. Personally I hoped shows would be reviewed by people who can actually look at them objectively to make us want it more and not mute it.
To me, it's like a match referee celebrating when one team scores instead of being neutral.
Hey, guys, Sam had more life in him with his one night stand than he had the entire time with Addison. Would you really want him tied down to someone who wants something completely different out of life than he does? And you claim to LOVE Sam? Geez. Let the guy be happy without a woman with goals that don't mirror his own.
@Jackie - I want to clarify that I said "I'll probably mute those parts or something ‘cause I've had enough of it!" because that's honestly what I feel about Addison and Sam but it does not reflect my opinion on Sam's arc with his sister. I have full respect for that story arc and the scenes I would've "muted" would've been those of Addison and Sam being in a relationship again and not of those of them being there for each other. There's a difference.
And as for those talking about how bias the review was for this episode, these reviews are based on the opinions of the writers so you expect their likings in them. Obviously there will be readers that agree and those that disagree and that's understandable. But I think it is unfair to call out the reviewer as a bad one simply because she is expressing her opinion. Let's all try to respect what everyone has to say.
I'm not a writer to even come close to it, but I sure expected better. so completely ridiculous Q/A for the review of an episode.
For an entire episode tackling an important issue like Mental illness you could only write, if they put addison/sam back together. I will mute the scenes? Give Me a Break and you all have the nerves to call yourself Staff of writers?
Jesus Christ talk about the performances and the meaty material for the actors and the dept of the storylines, for private practice first good show in week you really wrote a mediocre review. And it's a shame that you needed to add 2 more "writers" to do so, it talks about your lack of skills.
I TOTALLY agree with Erin here. Jack is SUCH a boring character. its all so forced. and seriously guys?! Sam storyline was SO GOOD in this episode. (great acting by Taye Diggs and Anika Noni Rose.) i cannot believe none of you guys even mention them or their characters.
im sorry to say, but i just have to say it. this is such a biased review, its ridiculous.after reading it, it just makes me wanna be an addisam fan even more.
PS: the addisam scenes in this is ep was really sweet. They should definitely get back together.
I can't even read the silliness of your review anymore, its biased and painful Addison doesnt need anyone to care of her, she is a grown woman that can take care of her baby and herself, completely ridiculous and biased you can't even see the storyline with objectivity anymorem, I guess it's better for private practice if you mute the entire episode and don't write a review. It's time for Tv fanatic to find someone better to write for them obviously your lack of objectivity and completely biased writing is what is driving people away.
Also Hannah don't think you are that important as a viewer for privat practice when they have millions out there ready to continue watching even when I the show is dreadful as I think it is right now, and to be honest addisam or not you are going to continue watching, the I'm not going to watch if they pair him/her it's the oldest trick in the book, grow the hell up.
WRITE A BETTER REVIEW, the TV Fanatic readers deserve something better than what y
I'm with all of you an the Jaddison/Addisam question. I'd prefer Jaddison over that horrible mess that's Addisam any day. But I wouldn't mind if Addison decided to be single for a while either. But the show is definitely gonna lose me as a viewer if it tries to force Addison and Sam down my throat again.
I'm expecting AddiSam to make a comeback, I can's stand the sight of Jack/Jake/Jim or whatever the name they use for the new doctor, he is despicably boring and have no storyline to offer, I sleep or mute everytime he is on. I prefer a complicated love story like addisam's than some fake 3 minutes last rewrite for a character that actually make no sense and is useless.
You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.
Remember My Info