American Idol > American Idol Results: A Shocking Save > Comments Page 2
Judges -- even if they are right, they should not show, and more importantly impose to the public who they think should win...because it's up to the public!! otherwise change your format and let the judges decide.
I think Hollie is the best and should win, Jessica is good but it is the people's vote that counts. The judges are a disgrace if it happened to Hollie they would not be able to get her off quick enough...
THE THING THAT THE JUDGES DID IS LIKE LETTING OTHER ESPECIALLY HOLLY FEEL DUMP AND NOT WORTHY, HOLLY MY WHOLE COUNTRY "SAMOA" LIKES YOUR VOICE, JUST BE YOURSELF, NO MATTER WHAT HAPPEN, BE PROUD OF YOU ......
I THOUGHT THAT AMERICA DO RIGHT THING BUT NOW I KNOW IT NOT......
well to me, I feels like the judges doesnt even know how to judge anything, I was really unhappy about what they did, NO ! if america's vote is already done then let it be, there are only 3 of them but the voting is done by billions of people and from that billions it included famous people who knows very well about sing and other stuff about american idol, so it seems that they don't care about the voting by america. and it is really unfair to other competitors to walk away and to give chance to others, HOLLY is a girl who always sings from her heart, everytime she sings it move peoples heart up, by I think that the judges cant hear that, SINGING is about giving good message, telling stories, emotions but NOT like YELLING, IT DOESNT MAKE EVERYONE FEELS GOOD ABOUT THAT. AND BY THE RECORD IT ONLY AMERICA WHO VOTE, IT ALL THE WORLD, SO PLEASE SING WITH THE HEART LIKE HOLLY BY NOT LIKE YELLING COZ IT DOESNT MAKES ME MOVES.
This is kinda expected for a few reasons...
a) this is American Idol--unlike the first season AI(Search for the Singing Superstar), this has become a popularity 101 contest. The Best singer usually does not win...
b) Judges -- even if they are right, they should not show, and more importantly impose to the public who they think should win...because it's up to the public!! otherwise change your format and let the judges decide.
c) Underdog mentality -- because of reason b, the least deserving contestant gets sympathy vote, after being lambasted (sometimes unreasonably) by the judges.
d) This is America--if they can put Dubya on the White House, the result is not that surprising actually =)
Shame on the judges for making the four that were saved feel like they weren't worthy of being in the top 4. It's Americas vote.
Karen, you got it right this time, the voters got it wrong...again!!!
This is a sad commentary for the voters of this competition. It's crystal clear to me that the best singers were voted by you, the bottom three. I support Jessica, Josha and Alise. I've never voted, but I will from this point forward!!! WAKE UP AMERICA!!!
I think Hollie is the best and should win, Jessica is good but it is the people's vote that counts. The judges are a disgrace if it happened to Hollie they would not be able to get her off quick enough.
Kelly your a sick pervert
There are only two contestants in this contest that one might label as being in the X Factor category, their names are Joshua Ledet & Jessica Sanchez, the rest are really only just so so.
I believe Phillip and Skylar are the most natural and talented singers this year and I have felt that way since the beginning auditions. They seem to just flow without even trying. Both of them seem to be the most genuine and make me believe when they sing. I vote and pray for both of them.
I am sorry, but I have a hard time believing that some people out there can actually think that Holly belongs in this competition with the others. I do think she has talent, but she is just not at the same level as the others with her voice. Every week she is pitchy.
I think Elise , Philip , Jessica , Colton and Josh are all fantastic singers and deserve a place in the music industry and should do well whether any of them win or not. My personal preference is Elise and would love to hear her sing a Janis Joplin tune .
It appears (to me) that the Judges (by true definition is to be impartial)I will reclassify them as "Observers" As judges they have about as much credibility as James Durbin claiming that he has sold over 100,000 copies of his CD......What??? Wtvr.... I am usually not a cynic but I cannot help myself....Holly has chops, a beautiful raw tone to her voice and to be made to feel inadequate by the "Judges."
No the person they should send home is...Steven Tyler ! A useless judge with useless comments all the time.
Lets nail him for good !
I personally feel the best talent who was voted off early was Katy Perry but she went off and did well ? So if Ur voted off that's a good thing better for business its a curse to win show ...I mean bruno mars look how far he's gone and he's was voted off in 10th week so you never know maybe its a good thing. Getting voted off omg!!!!! I love my new boyfriend colton he is so hot!!! Yummy and I'm 52 years old ! Single and looking
I was shocked! When jessica received a fewest number of votes,because she was a great singer ever,and i like her voice too.and also thanks for the judges they saved jessica.remember guys vote wisely,it is not a beauty contest or a blönd hair contest! It is a contest for those person who have their own talent in singing.
After thinking on this some more and talking with a friend that watches......I have to say I'm disappointed in the judges actions. They clearly showed favoritism, which in this type of show SHOULD NEVER be done by someone judging the competition.
These are YOUNG kids........Jessica is only 16!!!!!!! As I said in my other post Hollie is getting the sympathy vote because of the judges harsh criticism of her.
I may be wrong but right now I think it's going to come down to Colton and Phillip......
JESSICA SANCHEZ WILL FOREVER BE REMEMBERED!!!!!!!!!!!!!! VOTE WISELY,DON'T VOTE JUST BECAUSE OF THE LOOKS,VOTE FOR THE BEST. IT IS NOT (FAVORITE IDOL!) HOLLIE SHOULD GO HOME SHE'S PATHETIC.
@shawna: "At least Hollie can sing?" So you're saying Jessica can't. You're crazy. Favoring Hollie over Jessica makes sense but saying Jessica can't sing. You're crazy.
I think america absolutly got it right last night. the judges have no right to tell us who to vote for. i think she will go home next week. Im a Hollie fan at least she can sing!
Remember Adam Lambert
I was really pissed off when he was eliminated in the finals. Another overated
joker won. ??????????????? This time it was the American voters that screwed up.
Adam is one of the best singers I had ever heard in a long time. He may not be a great rock star but he will make himself known. He has even put a song onto the charts.
Guy Lemieux Nobody saved him.
I have to say how disappointed I am with judges. They are trying to push the voters in Jessica's direction and they made the other contestants feel bad. I guess when Randy said it could be anybody going home, what he really meant was anybody except Jessica. I am tuning off American Idol because it doesn't belong to the voters anymore just hand the voting over to the judges. Shame on you three!!!!!!
Judges should be sent home. Comments were not professional and were certainly biased.Very disappointed in them.
Damn, I so thought it's Hollie! So I was really shocked when I checked it out when I woke up this morning and it's... JESSICA? Wtf? America's fucking crazy!
thanks to the JUDGES they are doing right, hope AMERICA will look and listen and hoping there is no RACIST being JESSICA is not BLOND.? IS THIS A SINGING CONTEST OR BEAUTY CONTEST.
As I read through the comments, I'm amazed that everything ends up being about color or race. Jessica might have a good voice but over the weeks of performances, she comes off as boring and sounds like a thousand other singers. I think America got it right. Not at all surprised that she was voted off but shocked at the judges outrageous display of favoritism. Other singers are so much better than Jessica, but sounds like the 3 judges and the producers are determined to have her as the Idol. Why have the show at all then? Just give her the title and end the show now. I felt so sorry for the other 6 finalists. Nothing like getting a slap in the face with "keep working hard each week but we know Jessica is the best". I just hope America stands their ground and votes her off again.
You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.
Remember My Info