American Idol > American Idol Results: The Top Two Are... > Comments Page 4
Philip may occasionally sing a melody, but with a 3 note range it is hard. All I heard when he sang was someone trying to sound like Dave Matthews. Very little talent. Joshua at least was a great singer and an outstanding performer.
im so bugged, what is america thinking phillip cant even compare to joshua, im done watching this rigged show i could careless who wins, jessica has a good voice but thinks shes all that(why i dont know) phillip has his weird looks when he sings although he is cute, but its all about the best singer not the way they look
This was a mistake for americal idol warch thier rating the next week Joshua was the best, we know that they wasn't goning to let him be in the finals but its thier loss, like i said before thank God for x factor!!!!!!!
im glad joshua was sent home.. i think the judges had been over praising him coz all I hear are screams and growls when he sings.. i think phillip will win coz hes a true artist in every sense of the word.. go phillip!
Seriously... america does vote talent.. your more than likely one of those that have a chip on your shoulder from the 1900's.. when reality says you should study your history!!
Joshua is the best. I was sorry that he didn't make it to the finale, however nobody ever hears much about the "winner's" with the exception of Carrie Underwood. I expect that he will have the wonderful career he deserves. I think Joshua Ledet is star quality by far!
People who criticize Jessica for having 0 personality... AI isn't a personality competition. It's a singing competition and she got 100% of it.
A gospel type singer will never win this show as we all see again tonight . He is very good but the style is not for a American Idol ! Jessica is also very good but lacks her own style. Need I say anymore about style when it comes to Phil !
philips is good..but not good enough for a competition,he could be a recording artists..compare to jessica that really has this powerful,angelic voice that really fits for a competition like american idol.....
joshua???? I think hes a gay...
(con't) I've also read just today and AI will be going through some tweaking for next season and that Jennifer Lopez may not be back next season. Hopefully, they will finally change the voting system as that has been a major debate concerning this show.
Alright people what you need to realize is MOST if not ALL of the top ten will probably move on to releasing some kind of album in the future. I've already read that Sony is dying to work with Jessica so if she doesn't win next week she will be fine. So take a chill pill. Also, ENOUGH with the race card, that is totally ridiculous.
Fact of the matter is(to me anyway)Jessica has 0 personality and that has nothing to do with her race. She is just too young in my view. Joshua is good but he just screams too much and I have a hard time understanding his words as he sings sometimes, I'm sorry. He ruined "Imagine" last night by screaming during it.
In my view, Phillip is a true artist. He's stayed true to who he is and to me that says a lot. He may have not been perfect each performance but he's given each one his all(really they all have). I absolutely loved "We've got tonight" last night. I'm pulling for him to win it! And I will be voting for him next week.
I've also read just
Joshua should of taken it ALL. and i mean 1st. place all the way. he sang his heart-out and did it so well
It doesn't matter who wins- they will all have record deals the minute they are out of the clutches of the American Idol machine.
Idol truly got it WRONG should have been Joshua and Jessica. BUT he will be just fine and rich, God does not like wrong.
I look forward to downlading Joshua Ledet post-Idol songs and might actually go to an Idols concert just to hear him.
So infair!!! Joshua should have been the winer.
@Jaye, Taylor Hicks was unique too and where is he today? Unique belongs in the local pub, talent belongs on stage.
I strongly believed Joshua Ledet should be in the finale. He is such an amazing singer. A total performer!
im sick of joshua's voice...he always shout he never sings mellow ...if Simon would still be one of the judges..he would noticed that from the start...jessica has a very smooth and powerful voice...even jimmy noticed that jessica really has the best voice in the competition..jessica deserves to be in the finale .
I love Philip's voice, but, I don't understand all of America voting HIM to stay over the other two super voices....
I can't stand Jessica and Joshua......they know they/re good and it oozes....and makes me ill..
I agree ...I am done too...I feel so badly for Joshua. Jessica has 0 personality.
I sooooo want Philip Phillips to win this--the fact that he plays musical instruments and writes his own songs makes him the best choice! Also he is so talented and unique!
Oh please. They vote on whose voice is worth listening to. The race card again??
i am more excited if the battle next week is between jessica and joshua...but america voted and i have nothing to do about it...hope people of america will vote wisely...look at the talent that the two had not only the looks!!! the most deserving one to be the next american idol lies in your vote america,,,,so don't be bias... go jessica go!!!!!if only the whole world can vote.... i know u can do it!!!
I think Randy lost it for him. He showed too much favoritism, all the standing O's made me sick, I voted for Jessica all night long. Randy showed toooo much racism, just like al roker does.at this point I don't think the judges should be giving no standing O's.
You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.
Remember My Info