Tuesdays 9:00 PM on CW

Tournament of TV Fanatic: Jared Padalecki vs. Matt Davis!

by at . Comments

Welcome back to the 1st annual Tournament of TV Fanatic!

It's time for you, TV Fanatics, to choose your favorite CW star! We will be conducting surveys among fan favorites from across the network. The concept is easy: Pick your favorite of the two pairs in each poll. That's it!

Last week, a quartet of matchups started things off: Ian Somerhalder and Scott Porter, followed by Rachel Bilson and Maggie Q, AnnaLynne McCord and Shane West and Leighton Meester and Wilson Bethel.

Ian, Rachel, Shane and Leighton currently lead, but polls remain open! On tap Monday? Our #3 seed, Supernatural star Jared Padalecki against Matt Davis of TVD and now Cult (check out the CW's Cult trailer) fame!

Which do you love most? VOTE below:

And the Winner is?

Which CW star do you love more, Jared Padalecki or Matt Davis? Vote in this first-round matchup as TV Fanatic crowns its first annual Top CW Star! View Poll »

Poll is now closed! Here are the results:

Jared Padalecki

Matt Davis

Total Votes: 4342

Still to come in round one this week: #6 Paul Wesley vs. #11 Blake Lively; #7 Jensen Ackles vs. #10 Candice Accola; #2 Ed Westwick vs. #15 Shanae Grimes.

REMINDER: If your favorite didn't make the cut, there will also be a wild card round, on top of CBS, NBC, Fox, ABC and miscellaneous (HBO, USA, etc.) brackets! Leave a comment with your nominations.

The winners will then compete for the overall tournament title! Here's the CW bracket:

TVF CW Bracket

Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.

Tags: , , , , ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more Supernatural?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic


The Vampire Diaries: Exclusive Cast Scoop!

We talked to the cast of The Vampire Diaries at Comic-Con. Ready for some Season 6 scoop?

Supernatural Scoop: Demon Dean on the Attack!

Supernatural convened at Comic-Con today. Consider yourself SPOILER WARNED and read on for some major scoop.

The Vampire Diaries Spoilers: Who Will #SaveBamon?

The Vampire Diaries cast gathered today at Comic-Con to spill on Season 6. Consider yourself spoiler warned and read on for more!

Happy 32nd Birthday, Paul Wesley!

Paul Wesley is now 32 years old. Send in your best wishes to this Vampire Diaries star.


I just want the cast of vampire diaries and the others don't matter. I can't wait for the next season. =)


I love Jared Padalecki!!!!!


wow i cant believe Matt Davis didnt win he was perfect in TVD and we be so missed


I love both actors, and they put me in voting deadlock. But with all due respect to Matt, I vote for Jared


I love Matt Davis and he is an amazing actor. But Jared Padalecki is just so amazing and flawless and talented. We've seen him play so many different Sam's and he does them all so flawlessly!


go jared


Jared for sure!!! :D


No question, JARED PADALECKI 100%!!


I don't get it!!!! how could you compare Matt Davis with Jared Padalecki!!!! Jared is a super hottie, but Matt Davis is just a common man. it's not fair. :-/