Tournament of TV Fanatic ABC Championship: Stana Katic vs. Nathan Fillion!

at . Comments

Welcome back to the 1st annual Tournament of TV Fanatic: ABC edition!

It's time for you, TV Fanatics, to choose your favorite ABC star! We have chosen 16 fan favorites for this showdown. The concept is easy: Pick your favorite of the two pairs in each poll. That's it!

Castle fans have spoken. After tough semifinal wins against Grey's Anatomy's core duo, Stana Katic and Nathan Fillion will square off for the ABC title! After tens of thousands of votes cast (and last night's Castle season premiere), they've earned it. So who's it going to be in our all-Castle final? VOTE below!

And the Winner is?

Nathan Fillion vs. Stana Katic: Which ABC star do you love the most? Vote now in the championship round matchup of the Tournament of TV Fanatic: ABC Edition! View Poll »

Poll is now closed! Here are the results:

Stana Katic

Nathan Fillion

Total Votes: 5307

The winner will be announced Friday! Here's the updated ABC field:


Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.


Okay, either way they're the best couple on ABC. I, however, cannot vote in this for the fact that I love Stana and Nathan too much. These are talented actors and they deserve this honor, but I'll let some other Castle fan vote. I can't choose.


It's sad that this poll has brought out arguments about who's better, which fans are more loyal, which actor is more deserving. Does it really matter? For example, yes, I'm a fan of Fillion, and yes, I loved Firefly, but the very fact that I'm here means that I'm also a fan of Castle, having watched every single episode. So people telling Nathan fans (me in particular) to "go vote in a geek poll" is just absurd. What, we can't love both shows? Folks, this isn't a federal election. Vote for the one you like the best, or the one you think deserves it. No need to judge others' motives and reasons, and certainly no need to justify your votes.


hahaha I agree, @Laura. \Molly's and Nathan's egos are unbelievable sometimes, I feel they are just jealous of Stana, for different reasons of course. No wonder really, Stana is perfection! Nathan could stand to lose some attitude and learn something from her, professionally and as a human being. Like somebody said already she has the most to do with Castle's success and has most difficult parts to play (brilliantly). I don't know what Nathan can be so cocky about, playing the doofus that he is, not like it's that big a stretch. "Star" my ass. And seems like this poll agrees with me, hehe...


I love both of them so much, I chose based on who looked better in each photo.
So I ended up voting for Stana.


Очень хотела увидеть Стану и �атана в финале ! � теперь в ра�тер�нно�ти !!!!


D*mn ! I really don't know which one to choose !!


This is not fair but still voted for Nathan Fillion.


That is a terrible pic of Nathan. He look so old and tired there. Comparing the banner photo on top of the page (ie. season one poster photo) with the photo used in the poll (not too long ago, since it seems like it was taken during the Spiderman movie premiere), it's a bit surprising to see how much both Nathan and Stana have changed over the years. Nonetheless, love them both.


I don't understand how Stana is not 90 % yet. I dont know anyone who likes Nathan better than her, he has to have less percents. You browncoats should not vote in our pole if you dont watch this show and many of you even want Castle canceled. It's not fair.


@vilfbrim - but the problem is that we can't see the results before voting, so we have no idea who to put the vote in for and equalize the result to 50/50. As much as I want both to present ABC to battle against other network stars in the upcoming polls, there can only be one winner. So, the question being, who do you like more? Or who would you rather representing ABC? Can't decide? Then flip a coin. 50/50 is not happening. Either way, it's a win-win for Castle fans. We made it this far. The previous finales for CW and CBS has more than 10000 vote (CW is 30000 total if memory serves me right). So whoever wins this round, we should show our support no matter what. Because there would be no Castle if not for BOTH of these two talented actors.

Tags: , , ,

Castle Quotes

Castle: The fact that you even think that breaks my heart. I would walk into a tornado for you, Kate.
Beckett: And I would die if I lost you.

Sometimes the hardest things in life are the things most worth doing.