Tournament of TV Fanatic ABC Championship: Stana Katic vs. Nathan Fillion! Comments (Page 3)
77 Comments
stana
September 26th, 2012 12:46 AM
Stana is a better actor, even Andrew Marlowe know that, he gives he much more challenging rolls. Stana is a better person, ask any Castle fan and they will tell she understands us like nobody else. Stana even looks much better on this 2 photos. Its like the Universe know what's up. You don't want to let the universe down, do you?
Lex
September 26th, 2012 12:34 AM
Franicine- this tournament is between Stana Katic as Kate Beckett and Nathan Fillion as Richard Castle. Nowhere does it say Firefly! Get over it- the show ended like a decade ago. Move on!
vilfbrim
September 26th, 2012 12:13 AM
Yes, there is all the fans gone mad. You can easily make it a draw and they both win. Will be in the Castle, the best pair of channel ABC. We love them both, and are proud of them. So it is time to stop crying and start to vote, so that was a fifty-fifty.
Jen
September 25th, 2012 11:40 PM
Woohoo!!! I'm so proud to be a Castle fanatic and so proud that both of these fabulous actors made it into the final round!!! I really don't care who wins, considering it's a win-win for me (and should be for everyone else on here who call themselves Castle fans). I chose Nathan ONLY because I've been such a massive fan of his since Firefly back in '02 and my loyalty will always be to my Captain, but Stana is incredible, too, and I love her to death! I'm still on a high from last night's season premiere!!!
To the in-fighters - Why fight? BOTH our leads made it into the finals, it's just silly to be anything other than THRILLED and happy, so please drop the senseless vitriol! Peace out, Casketteers!
Kat
September 25th, 2012 11:20 PM
Seriously people; regardless of how this poll turns out this is a win for Castle. Why does everything have to be turned into a slagging match? Stana & Nathan are both fantastic actors & clearly have the fan support to get them this far. Sure we all have our favourites, but ultimately why does it matter who wins? Both are winners for getting this far. Castle is a winner for having two cast members in the finals. And everyone else is a winner for the hard work they do day in & day out on their shows. Why can't we all just be civil? Is this really how you want to represent the show & the cast by turning it into a hatefest. Stana & Nathan have feelings you know & they deserve better than this from people who call themselves fans. Show some respect.
Krystine Gibbs Winters
September 25th, 2012 10:42 PM
I'm not voting. I can't. I love them equally as much. They're both epic actors, and I'm disappointed with how badly the Castle fandom is representing themselves. We should be cheering them BOTH on!
Shena
September 25th, 2012 9:49 PM
I can't believe some of the comments! I love Stana, but I love Nathan too! They are both so crucial to why "Castle" is so awesome. Why are we fighting over this?! Shouldn't we be cheering on both of them???
Jen
September 25th, 2012 9:30 PM
90% of you that have commented so far, do you realize how badly you are representing the Castle fandom? The in-fighting and my favorite is better than yours, and worse still the open insults to the leading man? You're an embarrassment and the very worst of our fandom.
francine
September 25th, 2012 8:56 PM
FIREFLY people!!! COME ON! MAL is BRILLIANT!!!!!
Gabrielle
September 25th, 2012 8:35 PM
I love them both dearly, but after last night's episode, I have to go with Stana. She knows the character of Kate Beckett inside and out and plays her perfectly. It's the little things like the color purple and strawberry shakes that Stana contributes to the character and make her so real, and the growth we have seen in Kate throughout the past 5 seasons is incredible. If you watch the pilot again, it's like a whole different person (in a good way of course!) Again, both actors are wonderful and they balance each other out perfectly, but Stana has the edge for me. Good luck to both! :) [+1]
me
September 25th, 2012 8:19 PM
Can we get another picture for Nathan please?
Laura
September 25th, 2012 7:57 PM
Molly please come and vote for Nathan.."the reason of Castle Success" (My ass) Stana has win the heart of this Fandom a long time ago..Nathan can go on with his firefly obsession!
Nick1372 Rank: Guest Star
September 25th, 2012 7:39 PM
… I guess not!
Nick1372 Rank: Guest Star
September 25th, 2012 7:38 PM
I may be in the minority here, but I just think Stana is a better actor than Nathan.
Teri
September 25th, 2012 6:03 PM
voting for Stana! She is the shipper I love.
clover
September 25th, 2012 5:58 PM
joyeful, I sure hope not! it was because he was shamelessly promoting himself on Twitter about People Choice, his fans are on Twitter and not so much in Castle fandom lol! This is the poll for Castle fans and they know who is the Queen of our fandom. Nathan may be good to you, browncoats or what are you calling yourself lol, but he does nothinf for fans of his current show Castle and everybody knows that. Even Castle producers know that seeing that Beckett became the main character on the show. Go vote in your geek polls, you have no chance here lol.
vilfbrim
September 25th, 2012 5:41 PM
That's what you people? We have to do 50/50 and then they both win! It will just be luck to us all!
joyeful Rank: Regular Character
September 25th, 2012 5:25 PM
@Beckstle - If Nathan's fans can get him a People's Choice award, believe me, a TV Fanatic tournament will not deter them :-)
I love them both, they're both Canadian like me....I'm gonna have to go with length of fandom for me. Nathan wins.
Lindsay
September 25th, 2012 5:19 PM
I love them both dearly, but after last night's episode, I have to go with Stana. She knows the character of Kate Beckett inside and out and plays her perfectly. It's the little things like the color purple and strawberry shakes that Stana contributes to the character and make her so real, and the growth we have seen in Kate throughout the past 5 seasons is incredible. If you watch the pilot again, it's like a whole different person (in a good way of course!) Again, both actors are wonderful and they balance each other out perfectly, but Stana has the edge for me. Good luck to both! :)
kate
September 25th, 2012 5:19 PM
I can't believe it. My dreams have come true. My two favorites stars ever in the final. Go Casketteers! We f*king rock. People have to accept this: Castle have the best fandom ever
stanagirl98
September 25th, 2012 4:47 PM
STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA KATIC IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kate
September 25th, 2012 4:40 PM
Damn, it's especially hard after just having watched Firefly... But, Stana is so fucking great)
vilfbrim
September 25th, 2012 4:28 PM
We have to do better than them two, and then we'll all be happy!
coco
September 25th, 2012 4:23 PM
Stana is my idol! Nathan is OK with comedy but Stana is genius in comedy and drama both! And she is amazingly inteligent and just precious, just read her intervies. She is no question better in every way!
Beckstle
September 25th, 2012 4:18 PM
Well, this sucks. I'm gonna vote for Stana because I think she promotes the show better. Nathan is fab, but his loyalties are divided, and thus his fanbase. For every Firefly fan who started watching Castle because of Nathan there are two others who hate Castle despite Nathan. While they might vote for Nathan here I don't see them voting for Castle up against other networks. All of Stana's fanbase is Castle & thus ABC, so votes won't jump networks. Being that most of Castle's fanbase is like me - we love them both and love the show - it doesn't really matter who wins. We're gonna vote Castle in the network vote regardless. Nathan's fanbase won't necessarily back Castle, even if they vote for him here.
Castle: You guys get this a lot? Agent J…Agent K?
September 26th, 2012 12:46 AM
Stana is a better actor, even Andrew Marlowe know that, he gives he much more challenging rolls. Stana is a better person, ask any Castle fan and they will tell she understands us like nobody else. Stana even looks much better on this 2 photos. Its like the Universe know what's up. You don't want to let the universe down, do you?
September 26th, 2012 12:34 AM
Franicine- this tournament is between Stana Katic as Kate Beckett and Nathan Fillion as Richard Castle. Nowhere does it say Firefly! Get over it- the show ended like a decade ago. Move on!
September 26th, 2012 12:13 AM
Yes, there is all the fans gone mad. You can easily make it a draw and they both win. Will be in the Castle, the best pair of channel ABC. We love them both, and are proud of them. So it is time to stop crying and start to vote, so that was a fifty-fifty.
September 25th, 2012 11:40 PM
Woohoo!!! I'm so proud to be a Castle fanatic and so proud that both of these fabulous actors made it into the final round!!! I really don't care who wins, considering it's a win-win for me (and should be for everyone else on here who call themselves Castle fans). I chose Nathan ONLY because I've been such a massive fan of his since Firefly back in '02 and my loyalty will always be to my Captain, but Stana is incredible, too, and I love her to death! I'm still on a high from last night's season premiere!!!
To the in-fighters - Why fight? BOTH our leads made it into the finals, it's just silly to be anything other than THRILLED and happy, so please drop the senseless vitriol! Peace out, Casketteers!
September 25th, 2012 11:20 PM
Seriously people; regardless of how this poll turns out this is a win for Castle. Why does everything have to be turned into a slagging match? Stana & Nathan are both fantastic actors & clearly have the fan support to get them this far. Sure we all have our favourites, but ultimately why does it matter who wins? Both are winners for getting this far. Castle is a winner for having two cast members in the finals. And everyone else is a winner for the hard work they do day in & day out on their shows. Why can't we all just be civil? Is this really how you want to represent the show & the cast by turning it into a hatefest. Stana & Nathan have feelings you know & they deserve better than this from people who call themselves fans. Show some respect.
September 25th, 2012 10:42 PM
I'm not voting. I can't. I love them equally as much. They're both epic actors, and I'm disappointed with how badly the Castle fandom is representing themselves. We should be cheering them BOTH on!
September 25th, 2012 9:49 PM
I can't believe some of the comments! I love Stana, but I love Nathan too! They are both so crucial to why "Castle" is so awesome. Why are we fighting over this?! Shouldn't we be cheering on both of them???
September 25th, 2012 9:30 PM
90% of you that have commented so far, do you realize how badly you are representing the Castle fandom? The in-fighting and my favorite is better than yours, and worse still the open insults to the leading man? You're an embarrassment and the very worst of our fandom.
September 25th, 2012 8:56 PM
FIREFLY people!!! COME ON! MAL is BRILLIANT!!!!!
September 25th, 2012 8:35 PM
I love them both dearly, but after last night's episode, I have to go with Stana. She knows the character of Kate Beckett inside and out and plays her perfectly. It's the little things like the color purple and strawberry shakes that Stana contributes to the character and make her so real, and the growth we have seen in Kate throughout the past 5 seasons is incredible. If you watch the pilot again, it's like a whole different person (in a good way of course!) Again, both actors are wonderful and they balance each other out perfectly, but Stana has the edge for me. Good luck to both! :) [+1]
September 25th, 2012 8:19 PM
Can we get another picture for Nathan please?
September 25th, 2012 7:57 PM
Molly please come and vote for Nathan.."the reason of Castle Success" (My ass) Stana has win the heart of this Fandom a long time ago..Nathan can go on with his firefly obsession!
Rank: Guest Star
September 25th, 2012 7:39 PM
… I guess not!
Rank: Guest Star
September 25th, 2012 7:38 PM
I may be in the minority here, but I just think Stana is a better actor than Nathan.
September 25th, 2012 6:03 PM
voting for Stana! She is the shipper I love.
September 25th, 2012 5:58 PM
joyeful, I sure hope not! it was because he was shamelessly promoting himself on Twitter about People Choice, his fans are on Twitter and not so much in Castle fandom lol! This is the poll for Castle fans and they know who is the Queen of our fandom. Nathan may be good to you, browncoats or what are you calling yourself lol, but he does nothinf for fans of his current show Castle and everybody knows that. Even Castle producers know that seeing that Beckett became the main character on the show. Go vote in your geek polls, you have no chance here lol.
September 25th, 2012 5:41 PM
That's what you people? We have to do 50/50 and then they both win! It will just be luck to us all!
Rank: Regular Character
September 25th, 2012 5:25 PM
@Beckstle - If Nathan's fans can get him a People's Choice award, believe me, a TV Fanatic tournament will not deter them :-)
I love them both, they're both Canadian like me....I'm gonna have to go with length of fandom for me. Nathan wins.
September 25th, 2012 5:19 PM
I love them both dearly, but after last night's episode, I have to go with Stana. She knows the character of Kate Beckett inside and out and plays her perfectly. It's the little things like the color purple and strawberry shakes that Stana contributes to the character and make her so real, and the growth we have seen in Kate throughout the past 5 seasons is incredible. If you watch the pilot again, it's like a whole different person (in a good way of course!) Again, both actors are wonderful and they balance each other out perfectly, but Stana has the edge for me. Good luck to both! :)
September 25th, 2012 5:19 PM
I can't believe it. My dreams have come true. My two favorites stars ever in the final. Go Casketteers! We f*king rock. People have to accept this: Castle have the best fandom ever
September 25th, 2012 4:47 PM
STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA!STANA KATIC IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
September 25th, 2012 4:40 PM
Damn, it's especially hard after just having watched Firefly... But, Stana is so fucking great)
September 25th, 2012 4:28 PM
We have to do better than them two, and then we'll all be happy!
September 25th, 2012 4:23 PM
Stana is my idol! Nathan is OK with comedy but Stana is genius in comedy and drama both! And she is amazingly inteligent and just precious, just read her intervies. She is no question better in every way!
September 25th, 2012 4:18 PM
Well, this sucks. I'm gonna vote for Stana because I think she promotes the show better. Nathan is fab, but his loyalties are divided, and thus his fanbase. For every Firefly fan who started watching Castle because of Nathan there are two others who hate Castle despite Nathan. While they might vote for Nathan here I don't see them voting for Castle up against other networks. All of Stana's fanbase is Castle & thus ABC, so votes won't jump networks. Being that most of Castle's fanbase is like me - we love them both and love the show - it doesn't really matter who wins. We're gonna vote Castle in the network vote regardless. Nathan's fanbase won't necessarily back Castle, even if they vote for him here.