If they are going to sell Castle coffee in stores soon, I wanna know what kind of wine they drink too. Some house and view to kill for. How many women have been here, past is past Kate. You are the one now! Ryan keeping a secret? But this show with the Hampton's detectives was something. They don't have a budget for that. Wow. Kate looked great. And again they don't have to be in bed to be together. It will all come around sooner or later. When you know a secret sometimes you don't have to say anything to reveal it. Will see.
Gene
October 17th, 2012 2:42 PM
I felt last week's episode was the best in a long time. And then this week's episode came along. I must agree with other posters about Ryan's interrogation being the highlight. One of the funniest moments in Castle history. Very well-written, acted, and edited. The shots back-and-forth between Ryan and the suspect were cut to perfection.
This season has been knocking it out of the park every week.
Ravie
October 17th, 2012 12:47 PM
I am enjoying the episodes of Castle immensely, and even though I was never a shipper of the romance arc, it is nicely done (not like on Bones, which I can't seem to get my head around). However, I notice that most of the comments here are about the relationship between Castle and Beckett, and not much about the murder case. In fact, most people say "meh" when it came to "Murder He Wrote", but they went on and on about "Caskett". That's my problem right there. No matter what relationship occurs, whether it's Castle and Beckett or Lanie and Javi, the show is a detective show and the murder and solving the crime should be front and foremost. Some of the shippers have been hard on those who aren't shippers, and that's not fair, because it's a detective show and not a love drama. I think some people forget that, even the TV Fanatic writer.
Jo
October 17th, 2012 12:28 PM
Absolutely loved this episode and the sexual tension and frustration that the murder caused between Kate and Castle. His expressions when he could not get what he wanted were so to the point. I also loved the way Kate's colleagues wanted so badly to find out who her boyfriend was. Smart as they are had to give up even when the obvious is right under their noses. Cannot wait for the next episode.
Maria
October 17th, 2012 10:15 AM
I loved this episode, so AMAZING! When I think this show can´t get any better, I´m proven wrong; this season has been amazing since it started. It´s hard to pick a moment, there were so many great ones: "none of them were you", Ryan and Espo tracking Beckett´s ex´s, all the hot C & B moment´s, the Caskett thing...but Ryan finding out, LOL; I was watching online at 3.am. (european) and laughed so much I was affraid I would wake up my neighbours:) I´ve never seen Ryan so hard on a suspect!!!
All in all, amazing episode, amazing show!!
D
October 17th, 2012 4:54 AM
Love this show. It's the only show that I would watch with my 15-yr old daughter without getting slightly embarassed - because all the scenes with any couple are so tastefully done - unlike most of the other primetime shows. And the humor is great - I am always laughing out loud as if the show was actually a comedy. As for Nathan Fillion's weight - I have no idea why people find this to be an issue - quite frankly he looks more handsome now than in past seasons. I think they complement each other perfectly.
David
October 17th, 2012 12:45 AM
I give it
10+
fortyseven Rank: Regular Character
October 16th, 2012 11:51 PM
Too many cliches and the case was poorly written and contrived. I did think the sheriff did it mid-episode. I liked the Caskett line and Ryan keeping the secret.
Some cottage!!
I was on the floor laughing at Ryan's expression after the man says Kate's name. Detective, huh?
DeAnn Rank: Recurring Character
October 16th, 2012 9:39 PM
I loved this episode, and I agree that there is no Moonlighting curse at all on Castle...Caskett are perfectly marvelous together and very real as a couple.
The quotes were hilarious, and I was also so glad that Ryan kept their secret. And also glad to see Lani being fierce and giving Javi the stink-eye!
Teri
October 16th, 2012 8:43 PM
Castle keeps climbing upward each episode with it's writing and acting. Can Stana Katic look any more gorgeous?
Wilhelmina
October 16th, 2012 5:27 PM
Wonderful episode in a perfect season so far. My very favorite part was the homage at the end to old time films with the starry night with a shooting star rather than showing them in bed.
teachemwell Rank: Extra
October 16th, 2012 4:17 PM
GREAT episode! Best line? "...none of them were you."
WOW What a great show from start to finish Nave to watch it two or three times to get all of it all. The writers did a fantastic job I mean the look on Kate's face some times was LOL. I don.t want to repeat all the good stuff the other people said. Ilove what the gangster said and the reaction that Rick and Kate had funny. And Ryan and Esposito trying to protected Kate LOL and so much more. And the last scene was great the writers did it perfect. I loved his House. In the show he is rich. It was a good place to have a show for a change. And his first wife cheated on him with her producer and his second wife they were never in Love just had great sex. And that why they Parted company. Remenber when they went to the Hampton house for the summer and she stayed two weeks.And he wrote a new book. again a great show.
cheryl
October 16th, 2012 3:11 PM
Love the episode as I do all of them! But Ryan....you were awesome and love that you are willing to keep it a secret. Out of respect and friendship for them. Really worried about the 5x05 episode. And as ALWAYS Caskett fans stick together. So Michael...you have a right to comment but DON'T come in here to downgrade a great show! And yea there is no Moonlighting curse or Bones BS! CASTLE stands on it's on! Great writers,producers and directors. The Cast is in a LEAGUE of it's own. Best Show all around!!
William Bruce
October 16th, 2012 3:01 PM
Beckett being called his hooker was cute. As was the actions between them that ranged from excited about the case, to the sexual angst when they are interrupted. Just like in real life,lol. A good mix of people, from Aaron Lerner(who from first pic I thought did it),to Natalia Roosevelt, to Marty Bentley, Dock operator. I didn't figure Meth head, Casius McMurray, or Vinny "The Scar" Cardano(Bob "That 70's Show" and just on Sundays, "The Mentalist"), did it. "It was bush league" Funny how Castle woke up McMurray, to ask him a question. But between the Boats and the Helicopter it all fell into place. More were involved then I originally thought would be. Nice touch.
Having Ryan and Esposito helping from back at Squad room was good.And Ryan's interview was a good one. Surprised he was in there alone.
Didn't get who had out Aaron Lerner's boat, must be the deputy? Nice shooting star at the end. To bad Angela Lansbury couldn't have made at least a cameo.
William Bruce
October 16th, 2012 2:56 PM
Great Episode! I actually worried that Chief Brady was in on it some how.In my notes I wrote, "is he clueless or in on it?" But to have it be Deputy Jones, he should have been in the story a little more. Castle figuring out the Lanyard tying was good.
Kinda cool to have Ryan figure it out first, but Espo maybe mad at him again when he finds out Ryan knew and didn't talk.
The Hampton place actually made me think of the Kennedy homes. it was nice that Beckett wondered about all of Castle's conquests in it. The pool scene was shaping up to be good, until Randall Franklin fell in the pool. Of course he'd pick Castles Place to die,lol. Castle-"Call 911", Beckett-"You think?" Priceless. Castle excited to help and of course Beckett wanting to hide, to not raise suspicion. Laying on bed, Castle wants to figure it out. Beckett not so much, nice.
Beckett being called his hooker was cute. As was the actions between them that ranged from excited about the case, to the sexual angst when th
Bill
October 16th, 2012 2:19 PM
We can understand how Castle managed to blast past two wives. He is nearly attacked in bed by a sexually aggressive woman, and all he can think about is a murder story.
Jennifer
October 16th, 2012 1:47 PM
Castle is a great show. The idea of how shallow and rich he was was a great idea and the fact that he had had other women in that house was also great ... "But NONE of them were you". I mean he just mealted my heart then. Of course Castle was shallow and snooty rich but he has a heart of gold and he was Peter Pan who is just now starting to grow up with a quite remarkably beautiful lady in Kate. I'd grow up too if I could have that in my arms every morning ... She is lovely and gets better with each show. Hope next week I don't see CASKETT having too much difficulty and falling apart so quickly with him accused of murder. Crossing my fingers for them both.
Lisa
October 16th, 2012 1:44 PM
"We are Caskett" was great. Awesome epi! I loved how Ryan got so crazy angry and commanding interrogating that dude to find out who Castle's girlfriend was. I watched that scene a few times.
Glitter
October 16th, 2012 1:28 PM
I liked the reference to "Tying the Knot." Third time's the charm I hear. The hastily and clumsily tied knot, the first one, really tripped Castle up. The second (and maybe someday, the third?) are deliberately neat. I suppose it depends upon why you are tying the knot.
Legion
October 16th, 2012 1:24 PM
@Turquoise: WHAT is this thing against marriage a disturbing number of people seem to have? I personally can't for that proposal, for several reasons. I agree that 'Bones' muffed Booth/Brennan up, but seeing as they did that in the fourth season and never stopped, the get-together wasn't going to do anything BUT suck. However, this is 'Castle' - and you can't have fun forever. Marriage is the next step when you truly love someone and want to spend your life with them. I'm sorry you don't feel that way, but don"t wish it on the rest of us, please?
As for this ep, I laughed until I cried at Ryan' interrogation and the phone call with Castle after.
alanapaints
October 16th, 2012 1:22 PM
LOVED this episode. Only false note to me was the 5 o'clock scene - Ryan and Esposito both know that C&B are in love. Rick was just way too perky considering that he should be massively jealous and bummed-out that she's going off for the weekend with her 'new boyfriend'. Castle's a better liar than that, and they would have either called him on it or remarked on how pathetic he is, after the fact. But it was played for laughs and very funny. Ryan's interrogation scene was absolutely priceless.
I loved the Eddie Vedder/ukulele song "longing to belong". I thought it set the mood really well for Kate's wistfulness when they arrive at this big, elegant house with all of Rick's memories in it - none of them including her. They played her sense of intimidation and disconnection really well, just by timing how they moved through the space together and apart. Very human.
This is definitely in my top 20 favorites, maybe on second viewing, top 10.
null
October 16th, 2012 1:20 PM
it was okay, but loathed the house porn. this inreased emphasis on Castle's weath is a bit much. All of the sudden the audience cares more because he is dating Kate? probably, but talk about rubbing our nose in the shallow end of humanity.
turquoise
October 16th, 2012 1:07 PM
They are a great couple! But if in the future Kate becomes pregnant i will stop watching! Loved Bones until all the domestic bliss came into play!
Castle and Kate take the advice of someone who knows...have a great relationship, but PLEASE no baby or marriage..
Castle: Katherine Houghton Beckett, will you marry me?
October 17th, 2012 2:47 PM
If they are going to sell Castle coffee in stores soon, I wanna know what kind of wine they drink too. Some house and view to kill for. How many women have been here, past is past Kate. You are the one now! Ryan keeping a secret? But this show with the Hampton's detectives was something. They don't have a budget for that. Wow. Kate looked great. And again they don't have to be in bed to be together. It will all come around sooner or later. When you know a secret sometimes you don't have to say anything to reveal it. Will see.
October 17th, 2012 2:42 PM
I felt last week's episode was the best in a long time. And then this week's episode came along. I must agree with other posters about Ryan's interrogation being the highlight. One of the funniest moments in Castle history. Very well-written, acted, and edited. The shots back-and-forth between Ryan and the suspect were cut to perfection.
This season has been knocking it out of the park every week.
October 17th, 2012 12:47 PM
I am enjoying the episodes of Castle immensely, and even though I was never a shipper of the romance arc, it is nicely done (not like on Bones, which I can't seem to get my head around). However, I notice that most of the comments here are about the relationship between Castle and Beckett, and not much about the murder case. In fact, most people say "meh" when it came to "Murder He Wrote", but they went on and on about "Caskett". That's my problem right there. No matter what relationship occurs, whether it's Castle and Beckett or Lanie and Javi, the show is a detective show and the murder and solving the crime should be front and foremost. Some of the shippers have been hard on those who aren't shippers, and that's not fair, because it's a detective show and not a love drama. I think some people forget that, even the TV Fanatic writer.
October 17th, 2012 12:28 PM
Absolutely loved this episode and the sexual tension and frustration that the murder caused between Kate and Castle. His expressions when he could not get what he wanted were so to the point. I also loved the way Kate's colleagues wanted so badly to find out who her boyfriend was. Smart as they are had to give up even when the obvious is right under their noses. Cannot wait for the next episode.
October 17th, 2012 10:15 AM
I loved this episode, so AMAZING! When I think this show can´t get any better, I´m proven wrong; this season has been amazing since it started. It´s hard to pick a moment, there were so many great ones: "none of them were you", Ryan and Espo tracking Beckett´s ex´s, all the hot C & B moment´s, the Caskett thing...but Ryan finding out, LOL; I was watching online at 3.am. (european) and laughed so much I was affraid I would wake up my neighbours:) I´ve never seen Ryan so hard on a suspect!!!
All in all, amazing episode, amazing show!!
October 17th, 2012 4:54 AM
Love this show. It's the only show that I would watch with my 15-yr old daughter without getting slightly embarassed - because all the scenes with any couple are so tastefully done - unlike most of the other primetime shows. And the humor is great - I am always laughing out loud as if the show was actually a comedy. As for Nathan Fillion's weight - I have no idea why people find this to be an issue - quite frankly he looks more handsome now than in past seasons. I think they complement each other perfectly.
October 17th, 2012 12:45 AM
I give it
10+
Rank: Regular Character
October 16th, 2012 11:51 PM
Too many cliches and the case was poorly written and contrived. I did think the sheriff did it mid-episode. I liked the Caskett line and Ryan keeping the secret.
Rank: Extra
October 16th, 2012 11:01 PM
Some cottage!!
I was on the floor laughing at Ryan's expression after the man says Kate's name. Detective, huh?
Rank: Recurring Character
October 16th, 2012 9:39 PM
I loved this episode, and I agree that there is no Moonlighting curse at all on Castle...Caskett are perfectly marvelous together and very real as a couple.
The quotes were hilarious, and I was also so glad that Ryan kept their secret. And also glad to see Lani being fierce and giving Javi the stink-eye!
October 16th, 2012 8:43 PM
Castle keeps climbing upward each episode with it's writing and acting. Can Stana Katic look any more gorgeous?
October 16th, 2012 5:27 PM
Wonderful episode in a perfect season so far. My very favorite part was the homage at the end to old time films with the starry night with a shooting star rather than showing them in bed.
Rank: Extra
October 16th, 2012 4:17 PM
GREAT episode! Best line? "...none of them were you."
And Ryan? Wonderful secret keeping.
Lanie probably knows...just saying....women's intuition!
October 16th, 2012 3:53 PM
WOW What a great show from start to finish Nave to watch it two or three times to get all of it all. The writers did a fantastic job I mean the look on Kate's face some times was LOL. I don.t want to repeat all the good stuff the other people said. Ilove what the gangster said and the reaction that Rick and Kate had funny. And Ryan and Esposito trying to protected Kate LOL and so much more. And the last scene was great the writers did it perfect. I loved his House. In the show he is rich. It was a good place to have a show for a change. And his first wife cheated on him with her producer and his second wife they were never in Love just had great sex. And that why they Parted company. Remenber when they went to the Hampton house for the summer and she stayed two weeks.And he wrote a new book. again a great show.
October 16th, 2012 3:11 PM
Love the episode as I do all of them! But Ryan....you were awesome and love that you are willing to keep it a secret. Out of respect and friendship for them. Really worried about the 5x05 episode. And as ALWAYS Caskett fans stick together. So Michael...you have a right to comment but DON'T come in here to downgrade a great show! And yea there is no Moonlighting curse or Bones BS! CASTLE stands on it's on! Great writers,producers and directors. The Cast is in a LEAGUE of it's own. Best Show all around!!
October 16th, 2012 3:01 PM
Beckett being called his hooker was cute. As was the actions between them that ranged from excited about the case, to the sexual angst when they are interrupted. Just like in real life,lol. A good mix of people, from Aaron Lerner(who from first pic I thought did it),to Natalia Roosevelt, to Marty Bentley, Dock operator. I didn't figure Meth head, Casius McMurray, or Vinny "The Scar" Cardano(Bob "That 70's Show" and just on Sundays, "The Mentalist"), did it. "It was bush league" Funny how Castle woke up McMurray, to ask him a question. But between the Boats and the Helicopter it all fell into place. More were involved then I originally thought would be. Nice touch.
Having Ryan and Esposito helping from back at Squad room was good.And Ryan's interview was a good one. Surprised he was in there alone.
Didn't get who had out Aaron Lerner's boat, must be the deputy? Nice shooting star at the end. To bad Angela Lansbury couldn't have made at least a cameo.
October 16th, 2012 2:56 PM
Great Episode! I actually worried that Chief Brady was in on it some how.In my notes I wrote, "is he clueless or in on it?" But to have it be Deputy Jones, he should have been in the story a little more. Castle figuring out the Lanyard tying was good.
Kinda cool to have Ryan figure it out first, but Espo maybe mad at him again when he finds out Ryan knew and didn't talk.
The Hampton place actually made me think of the Kennedy homes. it was nice that Beckett wondered about all of Castle's conquests in it. The pool scene was shaping up to be good, until Randall Franklin fell in the pool. Of course he'd pick Castles Place to die,lol. Castle-"Call 911", Beckett-"You think?" Priceless. Castle excited to help and of course Beckett wanting to hide, to not raise suspicion. Laying on bed, Castle wants to figure it out. Beckett not so much, nice.
Beckett being called his hooker was cute. As was the actions between them that ranged from excited about the case, to the sexual angst when th
October 16th, 2012 2:19 PM
We can understand how Castle managed to blast past two wives. He is nearly attacked in bed by a sexually aggressive woman, and all he can think about is a murder story.
October 16th, 2012 1:47 PM
Castle is a great show. The idea of how shallow and rich he was was a great idea and the fact that he had had other women in that house was also great ... "But NONE of them were you". I mean he just mealted my heart then. Of course Castle was shallow and snooty rich but he has a heart of gold and he was Peter Pan who is just now starting to grow up with a quite remarkably beautiful lady in Kate. I'd grow up too if I could have that in my arms every morning ... She is lovely and gets better with each show. Hope next week I don't see CASKETT having too much difficulty and falling apart so quickly with him accused of murder. Crossing my fingers for them both.
October 16th, 2012 1:44 PM
"We are Caskett" was great. Awesome epi! I loved how Ryan got so crazy angry and commanding interrogating that dude to find out who Castle's girlfriend was. I watched that scene a few times.
October 16th, 2012 1:28 PM
I liked the reference to "Tying the Knot." Third time's the charm I hear. The hastily and clumsily tied knot, the first one, really tripped Castle up. The second (and maybe someday, the third?) are deliberately neat. I suppose it depends upon why you are tying the knot.
October 16th, 2012 1:24 PM
@Turquoise: WHAT is this thing against marriage a disturbing number of people seem to have? I personally can't for that proposal, for several reasons. I agree that 'Bones' muffed Booth/Brennan up, but seeing as they did that in the fourth season and never stopped, the get-together wasn't going to do anything BUT suck. However, this is 'Castle' - and you can't have fun forever. Marriage is the next step when you truly love someone and want to spend your life with them. I'm sorry you don't feel that way, but don"t wish it on the rest of us, please?
As for this ep, I laughed until I cried at Ryan' interrogation and the phone call with Castle after.
October 16th, 2012 1:22 PM
LOVED this episode. Only false note to me was the 5 o'clock scene - Ryan and Esposito both know that C&B are in love. Rick was just way too perky considering that he should be massively jealous and bummed-out that she's going off for the weekend with her 'new boyfriend'. Castle's a better liar than that, and they would have either called him on it or remarked on how pathetic he is, after the fact. But it was played for laughs and very funny. Ryan's interrogation scene was absolutely priceless.
I loved the Eddie Vedder/ukulele song "longing to belong". I thought it set the mood really well for Kate's wistfulness when they arrive at this big, elegant house with all of Rick's memories in it - none of them including her. They played her sense of intimidation and disconnection really well, just by timing how they moved through the space together and apart. Very human.
This is definitely in my top 20 favorites, maybe on second viewing, top 10.
October 16th, 2012 1:20 PM
it was okay, but loathed the house porn. this inreased emphasis on Castle's weath is a bit much. All of the sudden the audience cares more because he is dating Kate? probably, but talk about rubbing our nose in the shallow end of humanity.
October 16th, 2012 1:07 PM
They are a great couple! But if in the future Kate becomes pregnant i will stop watching! Loved Bones until all the domestic bliss came into play!
Castle and Kate take the advice of someone who knows...have a great relationship, but PLEASE no baby or marriage..