Mondays 10:00 PM on ABC
Castle

107 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Avatar

Time Will Tell...best Castle episode EVER!

Avatar

Our roy montgomery,

I really find it hard to believe the writers do not understand fans understand the canon pretty well and if it \changes want nay demand answers.

Really have they learnt nothing about the outcry of the final arc.

I have tried to make sense of it. try not trampis. tumblr. com

There is actually a debate about it!

Avatar

nottrampis. Agree. The Kate 'first guy moving in' thing was put in as a convenience for writer purposes. IMO. The comment was not consistent with Kate's past history. She is engaged to Castle now, but to know that Beckett had previously moved in with more than one guy, yet hasn't moved in with Castle despite the seriousness of their relationship as well, it just doesn't make sense. If that happened more than once before her mother's murder that would surprise me given that Kate was only 19 at the time. If it happened too soon after her mother's murder, I would have a hard time believing that her dad would have been involved in her life enough to be upset because of his drinking issues. Plus, after her mother died it has always been implied that Beckett may have had relationships, but none that were that serious because she didn't really love any of them.

Comment modified at

Avatar

Christine she would have had to be left quite a bit of money and she does have an expensive wardrobe!

I think the writers put in the living with someone at 19 with no thought to previous episodes.

thus we now have a changed canon.

i write today on how it is unlikely with Castle, actually it is impossible so either the writers were clueless about previous episodes or Alexis thought 20 and 19 were close anyway.

Unless one of the two has a reasonably good job I would have thought living together would be very hard!

As I said look up my tumblr blog if you are interested.

Avatar

hormones plays a roll in their decisions too. The writers are fulfilling their objective, we all are talking about "Alexis and her moving out" A/M and his muse are such an impressive writers, episode 6x05 was a nice change of pace, I like "Time will Tell" albeit I had to watched it twice, I watch a lot of "Castle" episodes twice for different reasons, this time I watched twice because Joshua Gomez (Doyle) spoke too fast and I missed some of the dialogue. "Number one Fan" 6x04, which I consider the best episode of the season until now, was an tough act to follow and A/M and his muse brought to the table a poignant and intriguing episode and they were able to deliver.

Avatar

I am so surprise that a lot of fans think that the comments of Beckett about her moving in with a guy when she was 19 were out of line for her character, we all know that kids do crazy things when they are young and they think it is normal, I had a nephew (who was a straight arrow with a good job and going to college) he was 19 yrs old, dated divorced women of 25/26 yrs old ("older women" for him) with children and move in with them!! nothing we could do! We kept quiet and waited. Today he finished his college education and is an Area Marketing Director for a 500 company and is happily married to a beautiful girl and has three children, Girls will do the same or worst, some will only move out for few months especially the ones that are smart and independent, "it's an adventure" they are living "their life" they said. I happen to believe that it is not scandalous or inappropriate, it is just a "phase" their way to grow up and find themselves, not everybody does it but a lot do, hormones play an important roll in their decisions too. The writers are fulfilling their objective, we all are discussing Alexis and her "moving out", A/M and his muse are such impressive writers. Episode 6x05 was intriguing and good, I had to watched it twice but I do that with a lot of the "Castle" episodes for different reasons, I watched "Time will Tell" twice because Joshua Gomez (Doyle) spoke too fast and I miss some of the dialogue but in general It was a nice change of pace, 6x04 "Number one fan", which I consider the best episode of the season until now, was a tough act to follow but A/M and his muse brought a poignant and intriguing episode to the table and they were able to deliver.

Corlando

Also, anyone having problems with their comments getting stuck in moderation can click on my name and send me a private message. We get a lot of spammers and our spam software is always adjusting to block them out. Sometimes regular posters get caught up in it. Usually if you aren't posting spam or links it will let you through after a few days. If you're having problems send me a message. I can't guarantee I can fix it but I'll definitely try.

And I apologize for any inconvenience. We definitely want to continue to see you here at TV Fanatic. :)

Christine

Corlando

Continued...

-Beckett's apartment. I wish they'd given us some sort of explanation but given NYC real estate, I can see her subletting. That apartment in the West Village would be anywhere from $1 to $2 million. Ridiculous on a cop's salary but I read something long ago that said Beckett was left money when her mom died. That's the only explanation that comes close to making sense but it's never been mentioned on the show. I love the place so I just write it off as a TV apartment…like on Friends where Rachel and Monica were able to afford their apartment. In real life it never would have happened.

Corlando

HI All,

I just thought I'd add my 2 cents into the conversation.

-Timeline issues: At least Alexis being home was sort of explained. I'm going with it's late August in the Castle world. As for all of the things we'e seen over the last couple of episodes with October dates…I have to chalk it up to continuity errors. That the visual effects folks and the writers weren't on the same page because of the Alexis timeline. It's annoying but I'm letting it go from here on out. Of course if this next episode talks about Halloween then none of it makes sense. :(

-Beckett's ring: Personally I'd think wearing that ring on the job would just be asking for serious trouble. I can see her wearing it on a chain while at work but I don't know that it would work with every outfit. I suppose it's a personal thing because I don't always wear my rings so I don't take it as seriously as some others do.

Continued...

Avatar

For anyone interested I write about Castle/Beckett and Alexis all moving in with someone at 19 at mt my tumblr blog. just type my name then tumblr then com.

Tel mt what you think. Like the timelines I believe thee are writers errors here, Castle's can be explained away. a year out but Beckett's cannot be.

I think it adds to my married man thesis!

These are only minor faults in a good episode but I agree with Captain Cook Marlowe does nothing ( intentionally) to undermine Beckett but Castle is another thing entirely!

I did write yesterday on my google blog on how he has unintentionally deliberately made Beckett look stupid and selfish but for a good reason!




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register