Downton Abbey Review: House Party

by at .  Updated at . Comments

The Crawleys throw a house party on Downton Abbey Season 4 Episode 2, but there wasn't a greal deal of merriment when all is said and done.

Frankly, by the time the episode ended, it was difficult to think of much other than Anna. 

I didn't catch exactly why there was a party, nor how the guest list was put together. It was rather surprising that Lady Edith was allowed to invite her married cohort, Mr. Gregson. As they keep reminding viewers (literally, they say it -- a lot), things have changed since the war.

Edith had Gregson as a guest; a chap who grew up with the ladies was invited, Anthony Foley -- now Lord Gillingham -- who was chatting up Mary, making her wish for a) Matthew or b) the Mary who kicked sand in the face of life on a regular basis before her heart was softened by her love for Matthew; and Dame Nellie Melba was going to be singing for the guests. 

Dame Nellie's arrival (after the war) meant that all of the household staff -- kitchen included! -- would also be able to enjoy the festivities. Imagine that. 

Back to Downton

As much as things have changed since the war, it's still bloody difficult to understand who everyone is when they start with that tricky, posh naming convention wherein the staff takes the name of their (I don't know what you call them, really) master and then people like Lord Gillingham's valet, Mr. Green, is sometimes also referred to as Gillingham. That happened in the Highlands on Downton Abbey Season 3 and I was equally as confused. 

Tom Branson made the mistake of calling a Duchess "Your Grace," which outside of that particular situation would have been proper, but at the party was incorrect. By the end of the social engagement, he felt so out of sorts he had confided in Edna Braithwaite and she may have slipped into his room after the festivities. Poor Tom. He told Robert he felt as if he had let everyone down and didn't belong. You and me both, Tom.

Mary and Isobel were both struggling with what must have been the first big social situation for the both since Matthew's death. We missed out on six months of their lives, but given their behavior, that's the only logical conclusion. By the end of the evening Isobel was in far better spirits, and Mary? We'll have to wait and see, but it appears she'll be seeing a bit more of Gillingham. She (literally) got back up on that horse.

Edith's Gregson managed to win the favor, however so slight, of Robert by evening's end by winning back his poker losses to a card sharp named Sampson who could have been cheating. The whole card playing scenario was a bit confusing, what they were betting and losing and what the IOUs consisted of -- whether money or something else. In any event, he'll not be persona non grata any longer. Maybe he'll just be a bit of a nuisance.

With all of the visiting servants, it was a jolly mood both downstairs as well as upstairs. Everyone was playing a raucous game of cards downstairs and Mrs. Patmore had a bit of a panic attack. Daisy took it to be a heart attack, but thankfully Dr. Clarkson was on hand to ensure she was alright.

Because Green had earlier flirted with Anna, I think Bates was a bit put out that Anna was so enjoying the game of cards that he had thrown together. While they were all laughing and enjoying themselves (the nerve!), Mrs. Patmore was falling ill and Bates was very angry; something he took out on Anna. It was a bit embarrassing and unnecessary, the way Bates spoke to Anna. After everything she's been through with him, he should know by now that she has eyes for no other man.

It was only a short while later when the entire household was gathered around listening to Dame Nellie sing that Anna fell ill. While she went to get a cure for her headache, she was confronted by Green and brutally raped. There's no need to go into details here, because you watched it. 

There was an irony to the situation, in that Bates and everyone else were upstairs, enjoying themselves with the noise and merriment -- Bates even took a moment to note to Mrs. Hughes that Anna must have fallen asleep downstairs -- while Anna was screaming for help, going unheard.

It was almost a mirror for the Mrs. Patmore incident that Bates had earlier chastised Anna. Instead of enjoying himself, he should have been looking after his wife. If at that second when he wondered if she had fallen asleep he had gone to find her, things could have turned out differently.

I'm not blaming the incident on Bates. I'm not even saying that he could have stopped it. I'm merely pointing out how incredibly eerie it was that those two things happened under such similar circumstances. 

Anna made her decision to keep what happened from anyone but Mrs. Hughes, and her reasoning is sound, even after the war. In Downton a woman may have had a better chance of being taken seriously, but given Cora's willingness to believe someone like Edna Braithwaite over Mrs. Hughes, the upstairs folks don't always see things clearly.

While Bates is a convicted felon and could be held accountable for whatever he chose to do to Green, I'd like to think after what he's been through he might think first and act second. He did tell Anna he learned quite a bit in prison. Then again, his anger at her could be part of the reason she had a headache, because she felt as if she let him down. Neither one of them were thinking clearly by the end of the night.

This development wasn't covered up very well on the Internet, and I knew it was on the way. The part that shocked me the most was how it happened so closely after Mrs. Patmore's panic attack was almost overlooked during a gleeful celebration. There is a lesson to be learned in that, but I don't know what it is. 

Anna's flimsy excuse about falling down and spilling wine was obviously a cover-up. The likelihood is their marriage will suffer another tremendous blow for a good portion of the remainder of the season. If Lord Gillingham is going to be courting Mary, it may come to a head the next time valet Green makes an appearance. Anna could barely hold it together while the creep made his goodbyes. How will she manage the next time he says hello?

I don't know how realistic the amount of heartbreak that occurs at Downton is to the times, but I have to wonder why such travesties are chosen for stories over other types of drama. There have been four deaths of note, William, Lavinia, Sybil and Matthew, the murder of Vera Bates, and the felony conviction of John Bates. Matthew was paralyzed in the war prior to his death. Thomas was beaten silly and Anna was raped.

I realize this is a soap opera, but there is so much to explore with the historical aspect, that I wonder if perhaps keeping the setting as a upstairs/downstairs scenario is curtailing what could be an otherwise larger story to draw upon.

Do you think Anna should have told Bates what happened?

TV Fanatics Love Prime Instant Video
Amazon Prime Instant Video
Watch Downton Abbey Now!


Editor Rating: 4.8 / 5.0
  • 4.8 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 3.7 / 5.0 (18 Votes)

Carissa Pavlica is the managing editor and staff writer for TV Fanatic. Follow her on Twitter and on Google+.

Tags: ,

We watched D Abbey as a family. We will never watch it again.


I liked this episode of DA. Felt like the first season, which also had a house party and equal amounts of comedy and drama. O'Brien and Thomas were particularly vicious in Season 1. So, I can't understand why so many people are "offended" at Anna's rape. Really? Why? Is rape only something that's supposed to happen in London, in the poorer parts of town? Or do people just think DA portrays dreamy world of parasols and butlers? I'm pretty sure servants were raped on grand English estates, especially female servants. Yes, it's was ugly. But, we don't want DA to become a boring, stodgy series where we just watch the staff plate meals and do a lady's hair, do we?


After all the tragedies in this show I am fed up. I do not intend to watch Downton Abbey ever again.


After all of the tragedies I have am totally offended by the plot; especially Anna's rape sequence. I don't intend to watch this show ever again.


I was glad, in a small way, to see Cora finally step up and take charge of a situation for once, instead of smiling indulgently at everyone. "(Dame Nelly) will be next to you at dinner, and you will like it." OK, so it wasn't a "high drama" situation, but maybe it's a sign of things to come. As for the reviewer's confusion about naming conventions, that's how things were done--writers of the original "Upstairs Downstairs" and "Gosford Park" (which was written by Julian Fellowes, the writer for DA) made careful use of this convention. Below stairs, the servants of the visitors were called by their "masters" last names. It's really only upstairs where it might get confusing.


If you think about it, Mrs. Hughes needs to know who the rapist is because it is unsafe to have someone like that sleeping in the house. None of her girls would be safe and since she is in charge along with Carson, they need to kick out the perpetrator!
I am really mad at the writers for adding this to the story line.
it totally ruined a nice evening viewing with the house party atmosphere.

@ Patty

Mrs. Hughes saw the rapist return to the performance, so it will be interesting to see hopefully how she pieces it together. Bates will piece it together when he sees Anna's injuries, so the healing process can begin for her.


I don't read spoilers, so I did NOT see that coming! Wow, it shook me up. She should have told Bates, or at the very least allowed Dr. Clarkson to check her out. Definitely Mr. Carson should know. He would know best how to deal with the situation. Tom Branson needs to stay FAR FAR away from that conniving maid!

@ Jennifer

Edna Braithwaite is the ONLY part of this season I don't like. Tom is letting his loneliness get to him. I think Sybil's family has done all they can to make him feel welcome and involved in the estate. He needs to stop making so many comparisons, and get a sense of humor about all the silly rules & customs.

@ Jennifer

I'd like to see Fellowes write in a twist here. We saw the maid sneak into a bedroom and we're assuming it's Tom's, but……suppose it's not? Or suppose Tom is wise to her and he's sitting in a chair, wide awake, fully dressed, the whiskey undrunk, and he turns her out? Or suppose Carson's in the room ready to catch her in the act? Oh I know…a little far-fetched since Tom's a lonely man who's been handed an alcoholic beverage, but it was only a passing thought.


The rape of Anna never should have happened. Why put that into the story line. Why? Also, all of Mrs. Hughes brilliant handling of the maid after Tom situation from last year just went down the drain with this ridiculous new story line about this maid. Why can we not have a nice weekend at Downton without nastiness. These writers need to get their heads checked.

@ Patty

Because that's life. Women get raped for no reason at all. Married women. Single women. Young, old, rich, poor...that's the point. There is NO logical reason for rape. It's violent. It's a crime. It's a brutal invasion of a woman's safety and security. Yet it happens for NO GOOD REASON. I think people are upset because mentally they still equate happy endings w/"goodness" and unhappy developments w/"badness." Life isn't that black & white, cut and dry. Bad things happen to good people, and DA has shown that in all its 4 seasons.

Downton Abbey Season 4 Episode 2 Quotes

Jimmy: Of course it was poker. You can't lose a fortune playing snap.
Molesley: I could.

  • Permalink:
  • Added:

Oh you know Mary. She's always quite opaque.