Cotton: Confession. I thought on occasion my character might have been improved by the infrequent tussle.
John: Oh yeah, beatings done you a world of good.

Well, the good folks of Salem declared you a drunk, not a witch. You're sprung.

John

Thieves have come to ransack the orphanage now that the town sees fit to hang its guardian.

John

There was a time when I might have suckled more than a toad.

Mary

Cotton: Pray for her.
John: I call bullshit. She's clearly touched in the head. She needs a doctor, not your prayers.

Mary: What do you want girl?
Mercy: I want it to stop. The torture, the torment, the suffering... or I will tell them. I will tell them all who and what you are.

We know that what we desire and what we must do to survive are often at odds.

Mary

Mary: My husband's affliction has robbed him of both reason and sense.
Hook: And yet are either actually required to point the finger in Salem?

Why? Because this is the fulfillment of all our dreams. Vengeance for centuries of oppression.

Mary

Glorianna: So you would buy me outright?
Cotton: I'm an only child. I never learned to share.
Glorianna: Which is as close as a man like you comes to an apology. Was it really so very painful for you to see me with another?
Cotton: Yes. Will you be mine?

The secret is useless. John Alden will not leave Salem over a gambling debt.

Hale

Do you know what Salem abhors even more than a witch, reverend? A Catholic. Yet under your watchful eye you have now allowed both to flourish.

Mary

Salem Quotes

All the world shall be yours in return; all the world.

Tituba

John: Judge not, lets ye be judged.
Sibley: Who said that?
Jesus. You might have heard of him.