The next time you see that witch in a dream, tell her to be more specific. I mean, her husband's about to be a dead man.

Jenny

To ensure he never rides again, my life he must end. It's the only way.

Ichabod

Ichabod: And through these centuries against the impossibilities that we would find each other, we did.
Abbie: How can you be so calm about it?
Ichabod: I'm terrified.

No, my death saved your soul. Only you chose to see it as regret.

Arthur Bernard

Ichabod: My ears shall remain eternally open to you admonition.
Abbie: I don't know what the hell that means. Just say yes.

This goes without saying, but in your version of events, make sure your perp is not headless.

Irving

The Horseman is here to hasten the end of days, just as he tried before. We must retrieve his head before he does, and this time, we must destroy it.

Ichabod

Irving: I need to fill out a report. I need to call the Governor.
Ichabod: What are you going to tell him?
Irving: What do you think I'm going to tell him? The Headless Horseman is mowing people down to bring about the end of days? For further questions, call Ichabod Crane, the man who beheaded him in 1781?

Abbie: The midnight ride. One if by land, two if by sea.
Ichabod: You've heard of it?
Abbie: Word may have gotten around.

Abbie: You printed this five times.
Ichabod: Correct.
Abbie: Why?
Ichabod: In case the picture vanishes from the screen like it did a moment ago.

Flummoxed by a foreign concept that resembles close to nothing of what you know? I can't imagine how that feels.

Ichabod

Ichabod: This water was free at the market.
Abbie: So was the arsenic that came with it.

Sleepy Hollow Quotes

Abbie: Who is he? When's the last time you saw him?
Ichabod: When I cut off his head.

Police Detective: Do you admit to cutting off his head, yes or no?
Ichabod: Nooo. First I shot him, then he rose back up. Cutting off his head seemed the next logical step.