Molly Taylor, Peter's high school crush asks the boys to help her teenaged son, Josh who is about to lose his scholarship to Columbia for writing an article about voter fraud in the school prom queen elections.

After being expelled from school, Josh and the boys find proof that the principal rigged the votes. Josh gets his scholarship back and Peter gets a date with Molly.

Ellen and Jared are asked to detail their personal relationship by HR. Peter convinces Jared to play it off as casual and Ellen is hurt because she wants more. 

A professional cello player leases space in the office for her school and ends up taking on a lawsuit with old friend, Infeld.