At a convenience store, Adam and Family run into Max's old baseball team which convinces him to rejoin the team.
Crosby and Katie meet with her obstetrician, which advices them to start trying to have a baby due to her elevated hormone levels and age.
At Max's baseball game, it is apparent that the teammates are not allowing him to properly participate in the game. They were told to just let Max stand there. So, Drew and Adam help Max practice playing baseball.
Sarah finds out her daughter has copied her English paper, from when she was in school. She goes to meet with Amber's teacher, Mr. Sears, to tell him, but chickens out.
Julia gives Sydney a pep talk about being the princess at her play dates. She wants her daughter to be more assertive, which she is not.
Crosby goes to ask Jasmine for a paternity test for Jabbar, which turns out to be a big mistake. Jasmine gets upset and cancels Jabbar and Crosby’s scheduled time together.
Crosby tells Katie he is a father. She is furious that he has been sneaking around, hiding Jabbar from her.
Adam tells Sarah that it was Drew that allowed him to spend time with Max at the ballpark, almost like Max did not have a “situation”.
Joel and Julia break into the local swimming pool. She is actually doing something reckless.
Mr. Sear's goes to Sarah's bar for a drink. He tells her that Amber admitted to copying her mother’s paper. They end up flirting with each other.
Max catches a ball at his game! Score! The team goes wild.
The episode ends with Adam playing baseball with Drew and Max.